3 ms·
> Slingshotting about the moon to gain velocity relative to the Sun doesn’t work. Why not? And you don't actually want to gain velocity, you'd want to change
by eru 3y ago
> Slingshotting about the moon to gain velocity relative to the Sun doesn’t work.
Why not? And you don't actually want to gain velocity, you'd want to change direction.
I agree that shooting stuff into the sun is not worth it, if you just want to get rid of it.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Why not? And you don't actually want to gain velocity, you'd want to change direction If you fall towards an object and then fall away from it, there is no net force. You can’t bleed or gain delta-V simply by falling into an object and then falling away from it. The reason planetary slingshots work is you’re “dragged” along with their orbital velocity about the Sun. You can be clever about using that to reduce the delta-V to the Sun. But it’s still more than system escape velocity.
- eru 3y ago> You can’t bleed or gain delta-V simply by falling into an object and then falling away from it. But you can change direction.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> you can change direction This is analogous to trying to turn a plane by only yawing. Or travel in a current by turning your head. This guy [1] is wrong. Delta-v comes from Tsiolkovsky’s rocket equation, which in turn derives from Newton’s second law and the conservation of linear momentum. It’s incredibly fundamental math that you can’t cheat by changing direction. (You’ll change orientation and keep going where the math says you will. Because you’re going sideways relative to the Sun at an incredible velocity, the inheritance of every atom in the Earth’s sphere of influence, including the Moon.) [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=o11c https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=o11c
- bagels 3y agoThere was a lot of charity shown in this thread.
- krallja 3y agoNo, the direction change is relative to the Moon, not your orbit around the Sun. The Moon, when retrograde, is still moving forward around the Sun. Your orbit will become more eccentric, but the periapsis won’t even make it past Venus’ orbit.
- bagels 3y agoWhat are the orbital parameters before and after the moon close approach?