3 ms·
> lower costs can reveal demand. The markets for sub-orbital passenger service, or transporting bulk goods, are still 99.9% speculation. Otherwise - the total
by bell-cot 3y ago
> lower costs can reveal demand.
The markets for sub-orbital passenger service, or transporting bulk goods, are still 99.9% speculation. Otherwise - the total cost of a satellite or space station includes generally-very-high development and construction costs, then serious ongoing operational expenses. Neither dirt-cheap launch, nor a "Raspberry Pi, but for space" generic satellite bus could make useful satellites nearly as cheap as many folks seem eager to imagine. And Kessler Syndrome concerns give every A List nation in space ample reason to discourage anyone who wants to put cheap-but-less-reliable stuff into orbit. (Or abandon their stuff in orbit, after they get bored or go bankrupt.)
Lower costs can also reveal that you've blown billions on a 4-lane bridge to Lonely Island, when the 4-trips-daily old car ferry really was enough.
- ben_w 3y agoI'm not sure what your point is, given you're responding negatively to the possibility of very small cheap things when my example was a piece of global power-grid infrastructure that's probably got a raw material cost in the hundreds of billions of dollars range even if launch was free? (And made out of a launch system which would make launch costs overlap the price range of cargo flights).
- bell-cot 3y ago>> For example, while I think microwave beamed power from space is a terrible idea, an orbital ring can also be used to transport power[0], and Starship makes such a structure somewhat more affordable... You're obviously more familiar with this concept than I am...and your wording seems fairly unenthusiastic about the prospects for it. So spending billions to unlock the possibility of it...well, just does not sound like a rational business decision. And my "...isn't enough demand...to justify..." point was tagged "From a business PoV".
- ben_w 3y agoThere are two different things in that quote. Microwave beamed power = bad for reasons too long to divert into here. Orbital ring = contiguous ring orbiting earth, with connection points floating on it mag-lev style, tethered to the ground. The latter is functionally a superconductor, you can put charge on it and it keeps moving without loss. It's also a convenient place to put PV with no clouds. It's also an estimated cost to LEO of $0.05/kg, which is cheap enough to be worth comparing to conventional transport costs. It's certainly extremely speculative. Heck, I hope the first is built on the moon rather than on Earth because I expect surprise failure modes. But for what it can do, there's several clear business cases — just extremely risky ones. And that's just one thing Starship can help make affordable. For example of a different possibility: I have no idea if the occasional ideas I hear about factories in freefall are good or bad ideas, but it seems to be attracting investment now.