3 ms·
the particular positions christiano is being criticized for are positions on questions such as the following: - what are the correct standards of right and wro
by kragen 3y ago
the particular positions christiano is being criticized for are positions on questions such as the following:
- what are the correct standards of right and wrong, if any exist?
- what is the ultimate purpose of human existence?
- what, if anything, will bring about the extinguishment of the human race?
- what sorts of immaterial more-than-human consciousnesses exist, or can exist, and what are the relationships between them and humanity?
it doesn't seem especially controversial or metaphorical to me to describe beliefs about such topics as 'religious', particularly when they are coupled with associations organized around those beliefs. buddhism is routinely described as a 'religion' even though it doesn't involve the worship of any deities and is often described by buddhists as entailing atheism
- burkaman 3y agoWhere did that list come from? I don't see anything like that in the article.
- kragen 3y agoit came from reading about effective altruism and longtermism since before they got those names
- burkaman 3y agoOk I see, I interpreted the phrase "association with" to be more about the people he's associating with than the beliefs, but the article is incredibly vague so there's no way for us to know what these criticisms actually are.
- kragen 3y agothe criticisms are that other people have different positions on those questions; it should hardly be surprising that people with conflicting positions on questions like the correct standards of right and wrong will criticize one another oh and also some bad people are effective altruists, which is something everyone agrees on, including the other effective altruists