3 ms·
> It’s central to open source that licenses can’t be revoked That…doesn’t change the underlying law. > if they could, then accepting contributions from extern
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> It’s central to open source that licenses can’t be revoked
That…doesn’t change the underlying law.
> if they could, then accepting contributions from external developers would be a hazard
Accepting code from external developers under a gratuitous license is a hazard (given promissory estoppel, probably a fairly limited one, but still something of a hazard); that is one of the reasons that some projects, even if they offer code in a way which is likely a gratuitous license, require individual license contracts before incorporating third-party code.
(Of course, there is still a hazard – the third party offering code might misrepresent their ownership of it, or despite copyright ownership might have violated a software patent, or… mitigating all hazards isn’t possible and individual projects decide their own risk tolerance.)
- nextaccountic 3y ago> gratuitous license What does this mean? Also.. do you have any references?
- cassianoleal 3y ago> What does this mean? I'm wondering the same. Perhaps something got lost in a double-translation? i.e. free -> <something in another language> -> gratuitous
- dllthomas 3y agoIIUC it means a license that's granted without the consideration that would usually be required for a contract. I think that's approximately what'd be meant by a "free license" in ordinary English, with no extra connection to "Free Software". The references I'm finding are about physical property, though.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> What does this mean? A license that is not part of a contract (usually, because of the absence of mutual consideration.)