3 ms·
This is perhaps too soon, but I had read of asteroid mining a few weeks back. Do asteroids harbor these rare earths? The mining process seems pretty messy. I wo
by pm90 15y ago
This is perhaps too soon, but I had read of asteroid mining a few weeks back. Do asteroids harbor these rare earths?
The mining process seems pretty messy. I wonder if we could get minerals that way, there would be no need to do more damage to our environment.
- ars 15y agoIt'll be a decade or more before asteroid mining goes anywhere. Probably decades even. And mining this is not any messier than mining anything else.
- defrost 15y agoNot all mining is the same. Copper / Gold mines tend to be extraction of a concentrated deposit by either open pit or tunnel, while there are exceptions they tend to be limited in surface area affected. Mineral sands mining for rare earths is often akin to strip mining for large broad area coal seams - very large areas are turned over just to access a thin layer - where mineral sands occur beneath old growth forest it's often the case that the entire forest would have to be removed, as opposed to a gold mine that might simply tunnel beneath. Other techniques of note include uranium leach mines where a well head pumps fluid underground and other well heads extract dissolved salts, this leads to relatively small amounts of surface disturbance, and (for the hell of it) marine based alluvial diamond dredging - performed by barges across deposits from current or ancient river mouths. Again, not a lot of surface disruption. The extraction of a billion dollar lead/zinc deposit two thirds of the way up a mountain in Greenland will be very different to any usual rare earth extraction. Greenland Deposit :: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BvUol1aS8UA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BvUol1aS8UA
- 46Bit 15y agoIn the long term we can hope for this. But simple logistics say it'll be decades at least before we on Earth will possible see benefit. Potentially only when the upper crust's resources start to draw thin will it really kick in, based on what I reckon about the prices of returning materials in bulk.
- loverobots 15y agoEverything is pretty much a tradeoff. Sucks to be near the mine but those minerals probably improve tech so much that eventually the environment is x times better off in a global scale.
- gurkendoktor 15y agoI was curious if Rare Earths are really useful for the environment or mostly used in short-lived gadgets like MP3 players. For anyone as clueless about the uses of Rare Earths as me, I liked the diagrams in this PDF. http://www.oeko.de/oekodoc/1111/2011-002-en.pdf http://www.oeko.de/oekodoc/1111/2011-002-en.pdf
- toemetoch 15y agoThey play a role as trace elements. A lot of these elements are blocking in nature: other parts of the organism's metabolism are a function of the availability of trace elements. As an example, Molybdenum was found to put a ceiling on CO2 uptake in certain Orchidaceae. So if you run an orchid nursery and want to reduce your IV-to-flower time by providing more CO2 you need to also provide adequate amounts of trace elements. You could compare it to adding Iodium to table salt in order to keep the population's fertility high.
- pm90 15y agoI'm not sure that this comparison really answers anything about the parents question. In the case of organisms, these elements are needed for the organism to survive; not to make it more efficient/compact.
- toemetoch 15y agoMost of the cost & risk of space exploration goes into the short trip from earth's surface to orbit. Getting free from surface is such a major factor that it actually makes sense to move launch to a location near the equator. Once you have extraction and processing in space, volume and mass no longer play a role in what you can do up there. That's where asteroid mining has potential: provide an infrastructure that mines and processes resources in situ. I don't think one can justify the cost of mining it in orbit and then bring it back to earth.