4 ms·
LK-99 is interesting because it really is like another example of cold fusion. And I don't mean what you probably infer from that. If you look into the way tha
by adastra22 3y ago
LK-99 is interesting because it really is like another example of cold fusion.
And I don't mean what you probably infer from that. If you look into the way that hydrogen adsorbs into a platinum lattice, and how phonon resonance modes can induce tremendous crushing forces on anything between two platinum atoms, cold fusion actually looks quite plausible. It's not like perpetual motion--there's a clear possible mechanism for it which is surprisingly fully compatible with the laws of physics as we understand them. That said, Pons and Fleischmann rushed publication on shoddy data, making a mockery of themselves and causing cold fusion to become an untouchable subject no one would go near a generation later due to perceived guilt by association.
The theory behind LK-99 is pretty solid. The linear structure of these apatite compounds create chains of conductive electron bands that in theory might have sufficient band gaps to enable superconductivity. If you could get atomic precision in the copper/lead alternating pattern that creates those stresses. However I fear any research into room-temperature linear superconductors will now be as taboo as cold fusion.
- worik 3y ago> That said, Pons and Fleischmann rushed publication on shoddy data, making a mockery of themselves and causing cold fusion to become an untouchable subject no one would go near a generation later Yes, they were shoddy But no, the field was swamped within weeks with people trying to replicate it. It has lost its luster, and become a parody, but that is because it was wrong It took a decade for the excitement to die down
- adastra22 3y agoPons and Fleischmann's experimental setup did not produce cold fusion. But some other variation or different catalyst material might. Yet effectively no one has carried on this work. LK-99, or at least the manufactured samples of it, is not a superconductor. But some other variation or different manufacturing technique might. Yet I predict no one is going to look very hard in the years to come.
- kergonath 3y ago> If you look into the way that hydrogen adsorbs into a platinum lattice, and how phonon resonance modes can induce tremendous crushing forces on anything between two platinum atoms, cold fusion actually looks quite plausible. No, it is not. These things are well understood. The behaviour of hydrogen in crystals is studied a lot. In metals because of issues with hydrogen embrittlement and fusion stuff, in some oxides for the storage of hydrogen for energy applications, and in material in general because proton irradiation is a common tool when studying them. All of this to say that this is not something that was never investigated. > It's not like perpetual motion--there's a clear possible mechanism for it which is surprisingly fully compatible with the laws of physics as we understand them. The orders of magnitude just do not match. The pressures involved is typically 1 GPa (usually less in metals, more in ceramics). That is far from enough to bring nuclei sufficiently close for fusion. There is a reason why nobody claims this, and it is not because we don’t look at the behaviour of hydrogen (or other light nuclei like deuterium, tritium, helium, or lithium for that matter). > The theory behind LK-99 is pretty solid. The linear structure of these apatite compounds create chains of conductive electron bands that in theory might have sufficient band gaps to enable superconductivity. Again, it is not. Some preliminary electronic structure calculations showed interesting features, but these features were no indication of superconducting behaviour, and indeed LK-99 is not a superconductor. There were plenty of people who tried to reproduce the results and it clearly showed that the initial paper was wrong. > If you could get atomic precision in the copper/lead alternating pattern that creates those stresses. Our understanding of what causes superconductivity and the creation of Cooper pairs is not complete. Otherwise, we’d design materials with the right properties from the beginning, rather than testing a lot of stuff just to see what works. > However I fear any research into room-temperature linear superconductors will now be as taboo as cold fusion. Contrary to cold fusion, superconduction is actually a thing. Current high-temperature superconductors work at the temperature of liquid nitrogen; finding one that works 100K higher is not that much of a stretch. The gap is not 6 orders of magnitude like with cold fusion. In fact, there is quite a lot of funding for research on high-temperature superconductors even this year so your fear is not really well founded.
- adastra22 3y agoOrders of magnitude variation in phonon energy is a thing though. You can do the basic statistics of waves in the open ocean and show that waves will never get high enough to crest an oil rig in the North Sea. Then go search for "rogue waves" on YouTube and watch it actually happen. We're just starting to get a handle on the mathematics underlying this phenomenon, but it does exist. And the causes of the phenomenon transpose directly into crystal latices. So we absolutely should expect "rogue phonons" that have energies orders of magnitude above average phonon energy, enough to overcome Coulomb barriers and trigger D-D or D-T fusion reactions. Of course thinking of using this to generate energy is something else entirely. It's a freak occurrence, and if there is a way of making it predictable or enhanced in some way, that solution is not obvious. But it should be detectable with very sensitive equipment, and would be a wonderful experimental physics result.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoThere's perhaps some misunderstanding about where "perpetual motion" comes from : it was about Aristotle's metaphysics, the best today's translation for at least some of these first devices would probably be "powered by changes in atmospheric pressure" : https://www.ageofinvention.xyz/p/age-of-invention-why-wasnt-the-steam-cc8 https://www.ageofinvention.xyz/p/age-of-invention-why-wasnt-... (Could skip to "Cornelis Drebbel".) So the term was used more as a synonym for "continuously working", like a water wheel, without presuming any violation of the laws of thermodynamics that had yet to be invented : https://www.ageofinvention.xyz/p/age-of-invention-perpetual-motion https://www.ageofinvention.xyz/p/age-of-invention-perpetual-... (Today we would call that one "a resume-padding buzzword.)
- adastra22 3y agoWhen physicists (I am one) talk about perpetual motion, we're making references to the results of statistical mechanics, not Aristotelian metaphysics.