4 ms·
Argentina inflation seen cooling as Milei austerity tempers food prices
- ashconnor 3y agoMilei's policies are going to stall once poverty rises further. https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/argentinas-barrios-rising-poverty-stalks-mileis-austerity-drive-2024-03-05/ https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/argentinas-barrios-ri... To me this is an incredibly complicated economic problem.
- sandspar 3y agoI have the image of a severely malfunctioning engine, a group of people gathered around trying to fix it. Someone finally gets tired of the whole thing and begins beating at it with a hammer. The other guys shrug. Maybe that'll work.
- zeroCalories 3y agoThe analogy is exactly the opposite. Argentina has been getting beat by idiotic populist policy forever. Milei is taking a hands-off approach, which will let the economic fiction disappear. Yes, that will send many people into poverty, but the reality is that Argentina is a poor country and cannot provide high standards if living for everyone.
- leidenfrost 3y ago1) Many times qe had "liberal" governments trying to fix it: Alfonsin, De La Rua, Macri. Even the de facto dictatorship tried to open up the economy. All of them failed. 2) Argentina is not poor. It's a rich country and their agriculture industry is one of the best in the world. However, it's an industry with very little trickle down dynamics, compared to other fields like electronics or the service industry. You don't need that many educated people to export crude oil and unprocessed goods to the world. A "pure" agricultural Argentina would be very financially stable, at the cost of having horribly high levels of inequality, with a (from my POV) inhuman quality of life for the average person. And no country in the world would favor that.
- zeroCalories 3y ago1) And they continually get undermined by populists, just as is happening here. 2) Argentina has the GDP of a third world country. It is poor. You don't need natural resources to be a wealthy country, you need efficient industry. You will never get that as long as Argentina continues its populist policies. I'm not even against government spending, but the spending needs to be done tactically, like east Asian countries, not for "muh workers".
- leidenfrost 3y ago> Yes, that will send many people into poverty, but the reality is that Argentina is a poor country and cannot provide high standards if living for everyone. The point of any talk about economics is to create prosperous nations and long lasting well being for the people. Not to make a number look good on paper. If you think that most people should live terrible lives just to have low rates of inflation, you just failed economics.
- zeroCalories 3y agoYou will never get a prosperous nation for everyone if you have a wasteful crab bucket economy. Yes, some people will need to be cut off. Hopefully they will find a more productive way to live, or die.
- aerhardt 3y agoMilei has a singular focus on curbing hyperinflation, an objective no other politician in recent Argentine history has shown any interest in, and he's using a multi-pronged approach to do so. Some of his policies have been fairly sophisticated, like removing the insanely complex network of quasi-monetary instruments that gave the government multiple ways to print money (ex: LELIQS - my head still hurts trying to understand that tire fire system), others are by-the-book inflation-curbing methods, but all in all more sophisticated than just hitting things with a hammer. Probably curbing inflation won't be enough, and maybe he will fail in doing so, but I think it's wrong to suggest his government is merely trying to brute-force the solution.
- sandspar 3y agoThanks for informing me. His public persona is "hammer guy" but perhaps that's more for the cameras.
- leidenfrost 3y agoArgentina hss a harsh reality: if it opens up its market and gets dedicated to work on the most profitable industry, you're basically dooming more than half of its population to starvation and poverty. There's a lot of sunken cost, millions of dollars and years of long running companies from an industry founded thanks to proteccionist policies. Those companies don't generate whealth directly, but it does sustain domestic commerce, create jobs and give fluidity to the internal economy
- aerhardt 3y agoThe article says that the main cause of poverty is the rising of prices, which is precisely Milei's obsession. There is no indication in the article as to how his policies are going to stall, or am I missing something? I'd agree nevertheless that if he fails to bring prices under control, his government is going to be considered an utter failure.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> The article says that the main cause of poverty is the rising of prices, which is precisely Milei’s obsession. No, the article says nothing of the kind. The only thing it says even roughly directly about poverty (though using slightly different words) is that the mechanism by which Milei’s policies are reining in prices is by causing poverty: “…as new libertarian President Javier Milei’s austerity drive squeezes shoppers, helping rein in grocery price rises.”
- leidenfrost 3y agoYes, but at what cost. The cost of living for food and general groceries has gone up to 700%. Some prices are even the same as those from Spain. However, the minimal wage there is of €1050 p/month, while our minimal wage is around U$S200. When will prices drop, we don't know. However, there's little incentive to do so. Argentina does one thing right and that is exporting good quality food. If it doesn't get bought internally, it will get exported instead of lowering prices.
- otherme123 3y agoThat contradicts frontally with this quote from the article: > "Food and beverage prices... rose significantly below the average: 11% in February," said consulting firm C&T Fixing hiperinflation is never easy. It's like going on a diet: it's hard to do, but nobody knows a better alternative. And politicians always have the easy binge at hand to solve any problem: printing money. Being responsible is hard at all times, and the only visible reward you get is the statu quo. But by printing money you get an easy economic spike that will soar your popularity.
- leidenfrost 3y agoThat's after the sudden surge a few months ago. The problem the diet analogy is that people neither die nor sink into poverty after a few months of reduced caloric intake. It's not just "unpleasant", long running companies die, people on the ends of the spectrum fall into starvation. You don't easily recover from that. Suffocating the private sector is not a long term policy. It's shooting yourself in the foot.
- otherme123 3y agoAs I said, that's to blame on the high inflation, not on trying to fix it. Traditionally hyperinflations also cause poverty. Take for example Venezuela or Zimbabwe, two of the worse cases in the last couple of decades. It's not like they ride the hyperinflation with a happy smile and business thriving. Argentina was drunk, and Milei decided to stop drinking. Hangover will have to come anyways, and everybody knows it. You cannot blame the headache on stopping drinking, and the solution is keep drinking for a while. That's not how hyperinflation works, we have had plenty of cases. It's exponentially worse.
- drak0n1c 3y agoRental prices have also dropped as the rental supply doubled immediately post-deregulation. https://voz.us/the-market-triumphs-milei-manages-to-improve-rent-prices-with-deregulatory-measures/?lang=en https://voz.us/the-market-triumphs-milei-manages-to-improve-... Hopefully the new crackdown on crime will also help temper inflation. My Argentinian colleague was kidnapped on the street and taken to his Buenos Aires apartment where he was robbed of a big chunk of his savings back in 2015/2016. If organized crime has been operating like that the threat and fear must put a damper on everyone's productivity.
- whitepoplar 3y agoYikes, can you say more about the circumstances surrounding your colleague's kidnapping? I'd love to visit BA sometime soon but stories like this give me pause.
- drak0n1c 3y agoHe didn't seem hurt from it physically, just mentally messed up from it. He's an iOS dev so maybe he had a Macbook out. Don't know the neighborhood. I've heard that the city limits can be risky, there is a big policy demarcation between "Buenos Aires autonomous district" and the surrounding Buenos Aires Province. I wouldn't be too discouraged from going though as a foreigner not carrying much, and the crime rate has reduced since then (robberies down 20% from 2016-2022). https://www.courthousenews.com/argentines-feeling-unsafe-despite-declining-official-crime-rates/ https://www.courthousenews.com/argentines-feeling-unsafe-des...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]