5 ms·
The Ruin of Mumbai
- alephnerd 3y agoThe height restrictions and rent control are overstated. If they were a blocker to slum redevelopment, then similar cities like Delhi (or even neighboring Thane and Navi Mumbai, or nearby Pune) would be equally as decrepit, which they are not. The major issue is land procurement and failure to minimize encroachment. India, being a democracy, is limited by public demands. As cities became economic growth engines, a lot of people migrated, but were unable to get housing, and then autarkic India had (and in a lot of cases, still has) socialist style "Development Authorities" manage housing construction within the Tier 1 cities. The development authorities were notorious slow at developing new property, so migrants were forced to encroach land and build slums. As the first generation of slum dwellers succeeded economically, they began moving out of the slums, but rented out the slum property to newer migrants, and kept a hold on the slum properties waiting for a government to eventually legalize those slum holdings and transfer the land rights to the "basti" owner (this kind of transfer has happened before - most recently in Odisha, Delhi, and Punjab). Unlike in China, India's democracy (no matter how flawed it is) prevents severely underfunded urban local governments from preventing this encroachment, and politicians actually liked this, as slum dwellers formed voting blocks, and would de facto collateralize their land to grey market financial institutions, which themselves worked under the auspices of those local politicans. And finally, slum dwellers would organize and place political minefields. There's a reason why tiny temples, mosques, and other religious institutions dot urban India - they aren't just for veneration but also tools to prevent demolitions, as dwellers can rally around protecting the temple or mosque from being demolished (along with the neighborhood), and politicians would have to back down, as Indian elections are won on extremely small margins. This economics of encroachment occurs in similar developing country like Brazil, Phillipines, and Vietnam as well as former developing economics like Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan. Slum dwellers are not idiots - just poor. They know they land they are on is worth millions, and most governments are not going to use force to kick them out, and if they do, they WILL fight back. The land they encroached is the closest thing they have to a nest egg.
- selimthegrim 3y agoWhat do you make of the DDC trying to demolish the mosque in Delhi currently then?
- alephnerd 3y agoMixed bag. They shouldn't have demolished the historic Akhondji masjid (it is truly ancient), but the slum built around it was built on land that was encroached on. Delhi is ruled by the opposition AAP. It's not like Temples don't get demolished either [0], and 4 temples were demolished along with the Akhondji Masjid [1] during the Mehrauli demolishment drive. If it was truly egregious Islamophobia, Indian allies like the UAE and KSA would have called it out like they did Nupur Sharma's extremely insensitive statement 2 years ago. [0] - https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/videos/city/delhi/delhi-temple-demolition-delhi-govts-encroachment-drive-leads-to-hindu-temple-demolition-in-geeta-colony/videoshow/102908393.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/videos/city/delhi/delhi-... [1] - https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/delhi-news/mosque-temples-graves-in-82-structures-razed-in-delhi-s-mehrauli-101707502017793.html https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/delhi-news/mosque-temp...
- selimthegrim 3y agohttps://thepatriot.in/heritage/experts-historians-object-to-proposal-to-remove-sunehri-masjid-44228 https://thepatriot.in/heritage/experts-historians-object-to-... NDMC is 80% controlled by Central Government, not Delhi government. (Sorry I should have written NDMC instead of MCD (which is what I meant by DDC above)).
- alephnerd 3y agoSunehri Bagh Masjid hasn't been demolished: it's still there. Also it appears you are confusing different cases. It's going through the court system, as it should. Hindu temples go through the cycle as well, and as I noted above, 4 Hindu temples neighboring the Akhondji Masjid were demolished as well. Look, I won't deny that it sucks being Muslim in India, but not every act is explicitly done out of Islamophobia. If I wanted to, I could say the same thing about Hindu Mandirs being demolished in Karachi's slum redevelopment program as well (not out of Hinduphobia) Finally, I've never heard of "The Patriot" before. The primary newspapers in Delhi are The Tribune's Delhi Edition and The Hindustan Times, and it's been that way for over a century.
- jkic47 3y agoIn fraught issues like rent control and housing, I often see claims like the one in the article that people moving to cities can see up to a 30% increase in income, but they never seem to factor in the increase in costs, which could be far higher than 30%, leading to a net loss. Same story with global warming claiming additional deaths due to increased temperatures without the corresponding statistic on deaths due to cold. I am not claiming the point is invalid - just that a fuller picture can make the conversation richer.
- alephnerd 3y agoRent control and Height restrictions aren't enforced in India. Property contract disputes in India follow the principle of "Jiski lathi, uski bhains" (might makes right // That cow belongs to the guy with the bamboo or iron rod). The landlord or the tenent can enforce their ideal level of rent based on who can force the other to comply, and civil courts have decades long backlogs so nothing will get done - property disputes make up the majority of cases in India.
- marcinzm 3y ago> Same story with global warming claiming additional deaths due to increased temperatures without the corresponding statistic on deaths due to cold. I am not claiming the point is invalid - just that a fuller picture can make the conversation richer. Studies on this definitely account for both. Of course, given that cold related deaths are already significantly fewer than heat deaths there isn't much to talk about beyond noting the fact that they're essentially irrelevant. This of course highlights why if one sees something "obvious" that experts miss the response should be to dig into why they're not accounting for it versus assuming they're idiots or malicious.
- jkic47 3y agoNot sure where you see my comment assuming they are idiots or malicious. I just note that they don't mention it, where they might reference the study that supports your assertion that they are significantly fewer.
- taneq 3y ago
- phowat 3y agoI 100% clicked the link expecting an article about how the open source PBX software Asterisk was being used in some nefarious way.
- user_7832 3y agoAs a Mumbaiker, I would also like to provide a bit of context that may not be obvious (but unfortunately isn't surprising) - the BMC (Municipal Corporation) is considered quite ineffective/corrupt/lazy by most citizens, despite being the richest municipal body in the world (with a budget of ₹59,954 crore this year, which I tried to convert to USD but I can't keep track of all zeros). Every year there are numerous deaths especially during heavy rain in monsoon, from potholes flipping bikers to the river not being desilted. There are valid arguments (eg lots of pollution in the river) but the end result isn't pretty. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brihanmumbai_Municipal_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brihanmumbai_Municipal_Corpora... has more info including controversies. Also, regarding housing specifically, due to a perpetual population growth and inflation, many buildings sit empty because builders know that people will cave in, even if property is temporarily overpriced and no one is buying them in the short term. Additionally legal disputes often block up other buildings, resulting in large dilapidated buildings sitting in the middle of busy/high-value areas but providing no benefit.
- shrikant 3y ago₹59,954 crore is roughly USD $7.2 billion.
- donbox 3y agoINR 59,954 crore is around 7 Billion USD.
- anon291 3y agoI was going to say... for a city with a population almost that of the entire state of California, this is hardly anything. To put that in perspective, California spends 200-300 billion each year.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoHow do you figured that? Average salary in california is around 10 times that of mumbai and population of greater mumbai is slightly more than half california. That adjusts the comparison to roughly 140 billion mumvai vs 200 billion california. So mumbai is marginally more efficient than one of the worst run us states by roughetrics. I suspect it should be considered worse because corruption at 8k a year average income cuts a lot worse than equivalent percentage corruption at 80k income
- anon291 3y agoI have never lived in Bombay, but my parents grew up there, and our family history there goes back to before it was even a city. Indians have an insatiable appetite for centralized economic planning that has done nothing but hurt the country. For me, it's inexplicable, but it's often like trying to talk at a wall. It makes American NIMBY's look like transit advocates. And for all the fascination with bureaucracy, the bureaucracy is never efficient. My aunts and uncles who landlorded there for a while had so much trouble evicting tenants for things that would be trivial in America, such as failure to pay. Courts, municipal officials, just drag their feet. It's a cultural problem, and shocks the American conscience. Such a sad squandering of potential and a good case study in how culture absolutely affects outcomes.
- elevatedastalt 3y ago> evicting tenants for things that would be trivial in America, such as failure to pay Evicting tenants is a MASSIVE pain in the ass in many American states.
- gedy 3y ago> And for all the fascination with bureaucracy, the bureaucracy is never efficient Isn't that perhaps the point? Corruption allows everyone to get their hand in the till for money, power, etc. Maybe this drives the "central planning" so that the elites get their graft too.
- addicted 3y agoThis comment is almost entirely ahistorical. India as a country is about 75 years old. It’s ridiculously young. India is the largest democracy in the world despite having half as many official languages as American states, and an order of magnitude more spoken languages, cultures and religions. Despite this India has remained a largely integral state, has seen authoritarian rule and seen it off in a few years, unlike nearly every other democracy formed around the same time has never been ruled by the military for even a moment. The greatest economic miracle in the history of human civilization, the growth of China was a product of almost complete central planning to the point that the state also coercively controlled the number of kids you could have. Central planning is clearly no barrier to growth. India, on the other hand has a highly federal system of government. Arguably the last few years have seen a lot more top down management but that’s a result of the party in federal government also being in power in most state governments. The current debate playing out in the world is the exact opposite of what you’re claiming. China’s success has made central planning and authoritarianism appear highly desirable. India’s slower growth has made it appear that federalism and democracy are not popular. However, as the pandemic is showing, when authoritarians mess up they tend to cause irreparable harm whereas democracies are able to absorb a lot more hits. Your vision of India is a mirror house vision of a 50 year old India at best. (Btw, even the court and municipal problems you’re referring to is clearly not cultural. India’s slow legal system is very clearly a result of sticking to an antiquated British system and not modernizing it to allow, for example, out of court settlements, which has led to massive backlogs that are now being addressed. And in terms of municipal actions the Indian state is addressing those issues to the point where there are many functions where the Indian equivalent are significantly faster than the U.S. Try getting a passport in the U.S. today vs India. Try making payments. India is far ahead of the U.S. which is frankly shocking considering the massive head start the U.S. has here. Try IDs. While Apple is celebrating something like 4 states doing a pilot system of digital IDs which hasn’t even grown in the 5 years or so, nearly every municipal ID in India today is digital. Most civil functions can now be done online. India has also drastically improved government distributions. While the US government was sending literal checks through the mail over COVID Indian monetary benefits are now directly deposited in a bank account.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]