3 ms·
It also means that the person asking the interview may not be the technical hiring manager. I expect such questions from someone in HR, but not from a technical
by malandrew 15y ago
It also means that the person asking the interview may not be the technical hiring manager. I expect such questions from someone in HR, but not from a technical hiring manager.
Someone in HR most like can't judge the answer to the question "How would you scale X, given Y and Z", nor could they come up with such a question that is appropriate for the position in question.
Such questions do more to isolate the variables, (1) the job to be performed, and (2) the interviewer's ability to judge the answer to a question relevant to the job. I can really only see such a question being asks by somebody that doesn't know why they are doing the hiring in the first place.
Judging by the responses in this thread, such a question is controversial, especially among the type of people that make up the HN community. That alone should be indicative that such a question may result in a high rate of false negatives. You probably lose more good candidates than gain.