6 ms·
>[...]this is a deliberate act of aggression by Apple [...] >There’s no other way than to interpret this, and the preceding actions by Apple, as a temper tantr
by gruez 3y ago
>[...]this is a deliberate act of aggression by Apple [...]
>There’s no other way than to interpret this, and the preceding actions by Apple, as a temper tantrum of malicious compliance [...]
While it's pretty clear that most people here would have liked it if Apple rolled out third party app stores to everyone and were hoping that EU regulations would extend to non-EU users (like with USB-C charging port standard), the reality of the situation is that EU jurisdiction ends at EU borders. Apple is complying with the laws exactly, and characterizing it as "aggression" or "temper tantrum" is closer to name calling than any sort of cogent argument. Chinese regulations require Apple to store iCloud data in Chinese data centers. Apple complies with this for only Chinese users. Should this also be characterized as "aggression" or "temper tantrum"? What's the difference between these two cases beyond "I like third party app stores" and "I hate my data stored in the hands of an authoritarian regime"?
- em-bee 3y agoi travel a lot. and that means, i sometimes leave my home for months at a time. more than 30 days. when roaming with a chinese sim card, all my traffic keeps going through china, regardless how long i leave the country. so for practical purposes, it is like i never left the country. but if i use an EU sim, suddenly after 30 days i am no longer considered to be part of the EU? as an EU citizen? how does that make any sense? EU laws should apply as long as i use a EU sim card, regardless how long i am outside of the country. only when i switch sims, then i find it acceptable to say that EU law should no longer apply to my phone.
- tmottabr 3y agoWhen using a EU sim your traffic will still go trough the EU server. But the EU laws stop applying at the border. The third-party stores are there because of a EU law that does not apply on any other country. If they wanted they could make the store stop working the minute you step out of the EU and they would still be following the law.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoWhat belies this is the fact that they do this differently for the specific intersection of the EU and the app store than they do for any of the many other long standing geofenced functions.
- tmottabr 3y agosimple.. other geo-fenced functions are not related to laws and apple does not care about it, but third-party stores are both. Apple stance is that they are against third-party stores and that they will not have it available unless they are forced to. only place where they are forced to make third-party stores available is EU, so that is the only place where they will be available.
- auselen 3y ago> EU jurisdiction ends at EU borders They still charge me EU prices outside though.
- arzig 3y agoIt’s malicious because they’ve done more work than necessary to put limitations on the user. They already know what region an account is in. If they just said “Ok, EU account, turn on the flags” that would be less engineering effort. Even if they increased verification of things like where you actually are relative your account at signup. But this is them engineering this solution to make sure the secret sauce doesn’t leak out of the EU. Everyone knows it’s malicious because it’s easy to intuitively grasp that they’ve gone through all this extra effort to make absolutely sure everyone outside of the EU has a worse experience no matter what
- tmottabr 3y agoon the other hand.. apple is against third-party stores.. they do not want then, so they will only make then available were they are forced to.. only place they are forced to is EU, so they made sure the third-party stores only work on the places that they are required by law.. if apple had any say in this there would be no third-party stores anywhere..] this is completely the opposite of other geo-fenced functions that apple want tom make available but cant because some reason or another, usually local laws. like the ECG on the apple watch.. they did not had it available everywhere, but if you enabled the function in a country that allowed it to be enabled you could keep using in other countries that did not had it available yet because the law in those countries did not forced then to disable it. but there were countries where you could not enable it even if your watch supported. same thing here but the other way around.. apple will enable third-party store only where they have to and disable everywhere else.. they could keep then enable when you leave but they do not want to, hell they do not want third-party stores at all even in EU, they only have it there because EU law forced then to have it..
- danlugo92 3y ago> less engineering effort Yep, I think this is a pretty clear-cut case of a "fuck you", they should be punished accordingly. By the EU inside the EU of course. Or just disallow this outright, which would require an Apple-specific law and all of the resources that brings in though, jeez.
- neurostimulant 3y ago> Chinese regulations require Apple to store iCloud data in Chinese data centers. Apple complies with this for only Chinese users. Do chinese users that leave the mainland for 30 days got converted to standard apple account with china-specific limitations removed?
- danlugo92 3y agoI bet not if there's such a thing.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoThey included an example fact that exposes how the current actions are different from equivalent long preexisting behavior, and so that difference does require an explanation.
- margana 3y ago> EU jurisdiction ends at EU borders. EU law applies to Apple or its subsidiaries operating in Europe. As long as Apple itself stays within EU borders, the law applies to them. It stops applying to them when they exit the EU market. The third parties (including EU citizens) mentioned within the text of the regulation do not define the applicability of the law itself.
- turquoisevar 3y agoExactly. They’re following the DMA to a T and because people don’t like that fact, all kinds of loaded language is used to describe the mere act of complying with a law. They might as well call Apple petty for not throwing in an iPhone with the purchase of a MacBook.
- leereeves 3y agoAre they continuing to accept your EU payment method after 30 days? Then they're still doing business with you in the EU and the DMA should still apply.
- turquoisevar 3y agoIf I vacation in the US and use my EU payment method to pay for a coffee in the US, am I doing business in the US or in the EU? How do you think the tax nexus plays out in that case? Do you think the coffee shop owes income or sales tax to the country where the bank issuing my payment method is established? What if I am from EU country A but my bank is located in EU country B? Is A or B going to claim nexus? I think there’s no need to be coy here because we both know that that merchant isn’t going to have to pay a dime to a government entity outside of the US and neither would I in this example, at least not insofar it is related to my purchase of the coffee.
- leereeves 3y agoThat's a poor comparison because Apple isn't a local business. They're everywhere. And to the extent that they act as if they were localized, they continue to treat EU customers as if they were in the EU until the customer chooses to change region. Selling to them through the EU app store, charging EU prices, with EU policies.
- Brian_K_White 3y ago"This just in: Legal scholar points out that they are not technically touching the cookie jar." It's trivial to invalidate this non-argument and expose intent, or rather remove the cloak of denyability, by simply witnessing several different inconsistencies. Not merely that such geofenced functions are nothing new, and so there is already a practically infinite body of evidense of established behavior around that, and somehow only this one thing is handled differently, but also other things like someone else pointed out, are Apple still accepting their EU payment method? Applying EU taxes on those transactions? Conforming to EU laws in other ways relating to that customer? In all other ways Apple are declaring that they recognize the user as an EU citizen.
- paulddraper 3y agoExactly. And yeah, the policies wind up arbitrary and weird....but that's because jurisdictions are arbitrary and weird. =