3 ms·
> Is Dune (as a series) really an endorsement of consequentialism? God Emperor of Dune consists largely of a lengthy and emphatic in-universe endorsement of a
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Is Dune (as a series) really an endorsement of consequentialism?
God Emperor of Dune consists largely of a lengthy and emphatic in-universe endorsement of a kind of consequentialism by the eponymous character.
While I think that it is a naive view to do so, its pretty easy to see how a reader might take it as an endorsement of that view by the author.
(OTOH, I think prescience, as featured in the series, really also challenges the idea of deontology and consequentialism as even being different in substance rather than different framings of the same considerations; the idea of a polar divide is, even without it, pretty clearly somewhat artificial – real deontological frameworks tend to incorporate context including known, intended, and reasonably foreseeable consequences in their understanding of what is part of the nature of the act itself, while any real consequentialist framework most adopt some rules as to which a priori outcomes that are viewed as positive or negative, and so the two somewhat blend; when all, or nearly all, outcomes become foreseeable…)