3 ms·
Any devs here create these types of things? Or other systems that make it hard to repair devices? Why do you do it? Do you see this as enshitification? Just ne
by godelski 3y ago
Any devs here create these types of things? Or other systems that make it hard to repair devices?
Why do you do it? Do you see this as enshitification? Just need to pay the bills? (can't find a different job?) Think "someone else will do it if I don't?" (and don't think they'll have to pay more for the other person or that the other person will be of lesser quality or people turning down the jobs/not applying puts pressure on them?)
I really am curious. FWIW, you can create an anonymous account if you want to truthfully answer these questions. HN just needs an email address and you can use disposable ones or masks. I really do want honest answers.
Note: I __DO NOT__ want answers form others who are just making assumptions about what people creating these things actually do or think. Point is to actually not understand, not "make an ass out of you and me". But if you worked on some other similar program or something like the Sony Playstation stuff, I am happy to have your comment. I just want to keep the theme relevant and not muddied with emotional conjecture that's such a common response to these questions. I appreciate that the people with conjectures want to help, but let's wait and hear responses before we jump to conclusions.
- duxup 3y agoI don't make that stuff, I'm not making any assumptions. But considering the state of discussion on the internet, I wonder how many takers you might get. Do / say something unpopular and you're just signing up for abuse online, heck even if you don't do anything. HN is better places than most but recently (not on HN) I got down-voted in a discussion where I said I didn't mind the neighbor kids running through my yard, and some folks stopped to e-yell at me how terrible it is ... I'm more riffing off of a "Can we even have these conversations?" kinda question here, but I am interested if anyone would take you up on your offer if only because of the lay of the internet land.
- BadHumans 3y agoWell, now I wanna know what you mean by "e-yell." If you say you don't mind and someone replies with dissension saying you should mind, is that not having the conversation? Not the point at all but I also think you should mind :P
- duxup 3y agoE-yell is a sort of sarcastic term I use when folks show up and the intensity of response seems out of place.
- godelski 3y ago> But considering the state of discussion on the internet, Yeah it is a tough problem. I specifically gave the advice of how to be anonymous in case someone was worried about that. That way at least they wouldn't be concerned with defacing their profile or other type of image. But I suspect that would bias it towards people who feel morally uncertain or are questioning their own actions. And I fully agree. We need to stop being reactionary. It doesn't solve problems, it creates them. We all got egos here and to address this I typically go after the ego (including to myself). If we're so smart and rational then we can promote smart and rational discussions right? I don't think many realize that they are often being used as pawns in a game of informational warfare. That our emotions play into the hands of others. Because they are quite easy to exploit, especially when we believe we are difficult to exploit (there's that ego again :) But I am trying to push for this type of behavior. Given your concern, I'd encourage you to take an active approach in this as well. I downvote any lazy comment I see (even if I agree with it, or even if it makes me laugh) in an effort to actively push up more meaningful comments. I also will try to openly question the interpretation of someone's comment as a means to quench any flames (an example is here[0] but clearly ineffective. Can be hit or miss). On the other hand, I will often upvote comments I disagree with if they are promoting discussions or if the replies to them are valuable. What I often see is a reply be great and highly informative but then because people agree with the reply they downvote the parent but this then pushes down the entire conversation. I'm not sure how to address this mechanism but this feels like the best I can do given the tools at hand. I do fully believe we need to have these types of questions. Liberal or conservative, enabling these discussions is perfectly in line with your political beliefs, and in fact I would say is critical to it. We shouldn't be afraid of asking questions and we should be able to ask things in good faith (which that part is key). I think you're right about the environment and so this is why I'm trying to be the environment I want to see and try to encourage others to do the same. One thing I personally find hard is that it is easy to react to someone who reacts in bad faith to you. But I try to apologize when I recognize it. I think this is an important habit to build. The other is to be explicit about gratitude because I think part of the issue is that we let things that are good or that we're grateful for go unsaid. It makes sense, but clearly puts a bias on our perception. It also puts bias on incentives for people doing the right thing. Like when a company that has been doing bad things in the past does something good for once you can totally say "This is great! I don't condone x,y,z but I hope they continue to push towards being not evil" or whatever. There needs to be positive reinforcement signals too. If I've learned anything in my own little domain that I'm an expert in it is that there's rabbit holes everywhere and nuances rule the domain. So I try to keep that in mind when thinking about other domains. I don't always succeed, but my process is set up to have multiple chances to correct course (but I'm still an idiot emotional human lol) And of course, I'm open for suggestions about how to better cultivate an environment where we can have better discussions. If you have any advice I'd love to hear it. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39644752 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39644752
- CptTightpants 3y agoI don't care for companies dictating what can and cannot be done with MY property. I may not agree with certain decisions the OEM made on how things operate, and I should be able to change them to fit my needs. If I physically destroy the device by whatever I do to it, then I don't expect warrantee service (but this should not be possible by changing the software alone, or it's a design flaw the OEM should be held accountable for). Otherwise, I should be able to customize my device to my needs and desires without losing coverage for a faulty device, just like we've been able to do to PCs for decades. Never mind the environmental concerns of being forced to trash a device because the OEM won't provide what's necessary to resuscitate it should something go wrong. Providing basic information and software necessary to do so is simply the right thing to do.
- godelski 3y agoI appreciate your passion, but I'm trying to understand the other side. Given your passion I hope you do too. Because I think we need to understand the other side if we want to argue our side. So let's wait for some responses and make sure we don't attack anyone that responds or discourage them. We need to understand why people make certain decisions if we're going to change things, not force people into our positions, especially by means of shame.
- charcircuit 3y ago>Why do you do it? Because I enjoy the process of making software. >Do you see this as enshitification? No, I see this as needing to make a trade off where the result ends up with one party gaining something and consumers losing something. >Just need to pay the bills? No, money is not a motivating factor. >can't find a different job? I have no reason to switch job, but finding a different job wouldn't be an issue. >Think "someone else will do it if I don't?" These companies are not masochists trying to exclusively hurt consumers. There are a lot of trade offs that happen between multiple different parties. A company is not going to be able to make the best possible product if in every single tradeoff they give priority to the consumers (you also can't make every single subgroup of consumers all happy with some things). Sure someone could execute on the tradeoff being made, but I don't need any kind of justification for me to stay at my job. I want to see all the relevant parties benefit from the existence of the product. If I disagree with a tradeoff being made I can raise that. What tradeoff to make is a hard decision that people don't always get right, sometimes they were missing available information and some information they may only be able to speculate on. In the future these tradeoffs can be reevaluated.
- godelski 3y agoThanks for the response. Do you think these trade-offs are actually meaningful? I can see how they might be useful in the short term, but at least to me they seem clearly poor strategy long term. It is unclear to me what exactly is gained by such actions. It is mentioned that preventing users from destroying their devices is a motivation, but I think this is such a limited set of users and I'm not sure letting more technical users bricking their devices is going to result in reduced sales. It does also result in others fixing your code for you if they can debug and inspect them. (So many times I just want to fix shit code but it's closed) It seems hackers and motivated actors are always able to get in anyways so I'm not sure what the real cost is. I think you might see things differently.
- charcircuit 3y ago>Do you think these trade-offs are actually meaningful? Yes, and it can be frustrating when your person want as a user may be different than what will be best for the most people. I do think there are a couple issues. The first is that reevaluating something, making a different tradeoff, and changing the product can be very expensive. Even if it's not be expensive alone, the opportunity cost may be higher and engineers could be working on something more impactful. The second issue is that the product will often target the needs of the majority of needs which means that the needs of power users may not be listened to very well. The solution to these issues are competition and extensibility. The work of making a version of the product for niche users can be done by a niche company and that can work out.