2 ms·
> there isn't enough demand for launch services, satellites, etc. to justify even 10% of the current and near-future capacity. Perhaps. But lower costs can rev
by ben_w 3y ago
> there isn't enough demand for launch services, satellites, etc. to justify even 10% of the current and near-future capacity.
Perhaps. But lower costs can reveal demand.
For example, while I think microwave beamed power from space is a terrible idea, an orbital ring can also be used to transport power[0], and Starship makes such a structure somewhat more affordable.
[0] can, but I'm not saying it's the best option, even if "a charged object spinning in a vacuum" is a ballistic superconductor[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_ring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_ring
[1] without the quantum effects: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ballistic_conduction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ballistic_conduction
- bell-cot 3y ago> lower costs can reveal demand. The markets for sub-orbital passenger service, or transporting bulk goods, are still 99.9% speculation. Otherwise - the total cost of a satellite or space station includes generally-very-high development and construction costs, then serious ongoing operational expenses. Neither dirt-cheap launch, nor a "Raspberry Pi, but for space" generic satellite bus could make useful satellites nearly as cheap as many folks seem eager to imagine. And Kessler Syndrome concerns give every A List nation in space ample reason to discourage anyone who wants to put cheap-but-less-reliable stuff into orbit. (Or abandon their stuff in orbit, after they get bored or go bankrupt.) Lower costs can also reveal that you've blown billions on a 4-lane bridge to Lonely Island, when the 4-trips-daily old car ferry really was enough.
- ben_w 3y agoI'm not sure what your point is, given you're responding negatively to the possibility of very small cheap things when my example was a piece of global power-grid infrastructure that's probably got a raw material cost in the hundreds of billions of dollars range even if launch was free? (And made out of a launch system which would make launch costs overlap the price range of cargo flights).
- bell-cot 3y ago>> For example, while I think microwave beamed power from space is a terrible idea, an orbital ring can also be used to transport power[0], and Starship makes such a structure somewhat more affordable... You're obviously more familiar with this concept than I am...and your wording seems fairly unenthusiastic about the prospects for it. So spending billions to unlock the possibility of it...well, just does not sound like a rational business decision. And my "...isn't enough demand...to justify..." point was tagged "From a business PoV".
- ben_w 3y agoThere are two different things in that quote. Microwave beamed power = bad for reasons too long to divert into here. Orbital ring = contiguous ring orbiting earth, with connection points floating on it mag-lev style, tethered to the ground. The latter is functionally a superconductor, you can put charge on it and it keeps moving without loss. It's also a convenient place to put PV with no clouds. It's also an estimated cost to LEO of $0.05/kg, which is cheap enough to be worth comparing to conventional transport costs. It's certainly extremely speculative. Heck, I hope the first is built on the moon rather than on Earth because I expect surprise failure modes. But for what it can do, there's several clear business cases — just extremely risky ones. And that's just one thing Starship can help make affordable. For example of a different possibility: I have no idea if the occasional ideas I hear about factories in freefall are good or bad ideas, but it seems to be attracting investment now.
- thechao 3y agoA "stack" of orbital ring systems (this is a train-on-ring) lets you build the functional equivalent of a space elevator out of plausible materials like fiber glass & superconductors. Every rung in the ladder has value.
- ben_w 3y agoSure (also: that's a new idea I'd not heard of before), but why? Just the first step is half way to anywhere, by Δv.
- thechao 3y agoThe top of an ORS isn't in orbit — it's stationary with respect to the ground. You still have to burn the Δv to get into orbit. The idea is that it's easier to go slowly up, where the natural speed you're at will (eventually) match the Earth's rotation.
- ben_w 3y agoI'm not sure which structure you're thinking of, but the first sentence of my link was this: """An orbital ring is a concept of an artificial ring placed around a body and set rotating at such a rate that the apparent centrifugal force is large enough to counteract the force of gravity.""" The tether isn't in orbit, but the ring absolutely is. And you can exchange momentum with the ring to reach orbital speed.