3 ms·
Or, TikTok has been banned in India since 2020, and all the chhapri/pullingo content moved to IG and YT Shorts as a result India's been Instagram's (and Meta i
by alephnerd 3y ago
Or, TikTok has been banned in India since 2020, and all the chhapri/pullingo content moved to IG and YT Shorts as a result
India's been Instagram's (and Meta in general) largest market for years now and 75% of Indians on the Internet use IG [0], and every month an additional million users in India seem to join based on MAU stats.
[0] - https://www.oberlo.com/statistics/instagram-users-by-country https://www.oberlo.com/statistics/instagram-users-by-country
- downWidOutaFite 3y agoPolitical momentum keeps building for banning it in the USA as well. It's driven by both Chinese (too much control) and Israeli (not enough control) propaganda concerns.
- rchaud 3y agoWhat would the overlap be between senior citizens in Congress pushing a bill and TikTok's audience?
- dylan604 3y agoDoes it matter? If the ban is established, the US TikTok audience essentially goes to 0.
- rchaud 3y agoA ban has been attempted since at least 2020, and has gone nowhere. There is no precedent for something like this, as Congress cannot show what law Tiktok has violated. It would need to go to the Supreme Court, even if both houses passed the bill. Congress puts forward many bills that have no shot at passing. The goal of something like this is to force Bytedance to sell its US operation to a US company, rather than deal with regulatory uncertainty. Hasn't worked yet.
- dylan604 3y agoWhen has a ban ever been attempted? It's been threatened, but that's a far cry from attempting it.
- rchaud 3y agoMontana has a ban on Tiktok (currently under appeal). Texas bans Tiktok on government wifi and wired networks. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/may/17/tiktok-ban-montana https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/may/17/tiktok-ban-m...
- dylan604 3y agoWell, now you've moved the goal posts. What a government says its employees can/cannot do is not the same thing as what the citizens can/cannot do. I see that no different than any employer not allowing apps on company devices, or even having the corp network block any/all social media.
- downWidOutaFite 3y agoI don't know what the difference is between a threat and an attempt but just yesterday a U.S. House panel unanimously approved a bill that could ban it. Today Biden said he'd sign the bill it if it passes.
- dylan604 3y ago> I don't know what the difference is between a threat and an attempt Is this a real statement? As in, ESL possibly? Someone blustering/threatening to do something is just a bunch of hot air. Enacting legislation and putting into action so that it becomes illegal would be attempting it. It would only be an attempt, as we've seen how well banning through legislation works with things like Prohibition, War on Drugs, etc. Are they going to force all US ISPs to block it? Are they going to ban it from the stores? Are they going to prevent US users from accessing VPNs from outside US territories? Let's face it, people are addicted to TikTok, and they will find a way to get their fix.
- ganeshkrishnan 3y agochhapri is not the same as pullingo. Chhapri is a bit derogatory term for "low class individuals"
- alephnerd 3y agoNaw. Chhapri is now used to represent the Hindi subculture similar to Pullingo, same way Punjabi and Haryanvi speakers use "Jatt" now. It's a cool example of dialectic change due to slang. Edit: though now that I think about it, someone like Elvish Yadav wouldn't own up to being Chhapri but his Pullingo equivalent would
- simpletone 3y ago> Or, TikTok has been banned in India since 202 Exactly. I'm surprised that tiktok has been able to maintain its top spot for so long. The biggest headscratcher is why india didn't ban facebook, instagram, youtube, etc along with tiktok. My hope was india would build up their own tech giants. Instead india just handed their social media environment to zuckerburg. What's the long term plan there? Give zuckerburg's properties ( facebook, instagram, whatsapp, etc ) monopoly over india? Are there any competent leaders in india? I simply don't get it.
- alephnerd 3y ago> why india didn't ban facebook, instagram, youtube, etc Has India almost went to war with the US in the last 5 years? No. Has India almost went to war with China in the last 5 years? Yes. That's why. Before 2020, Chinese firms were trying to expand into India as their ideal target market. In retaliation for Galwan, they got kicked out. > would build up their own tech giants Why? How many global software giants can you name from Israel, Japan, or South Korea (let alone the entire EU)? The biggest reason that countries like Israel were able to rapidly develop was because of the soft power of being so integrated in the American tech industry. IP driven industries like ICT, Pharmaecuticals, Semiconductors, and Finance represent 33% of Indian exports [0] but 10% of China's [1], and India's entire R&D capacity was built by western private sector companies like IBM, GE, TI, Intel, Nvidia, Apple, etc. Kicking them out is economic and research suicide for India. > I'm surprised that tiktok has been able to maintain its top spot for so long Because every other country uses it because it's so popular. [Is it just me or has HN gotten dumber recently?] [0] - https://atlas.cid.harvard.edu/countries/104/export-basket https://atlas.cid.harvard.edu/countries/104/export-basket [1] - https://atlas.cid.harvard.edu/countries/43/export-basket https://atlas.cid.harvard.edu/countries/43/export-basket
- simpletone 3y ago> Has India almost went to war with the US in the last 5 years? No. No. The US threatened nuclear war with india in the last 30 years though. https://thediplomat.com/2018/05/looking-back-the-1998-nuclear-wake-up-call-for-us-india-ties/ https://thediplomat.com/2018/05/looking-back-the-1998-nuclea... > That's why. If that was the case, then india would have stopped trade with china. China is still one of india's top trading partners. And one of its biggest investors. > they got kicked out. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_trading_partners_of_India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_trading_partne... > Why? Why ban tiktok? It's a national security issue. And india has the talent, population and resources to do so. > How many global software giants can you name from Israel, Japan, or South Korea (let alone the entire EU)? Surely you are smart enough to see the difference between israel, japan or south korea and india? I'm also a big proponent of the EU banning american tech and building up their own tech. The EU built up airbus, why can't they do the same for facebook, microsoft, etc? > The biggest reason that countries like Israel were able to rapidly develop was because of the soft power of being so integrated in the American tech industry. What does israel have to do with india? Are you saying india should be a vassal to the US like israel, japan and south korea are? You surely must be joking. India should be a regional power like china, russia and hopefully the EU. It shouldn't be anything like israel, korea or japan. Given its size and history, don't you think india should set its sights a little bit higher?