5 ms·
I feel like these days (especially given the recent focus on side channel attacks) it is basically a given that adding uniform noise to something that leaks dat
by saagarjha 3y ago
I feel like these days (especially given the recent focus on side channel attacks) it is basically a given that adding uniform noise to something that leaks data does not work, because you can always take more samples and remove the noise. Why did Safari add this? I understand that needing more samples is definitely an annoyance to fingerprinting efforts, but as this post shows it's basically always surmountable in some form or the other.
- lapcat 3y ago> Why did Safari add this? A lot of Apple's "privacy" features nowadays are marketing. It's privacy theater. What matters is whether they can tell a plausible story to the public, not whether is technically effective.
- shuckles 3y agoIs iCloud Private Relay theatre? 3rd party cookie blocking? What specific features do you allege exist just to mislead the general public?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lapcat 3y ago> Is iCloud Private Relay theatre? https://fingerprint.com/blog/ios15-icloud-private-relay-vulnerability/ https://fingerprint.com/blog/ios15-icloud-private-relay-vuln... > 3rd party cookie blocking? It's very funny that you should ask this question in response to an article about fingerprinting without cookies. But yes, there are various workaround to use 1st party cookies or other storage to take the place of 3rd party cookies. Perhaps the worst is the Safari "Privacy Report", which has always been misleading: https://www.simoahava.com/privacy/intelligent-tracking-prevention-ios-14-ipados-14-safari-14/ https://www.simoahava.com/privacy/intelligent-tracking-preve...
- fh9302 3y agoDo you have something more recent than a leak from over 2 years ago that has long been fixed? I'm curious why iCloud Private Relay is theatre at the moment.
- lapcat 3y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> It was advertised as being private, but it wasn't Signal had a bug once. Herego, it’s a scam?
- lapcat 3y ago> Signal had a bug once. Are you referring to this? https://www.forbes.com/sites/daveywinder/2019/10/05/signal-messenger-eavesdropping-exploit-confirmedwhat-you-need-to-know/?sh=d3fe2487dc11 https://www.forbes.com/sites/daveywinder/2019/10/05/signal-m... It was a bad bug in the Android client, to be sure, but it didn't bypass Signal encryption.
- shuckles 3y agoAnd a VPN leaks a lot of information about your network activity to the operator, so by your standard it is privacy theater. Do you see why you’re coming across as having inconsistent standards and thereby perhaps an axe to grind? iCloud Private Relay is used for all network activity from Safari which does not seem like a “limited amount of activity.”
- lapcat 3y ago> And a VPN leaks a lot of information about your network activity to the operator, so by your standard it is privacy theater. A VPN isn't designed to keep your IP address hidden from the operator. iCloud Private Relay doesn't hide your IP address from Apple either. That's not the point, and everyone knows this in advance. The point is to keep your IP address hidden from the request destination servers.
- fsflover 3y agohttps://sneak.berlin/20231005/apple-operating-system-surveillance/ https://sneak.berlin/20231005/apple-operating-system-surveil...
- simondotau 3y agoThat's an wild accusation to make without citations. It doesn't even apply in this instance, since Apple's work on fingerprint resistance still results in real privacy improvements even when later shown to be imperfect. It means Apple has to improve what they've already done, not that what they've done so far is mere "marketing" or "theatre".
- lapcat 3y ago> That's an wild accusation to make without citations. Shall I cite my list of CVE? Or perhaps it would be more interesting to cite my list of unfixed 0days. > It doesn't even apply in this instance, since Apple's work on fingerprint resistance still results in real privacy improvements even when later shown to be imperfect. It means Apple has to improve what they've already done, not that what they've done so far is mere "marketing" or "theatre". What does it say about Apple engineering that that they keep shipping features with very obvious and/or predictable flaws?
- jessekv 3y agoI haven't seen marketing related to audio fingerprinting protection. Maybe Hanlon's applies here. As for your point about the pattern of vulnerabilities: I'd attribute this to being closed source. They keep shipping security features with limited auditing, and only discover flaws in production.
- lapcat 3y ago> I haven't seen marketing related to audio fingerprinting protection. Apple announces powerful new privacy and security features: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2023/06/apple-announces-powerful-new-privacy-and-security-features/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2023/06/apple-announces-power... WebKit Features in Safari 17.0: https://webkit.org/blog/14445/webkit-features-in-safari-17-0/ https://webkit.org/blog/14445/webkit-features-in-safari-17-0... In general, Apple is trying to market itself as the privacy company. "What happens on iPhone stays on iPhone", yadda yadda. > Maybe Hanlon's applies here. I think my view is in alignment with Hanlon's razor. I don't think it's necessarily malicious deception. Rather, Apple has a habit of shipping the laziest implementations and slapping a "privacy" label on them, but the public doesn't know that these are lazy half-measures. > As for your point about the pattern of vulnerabilities: I'd attribute this to being closed source. WebKit is open source. > They keep shipping security features with limited auditing, and only discover flaws in production. I don't think this is a closed/open source issue. It's just bad engineering.