3 ms·
They'd gotten pretty close in their last launch. It may not have looked like it (the first stage exiting stage right was wacky), but from a technical standpoint
by adastra22 3y ago
They'd gotten pretty close in their last launch. It may not have looked like it (the first stage exiting stage right was wacky), but from a technical standpoint it actually went off pretty well.
It's the business case that failed. Mass-produced expendable rockets was a brilliant idea prior to SpaceX. It would have worked two decades ago. There's no market for it now.
ETA: Apparently they had more attempts than I remembered. The next one after the sideways launch did in fact reach orbit as their first success. They've only had a 50% success rate after that though, which is really unusual.
- panick21_ 3y ago> It's the business case that failed. They failed technically and in business. Their lunch success rate was far to late and the rockets they built were always behind what the market actually demanded. They moved from rocket model to rocket model and never managed to stable produce any of them. > Mass-produced expendable rockets was a brilliant idea prior to SpaceX. No it wasn't. Their whole idea of 'its fine if half the rockets fail' doesn't actually work. There are not enough payloads to mass-produce rockets (specially small rockets). Its a total misunderstanding of the economics of mass manufacture to think this was gone get the price low enough. > It would have worked two decades ago. No it wouldn't have. Because a decade ago they would not have gotten the money for so many failed launches in the first place. Its only because SpaceX and RocketLab proved the viability, that companies like Astra got the money to even attempted what they did. The reason why they survived as long as they did is because the were able to SPAC when the market was high. The readability is Astra was a technical failure of a company. The only success they had was because their CEO was good at twitter and selling the company.
- ahartmetz 3y agoI can say that my lunch success rate, for the ones that took place, is easily above 99.5% (sorry, that typo was too funny)
- panick21_ 3y agoDyslexia strikes again
- adastra22 3y agoTheir business model was not based on a 50% flight success rate. They anticipated some failures, but not that many. They wanted to be launching a new rocket literally every day, with only a few failures per year. Ironically, SpaceX is approaching those numbers for its reusable Falcon fleet. > The readability is Astra was a technical failure of a company. The only success they had was because their CEO was good at twitter and selling the company. Couldn't agree with you more on this though. I worked under the guy at NASA Ames. He was a hack and a poser, and I steered clear ever since.