5 ms·
I'm all for some good old civil disobedience as far as every day choices go in the outside world. However, I also think if you're employed somewhere there are
by duxup 3y ago
I'm all for some good old civil disobedience as far as every day choices go in the outside world.
However, I also think if you're employed somewhere there are reasonable expectations as far as workplace behavior goes that would prohibit the same "protest" or "civil disobedience" type behavior.
It is interesting that the protestor immediately declares that they don't wan to work for such a company. It sorta begs the question of "Then why do you?". It seems like their choice is obvious.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rs_rs_rs_rs_rs 3y ago[flagged]
- duxup 3y agoI'm thinking someone does some sit in at city hall or such. Things along those lines. Some folks do a sit in one day, they make themselves heard, there ya go. There are of course limits.
- user_7832 3y agoI partially agree, depending on the topic being protested. I was writing a reply to the above commenter before it got killed, but it is an open question to all who oppose such demonstrations. > Would you have any suggestions of what else could the guy have done, that would've brought similar media attention to the topic? > The line between "annoying/childish protestors" and "folks legitimately raising awareness" is ill defined for me, perhaps if anyone else has better suggestions I would be happy to hear them.
- sanderjd 3y agoNot "prohibit the same ... behavior", just "lead to consequences, like being fired, for the same behavior".
- PheonixPharts 3y agoThe trouble is that "reasonable expectations" are set by those in power. Slave overs set "reasonable expectations" for slaves, feudal lords set "reasonable expectations" for peasants. In such a world "reasonable expectations" by their nature foster a continuation of the existing power structures. Behavior that challenges "reasonable expectations" does so precisely because of the belief that the continuation of the status quo as perpetuated by those in power has become untenable. Many people "reasonably expect" nations and companies to not be complicit in genocide, where is their recourse?
- duxup 3y agoI feel like the expectations here are reasonable. I wouldn't want another employee interrupting my meeting like that either. As for the rest of your "salve owner" commentary I think that's an absurd comparison.
- PheonixPharts 3y agoAre you being deliberately obtuse? Surely you recognized there is a context to the "no interrupting meetings" guideline. The protester felt that meeting was playing part in the support and facilitation genocide, I think that's adequate grounds to interrupt a meeting. And what do you find absurd about the "slave owner" comparison? I'm not arguing that modern day employment is slavery or anything of the sort, just pointing out that the terms of "reasonable expectations" are always defined by those in power, and not once in history has working within "reasonable expectations" caused a shift in those power dynamics.
- duxup 3y agoObviously his behavior wasn't simply interrupting a meeting.
- catlikesshrimp 3y ago>"Are you being deliberately obtuse?" This is getting your post more downvotes than your opinion is. It hurts your opinion.
- moribvndvs 3y agoI don’t think it’s reasonable to expect that because you took a position, you forfeit any rights to decide a company has crossed your ethical line in the sand, or that you shouldn’t use a unique opportunity–even at your own risk–to appeal to other employees and leadership to adjust course. Growing up, I was told by family, mentors, educators that you effect change from within. Protest only when it’s safe and convenient is easily dismissed thus counterproductive. It’s up to the individual to decide if this employee was right or wrong about the issue at hand, but puzzling over whether or not they’re some sort of fool for strongly believing in something seems a bit obtuse.
- duxup 3y agoI think he can do all you describe, even do it in a way that doesn't get him fired.
- dahdum 3y agoHe could have worked on the inside, but it would have taken years of hard work building his credibility and power within the organization. He chose a much simpler path. Disruptively virtue signal knowing he would be fired. Now he can slide into a smaller progressive tech company where he will be lauded for his virtue, used by the company for PR, and ultimately not judged by the quality of his work. This was a thoughtfully orchestrated career strategy first, protest second. It was well done and I think he’s set himself up nicely for the next 5-10 years. If you disagree and think he was risking his future instead of securing it, I would humbly ask why? Both the media and Google’s response were 100% predictable. If I were him I’d try to move into a fuzzy, semi-technical role with some public presence. Something like DevRel seems the ideal target and maximizes the PR benefit for his employer.
- HackerThemAll 3y agoSo, immediate termination is ok for just yelling a few words, none of them being an f word against the CEO? I think they could just reprimand him and not fire him. This company is becoming a fear- and power-fueled autocracy of the board. Which won't bring any good to them.
- smsm42 3y agoDepending on the words, yes. Obviously, they disagree on what is the best way for the company to behave. In this case, the management of the company, by definition, has the priority, and if the differences are large enough, ending the employment relationship looks like the right way to go. Working at google is not some kind of right that belongs to everyone, it's a relationship between two sides, and each side can end it. Staging a protest on a keynote sounds like a good reason to end it.
- catlikesshrimp 3y agoOffer to relocate the employee first? >"Staging a protest on a keynote sounds like a good reason to end it." Google had shutdown the private forum without a proper discussion. Remind employees they can work in other areas? Going tangent: What if they were denouncing racism? Would it still be correct to fire them immediately? What about alleged genocide?
- smsm42 3y ago> Offer to relocate the employee first? To Gaza? That's an interesting idea, but I don't think it'd work out very well. > Remind employees they can work in other areas? I don't think somebody who can't figure that out by themselves is really a very valuable asset. But also I don't think that's the problem. The person did that not because they weren't aware there are other people in Google working on other things - literally everybody is aware on that. They didn't just requested a transfer to another group. They staged a protest because they wanted to influence Google's decisions by publicly threatening the withdrawal of their contribution. Turns out, Google is ok with that scenario. When you bluff, you should always consider what happens if you're called. > Google had shutdown the private forum without a proper discussion As I understand, the reverse had happened - the forum was overflown with the inflammatory activist messaging having no relation to the topic it has been created for, and had to be shut down, because it could no longer serve the function it was created for. "Proper discussion" has never been the activists' intent (and in general, experience teaches us these kinds of activists are a lot more into shutting down and deplatforming opponents than properly debating them). Not that Google has ever lately been on the frontlines of enabling proper discussion - as most major tech companies, they have abandoned this idea years ago in favor of serving as a gatekeepers and the pretorian guard - but in this particular case, it seems to be pretty clear no proper discussing was intended. > What if they were denouncing racism? What if Google was literally run by Hitler? You can always make an inflammatory hypothetical. But I don't see much point in discussing it - there's an infinite things that could happen, you can't discuss them all. Better to concentrate on things that are actually happening.
- catlikesshrimp 3y ago"In recent weeks, more than 600 Google workers signed a letter addressed to leadership asking that the company ..." Old twitter post acquisition would have terminated those 600 employees, too? I hope "west" society isn't demanding either obedience or cancelling your ideas. That much happens in Venezuela. It would be morally correct to allow a little leeway for expressing a shared opinion, then call for order, and remind collaborators to follow proper channels to "continue discussion". And, of course, not shutting down nor ignore such continued discussion. TLDR: Google is evil all the way down.