2 ms·
So you think a central planner is a fairy tale but a perfect government isn't? The reason why communism fails is the same why the market fails, because humans
by croes 3y ago
So you think a central planner is a fairy tale but a perfect government isn't?
The reason why communism fails is the same why the market fails, because humans aren't perfect.
By your logic a crime is never to blame on the perpetrator only on the government.
Do you know who also shifts responsibility like that?
Serial killers!
"I did it because you didn't stop me."
If you recognize the product you are selling hurts or kills people and your first response is, as long as it is legal I don't care, then the failure doesn't lie in the government, the failure is you.
BTW there is no market, there are only people and people are responsible for what they are doing
- alchemist1e9 3y agoI stand corrected it’s the people who do it are the responsible party I do agree. However in markets those transactions are voluntary. In central planning they are involuntary. When the transaction harms the buyer the reason that happens is the seller has deceived them and is certainly the underlying guilty party, that I agree. I agree perfect governments are also a fairy tale. All that said you don’t seem to recognize the heroic role of incentives and profits and markets in finding usefulness. That’s what triggers me. When people voluntarily pay for something it’s because they find it useful. What you appear to claim is that governments need to be the arbiter of usefulness since the people cannot be trusted. That is a seriously dystopian approach.