4 ms·
> the undercover staff interviews seemed pretty damning This is the least credible possible evidence, because shows like that have a long history of doing sele
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> the undercover staff interviews seemed pretty damning
This is the least credible possible evidence, because shows like that have a long history of doing selective editing or purposely taking things out of context.
Sometimes they don't have to because what they're reporting is real, but you can't tell that one way or the other just by watching the segment.
- Zetaphor 3y agoI was unaware of these accusations, do you have have any supporting information?
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThey're comedy shows. They send someone to record an hour-long interview but the whole segment is 5 minutes long and the clip they air is only a few seconds. Selective editing is built into the format, they don't spend the airtime to run the full interview and their purpose is to choose the short clip which has the most comedy value or makes the target look bad.
- hef19898 3y agoThere was not a single interview done by LWTN for that segment, they took those from other sources. And the segment was pretty good actually, covered all the major points and didn't have any major errors. Actually, it is light years ahead of what other news outlets reported. Surey it is not on the same level as an audit report, but that is not its purpose. It is much closer to a comprehensive executive summary of an incident report than anything I have ever seen in media elsewher. Re: selection of statements, the reports in Fukushima and Cherbobyl do the same. The point is to showcase the underlying issues with concrete examples and statements. Nothing wrong with that per-se. And in th LWTN segment, it was not done in bad faith, it is bot FOX news after all.
- BuckYeah 3y agoWell put. Most skeptics these days are borderline conspiracists when it comes to delivering their opinions. The person above only needed to say, “trust but verify comedic claims” but instead they went down the all too common road of dogwhistling to other “skeptics.” I’m confident that quite a lot of John Oliver’s claims are verifiable (I have spent a lot of time doing my own research on the claims after watching the show). Not saying I’m a brilliant investigator but wanted to offer an opposing opinion. Blatantly sowing distrust is exactly the kind of behavior a true skeptic hopes to avoid.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> It is much closer to a comprehensive executive summary of an incident report than anything I have ever seen in media elsewher. This is the danger in it. They pick someone they don't like and basically do a hit piece. Now sometimes the target is actually bad and deserving of the criticism, and then if you try to get the real story, the real story is that the target is actually bad and deserving of the criticism. But then they'll run a segment in the same style where the target is just someone from the outgroup of the show's target audience.
- hef19898 3y ago[flagged]
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago[flagged]
- hef19898 3y agoAs I said, their reporting has been scrutinzed a lot. Including a multi-million dollar defamition suite brought by this coal magnate. Guess what, the show didn't get it wrong. You don'z have to like the humor or bias of the show. Factually so, so far, their reporting was always as correct as possible at the time of filming. Or do you have proof otherwise, retractions they did, law suites they lost, that kind of stuff?
- Lendal 3y agoThey do that because nobody wants to look at hundreds of dead bodies or talk to grieving widows, or search through rubble for broken airplane parts or data recorders. That's not so funny. Just because comedy shows focus on entertainment value doesn't mean there's no evidence. They have a different focus from investigators or courts, but in democratic countries, the funds to run investigations come from politicians and public outcry, and that comes from the people actually giving a sh*t about it. So they do perform a function.
- loktarogar 3y ago"Shows like that" or this show in particular?
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoShows using the format where they do an interview and then selectively air parts of it rather than the whole thing. In general The Daily Show and its offspring -- not the interviews that happen in front of the audience in the studio, the ones for the pre-recorded segments.
- loktarogar 3y agoHave you seen this show at all? It generally dedicates the bulk of its episode to a single story and goes in depth. Not saying this can't be happening, and there's always going to be stuff left out in even a 30 minute timeframe, but it tries to educate on the "complete picture" with nuanced points on a single issue per ep
- Voultapher 3y agoWith going in depth you mean: 1. Continuously make fun of superficial attributes and mannerisms 2. Selectively present a biased narrative without opposition 3. Push said narrative with ad hominem attacks and jokes about someones' appearance Even when I agree with the narrative, the mechanisms by which the audience is persuaded feels quite disingenuous to me. Look at the episodes he did about Trump in 2016, the host spends half the time making fun of small hands, when you could fill hours with Trump's fascism. My perspective is based on episodes I watched in 2016. The small bits I've seen from him and other similar formats since then suggest it is still this way.
- hef19898 3y agoIt is a comedy show after all. One that tackles very serious subjects in ahumerous way. Doesn make the reporting wrong. And, this show in particular, gets the fact right almost all of the time. And it provided more context and details on the whole Boeing saga than any other news source I have seen or read so far since the door plug blew out. Heck, going back to the 737 Max crashes I would be hard pushed to find main stream media reporting that was, factually and regarding context, better.
- hef19898 3y agoThe recorded comments were from the 787 days, and LWTN didn't produce those recordings themselves.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThat doesn't really tell you anything. The way the format works is they take a large amount of material and pare it down to whatever they can find to make the target look stupid or nefarious. It works the same whether they were holding the camera or not. Also: > Sometimes they don't have to because what they're reporting is real, but you can't tell that one way or the other just by watching the segment.
- hef19898 3y agoAs someone who read the official reports on the B737 MAX and the 787 battery fires and who is from the industry, I can tell you that your accusations are completely unfounded in reality. By the way, LWTN was not once found to have wrong reporting on any of their subjects. Last party to pull them to court over it was this cial guy. And it was found that the reporting was factually correct. Not like, say, Fox News with its usual defwnc ein court that boils down to "who in his right mind would take us for a serious news outlet employing journalists".
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> As someone who read the official reports on the B737 MAX and the 787 battery fires and who is from the industry, I can tell you that your accusations are completely unfounded in reality. You're defending this particular story when I never claimed it was necessarily false. > By the way, LWTN was not once found to have wrong reporting on any of their subjects. Last party to pull them to court over it was this cial guy. And it was found that the reporting was factually correct. That is how "out of context" works. They don't affirmatively lie, they lie through omission. They have lawyers who know how defamation laws work.
- hef19898 3y ago
- inferiorhuman 3y agoSo how about the Seattle Times? https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boeing-congressional-lobbyist-tries-to-discredit-ntsb-testimony/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boein... Rather than fix their airplanes Boeing is trying to discredit the NTSB.
- ShamelessC 3y ago[flagged]
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoI made a general comment about the format and then all of the people who remove any nuance (i.e. can't distinguish between a criticism of the format and a criticism of the story) started posting replies defending the story even though the possibility of the story being accurate was explicitly admitted in the original comment.
- whoknowsidont 3y ago>This is the least credible possible evidence How about the U.S. government opening a criminal inquiry that corroborates what they were reporting?
- thaumasiotes 3y agoThat's not evidence at all; there was going to be an investigation no matter what. That said, I was greatly amused by this in the article: > “In an event like this, it’s normal for the D.O.J. to be conducting an investigation,” Alaska Airlines said in a statement. “We are fully cooperating and do not believe we are a target of the investigation.” > Boeing had no comment.
- leereeves 3y agoA criminal inquiry that concluded with only a $500k fine, because: > "We were unable to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the company's actions caused the mine collapse," said David Barlow, the U.S. Attorney for Utah. https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2012/03/09/148319836/mining-company-pleads-guilty-for-2007-utah-mine-disaster https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2012/03/09/148319836...
- int_19h 3y ago"Beyond a reasonable doubt" is a very high bar to match. Certainly way higher than would be expected of even the most respectable newspaper, for example.
- leereeves 3y agoIt's a reasonable bar to ask for before you start demonizing someone in front of millions of people. But let's be honest, Oliver didn't hate Murray because of the mine disaster, he hated Murray for mining coal. The mine disaster (responsibility for which wasn't even proven) was all LWT could dig up. And the audience will pretty much hate anyone Oliver tells them to hate. That's why they watch - to enjoy their Two Minutes Hate.