4 ms·
Basically, this article invents an elaborate fantasy whose primary factual anchor is Tolkien writing that he very much didn’t like Dune with no further elaborat
by dragonwriter 3y ago
Basically, this article invents an elaborate fantasy whose primary factual anchor is Tolkien writing that he very much didn’t like Dune with no further elaboration. That Tolkien was of a deontological philosophical bent and that this is reflected in his writings is a fairly reasonable statement. That Herbert was a consequentialist might be (based on other things), but that this was clearly indicated in, much less a focal message of, Dune, either the novel or the broader series, is, I feel, a quite strained reading, and seems to come from a place of excessive desire to read a simplistic moral argument into Dune.
While Mauldin notes that Herbert, “saw religion as an inherently mutable, utilitarian institution”, he seems to have failed to realize the centrality of mutability of perceived religious and moral truth, especially as it comes with distance from the facts on the ground, in Herbert’s writing, and that Dune (in the small or large sense) isn’t a fable with a pat moral lesson. I think its usually a mistake to argue that any but the most simplistic fiction is “about” some message that can fit on a fortune cookie, but I think it is less inaccurate to say that Dune is a challenge to simplistic narratives about the present, past, and morality (whether framed in consequentialist or deontological terms) than it is about any thesis as to what the correct framing of morality is.
Mauldin points out the Golden Path of God Emperor of Dune, but I think he mistakes the eponymous character’s voice for the authorial voice. Leto II Atreides clearly sees his vision of the future and what is necessary to save humanity as warranting any horrors done in its name, but is Herbert saying that? Or is Herbert framing it in a way that the reader while recoil at it even framed with Leto II’s prescience, and from that question acts that seem on their own repugnant done with mere human confidence, and not science fiction prescience, of their distant consequences?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- scyzoryk_xyz 3y agoi.e. sometimes writers write because they like to write. It can be a bit much sometimes to be projecting so much onto them. Which is a shame because the interpretations are interesting - would work better as personal subjective opinion.