3 ms·

We were quite surprised to learn recently from an unrelated HN article that there is now an essential tremor cure through ultrasonic brain surgery. FDA approved

We were quite surprised to learn recently from an unrelated HN article that there is now an essential tremor cure through ultrasonic brain surgery. FDA approved 2016 and now available in various countries. https://www.fusfoundation.org/diseases-and-conditions/essential-tremor/ https://www.fusfoundation.org/diseases-and-conditions/essent...

southernplaces7 3y ago
The word cure that you use seems pretty certain, and even your link doesn't use it to describe how the treatment affects the condition. Just curious, what made you say that it's curative? Do you know of people who've been cured by this therapy?
- throwaway10987 3y ago
  My dad suffered terrible ET from age 40 on. At 65 he became terribly depressed and isolated as he couldn't do basic things like write or hold a fork. Fearing for his wellbeing I researched anything I could get my hands on and called doctors around the world. Finally found a research hospital in S Korea and a clinic in Florida willing to meet him. In 2018 they did the non-invasive surgery in SK and the ET stopped completely in his dominant hand and has been good since.
- stubish 3y ago
  It seems a cure rather than a treatment. If the correct neurons can be found via MRI and the condition deemed suitable for treatment, the neurons get destroyed and I think no ongoing medication or repeat treatments are required. I believe they treat one limb at a time if you have the condition in both hands. All this is my initial impressions because we only learned of this recently and my relative won't be able to chase this up until later this year. I have second hand feedback about people who have undergone the treatment successfully in Australia. I don't actually know anyone outside of my family with the condition at all, so no first hand. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39551457 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39551457 was the HN article where I picked it up. Buried in the middle of the video is a minute or so talking about earlier successes with ultrasound, the essential tremor treatment. HN commenters indicate successful treatments.
  - throwaway10987 3y ago
    yes, I can confirm the doctor told us only one limb can be targeted so we picked his dominant arm.
    - southernplaces7 3y ago
      Thanks for your earlier reply. I was honestly curious about your reasoning for the way you described it, and especially these days in which many things are branded as cures despite not being shown as such by something reliable. You mention that only one limb could be targeted. Did they explain that this applied to one limb at a time or that it applied to only one limb period? The other reply states both, but maybe that's because of differences in procedure or clinic.
      - throwaway10987 3y ago
        We were told one limb, period. I can get you more info if you need, email me direct at: hnews.crunching363 at passmail.net
        southernplaces7 3y ago
        Sincerely Thank you, and I will through my Protonmail address.

southernplaces7 3y ago

The word cure that you use seems pretty certain, and even your link doesn't use it to describe how the treatment affects the condition. Just curious, what made you say that it's curative? Do you know of people who've been cured by this therapy?

throwaway10987 3y ago
My dad suffered terrible ET from age 40 on. At 65 he became terribly depressed and isolated as he couldn't do basic things like write or hold a fork. Fearing for his wellbeing I researched anything I could get my hands on and called doctors around the world. Finally found a research hospital in S Korea and a clinic in Florida willing to meet him. In 2018 they did the non-invasive surgery in SK and the ET stopped completely in his dominant hand and has been good since.
stubish 3y ago
It seems a cure rather than a treatment. If the correct neurons can be found via MRI and the condition deemed suitable for treatment, the neurons get destroyed and I think no ongoing medication or repeat treatments are required. I believe they treat one limb at a time if you have the condition in both hands. All this is my initial impressions because we only learned of this recently and my relative won't be able to chase this up until later this year. I have second hand feedback about people who have undergone the treatment successfully in Australia. I don't actually know anyone outside of my family with the condition at all, so no first hand. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39551457 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39551457 was the HN article where I picked it up. Buried in the middle of the video is a minute or so talking about earlier successes with ultrasound, the essential tremor treatment. HN commenters indicate successful treatments.
- throwaway10987 3y ago
  yes, I can confirm the doctor told us only one limb can be targeted so we picked his dominant arm.
  - southernplaces7 3y ago
    Thanks for your earlier reply. I was honestly curious about your reasoning for the way you described it, and especially these days in which many things are branded as cures despite not being shown as such by something reliable. You mention that only one limb could be targeted. Did they explain that this applied to one limb at a time or that it applied to only one limb period? The other reply states both, but maybe that's because of differences in procedure or clinic.
    - throwaway10987 3y ago
      We were told one limb, period. I can get you more info if you need, email me direct at: hnews.crunching363 at passmail.net
      - southernplaces7 3y ago
        Sincerely Thank you, and I will through my Protonmail address.