3 ms·
The situation for Arab Israeli citizens, fraught as it may be, is not comparable to that of Black Africans under Apartheid, or that of Black Americans in the 19
by tptacek 3y ago
The situation for Arab Israeli citizens, fraught as it may be, is not comparable to that of Black Africans under Apartheid, or that of Black Americans in the 1950s. There are Arab Israelis in the Knesset.
I don't have a problem with people calling Israel an "apartheid state", given their occupation of Gaza. Fair enough. But you should be careful not to overplay those cards, because you'll end up making arguments that are easily refuted.
- feedforward 3y ago> The situation for Arab Israeli citizens, fraught as it may be, is not comparable to that of Black Africans under Apartheid, or that of Black Americans in the 1950s. There are Arab Israelis in the Knesset. Adam Clayton Powell Jr. and William Dawson were in the US congress in the 1940s and 1950s.
- runarberg 3y agoApartheid South Africa also had the Tricameral Parliament[1] which gave “Coloured” and Indian people a minority seats at the legislator. Off course this type of representation was only performative and the only purpose was to give the appearance of democracy. Notable here—since we are now comparing the rights of victims of different apartheid systems—is the tiered system of giving separate peoples varying levels of—still performative—representation. In Israel, Palestinians with Israeli citizenship (including Bedouin) do have a minority representation at their legislator, however Palestinians in the West Bank don’t, while Palestinians in Gaza effectively live in an unrecognized (and constantly terrorized) bantustan. The systems of apartheid which Israel upholds are in many ways worse than South Africa’s (and in every way worse than Pre-civil rights USA). But in most way’s it is simply different. Which is kind of why we really shouldn’t be ranking apartheid systems (nor any form of oppression for that matter). 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tricameral_Parliament https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tricameral_Parliament
- nsguy 3y agoIsrael didn't occupy Gaza. It completely withdrew from Gaza in 2005. The use of the word "occupation" in this context is newspeak. Gaza used to be under Egyptian control until 1967. The term "occupation" in the context of Gaza and international law referred to it being occupied from Egypt by Israel in the six day war. The term "occupation" used by pro-Palestinians refers to the existence of Israel. They s/Israel/occupation/ and they refer to the Jewish presence anywhere in Mandatory Palestine and the middle east. I'm not going to revisit the entire history of the conflict in this comment but the adoption of terminology like "apartheid", "genocide", "occupation", "resistance", "ghetto", "concentration camp", "nazis" etc. is intentional and insidious. The intent is not to criticize Israel. The intent is to dehumanize it and justify violence against it as a whole. The people using these terms are intentionally presenting falsehoods refuse to acknowledge the factual reality. The choice of terminology is to prevent dialogue. We don't need new words for the status of people living in areas that are occupied. Everyone understands that people living in occupied territories (such as e.g. Germany post WW-II) don't receive the same rights as the people living in the country of the occupier. That is not Apartheid. Israel recognizes that it occupies the west bank (from Jordan btw. which also doesn't want the territory back) and has tried many times to resolve this issue. tl;dr I do have a problem with people calling Israel an "apartheid state". Let's reserve that word to South Africa which is what it's supposed to mean. This is just wrong on so many levels. If you want to criticize Israel do it on a factual basis. And btw, this was true pre-Oct 7th as well. I'd argue these people have contributed to the events of Oct 7th and are partly responsible for this terrible mess we're in today.
- runarberg 3y agoFor the record, there are currently two cases against Israel at the ICJ, one is for genocide, and the other is for apartheid[*]. These are the words which are used before the world court, it would be kind of silly to police the same usage on an internet forum. The intent here is the same as at the ICJ, to accuse Israel of an illegal, undemocratic, and inhumane practice. Otherwise, tit-for-tat, if you want to use these words for what they were originally used, you should probably not use the term “terrorism” unless you are specifically referring to Irish nationalists using terrorism against the British colonial rule. But onto your main point, that Israel does not practice apartheid because occupation is not apartheid (and there is no occupation in Gaza?) When people refer to the policy of Apartheid which Israel imposes onto Palestinians, they are more likely referring to something like: a) Separate freedom of migration: Israel is famous for their policy of granting citizenship for people of Jewish ethnicity, meanwhile Palestinians in exile are not even allowed to return to Gaza, let alone the West Bank, or Israel proper. Gazans are also not allowed to migrate to the West Bank although the reverse is allowed (if you never return). At the same time, Israelis or even American Jews, are allowed to move into areas in the West Bank. b) Limitations on the freedom of movement: Palestinians living in the West Bank have to move between constant checkpoints to go between areas within the West Bank, they cannot go to Israel Proper, and Gaza has severe restrictions. Israelis living in the same areas do not have to go to these checkpoints and can travel freely between Israel and the West Bank. c) Separate legal system: Palestinians in the West Bank are tried before a military court, while Israelis living in the same area guilty of the same crime are tried before a much more lenient civilian court. d) Land grabs for Israelis: Israel allows settlements in vast areas inside the West Bank, Palestinians are not allowed to create settlements like that. e) Access to water: Israel portions the water disproportionately to Israel, leaving Palestinians with less chances to e.g. farm profitably. f) Settler terrorism: Israeli settlers constantly terrorize Palestinians in the West Bank and East Jerusalem. This includes stealing their houses, stealing their farmland, destroying their crops, killing their livestock, destroying their property. This is not government policy, and some of the settler terrorist do get punished in the Israeli civilian legal system (see (c)). However there are plenty of instances where the Israeli police or army has observed these terrorist attacks and done nothing to prevent them, sometimes they even participate in them. --- *: More accurately the case only mentions policies and practices but several nations (including South Africa) have used the term “apartheid” in their oral testimonies.
- runarberg 3y agoI mention Apartheid South Africa three times in this thread. Once to demonstrate that USA withdrawing support can mean an end to an oppressive system and liberating their peoples (as opposed to turning it into a pariah state akin to North Korea). And here I mention it as point of comparison to which values Israel might hold (as opposed to the vague unspecified “western values” my parent was talking about). Later down I mention Apartheid South Africa for the third time to reinforce that USA’s values (should) support freedom from oppression. Nowhere am I comparing the rights of the victims of various forms of Apartheid. Here in particular I’m trying to get my parent to explain what they mean by “western values” and am using Apartheid South Africa as an example of what I believe the values of Israel resemble.
- tptacek 3y agoYou wrote "Israel shares a lot of values with Apartheid South Africa". No, not so much. If you want to call Israel an apartheid state, because of its occupation of the Gaza strip, I won't quibble. But no, I don't think you can make that specific comparison work.
- runarberg 3y agoI give three examples: > It does not offer equal status to all its subjects, it maintains a prolonged occupation, it is highly militaristic. These are all true points. And makes of kind of unique, which I would argue is a true display of values.
- tptacek 3y agoLet's not find creative ways to argue. If what I said was banal or didn't intersect your argument, we don't have a dispute. I took you to be saying something, but it sounds like you're saying you didn't mean that. Fair enough!