15 ms·
Reentry of International Space Station Batteries into Earth's Atmosphere
- geepytee 3y agoReally cool to think about it. I didn't think they'd just drop 2 tonnes worth of batteries like that.
- m4rtink 3y agoI recently saw in person a non-flight part of a Vega satellite dispenser - rather solid looking 80+ kg aluminum ring like shape, that during a normal flight profile burns up about 100 minutes after lunch via controlled re-entry of the upper stage. Apparently, very little of that is expected to come down, courtesy of the 8 km/s of kinetic energy it has turning into heat in a very short amount of time. I image it will be the same for the battery pallet, aided with parts being thin skinned & pressurized.
- bagels 3y agoNot much else you can do with them. They won't stay in that low orbit without boosts, and pose a danger if they stay on orbit.
- bigfatfrock 3y agoIs it prohibitively expensive to just boost them into the sun or elsewhere, while in low orbit?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> prohibitively expensive to just boost them into the sun or elsewhere, while in low orbit? It’s easier to exit the Solar System than it is to boost mass into the Sun from any Earth orbit [1][2]. The atmosphere providing braking for “free” is a huge propellant saver. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Solar_system_delta_v_map.svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Solar_system_delta_v_ma... [2] https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/3612/calculating-solar-system-escape-and-and-sun-dive-delta-v-from-lower-earth-orbit https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/3612/calculating-s...
- o11c 3y agoThat's commonly cited, but actually a wrong implication of delta-v. It's expensive to get close to the Sun at low speeds (e.g. if you could land on it, or if you want a close orbit). It's trivial to slingshot around the moon and impact the Sun at high speed.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> actually a wrong implication of delta-v Could you share a sample pair of trajectories that demonstrates this claim?
- mnw21cam 3y agoThe Earth's orbital velocity around the Sun is ~30km/s. You need to cancel almost all of that out in order to shift to a trajectory that intersects the Sun, and that trajectory still has you impacting the Sun at quite some speed. The Moon's orbital velocity around the Earth is ~1km/s. A slingshot manoeuvre around the Moon isn't going to help nearly enough here. One of the most efficient ways to get to the Sun is to leave Earth in the same direction it is going (and yes you can use a Moon slingshot to help here if you want) which will result in your rocket going further away from the Sun than the Earth. Once you're out in the region of the outer planets, you'll be travelling a lot slower and won't need to cancel out nearly as much velocity. Neptune's orbital velocity is ~5.5km/s, and if your rocket has an apohelion around there and a perihelion around Earth then you'll be travelling slower than that. However, it still takes a huge amount of delta-v to get out to the region of Neptune and then cancel out your velocity relative to the Sun. Compare that to the amount of delta-v required to de-orbit an object from low Earth orbit. The object's velocity around the Earth is going to be about 7.9km/s, but it only requires a delta-v of around 100m/s to put it into a nice predictable atmospheric entry. That's comparatively nothing.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoNot so trivial though to slingshot around the Moon? (Though ISS is in orbit, I believe there is some ways still to climb from ISS to get to the Moon.)
- perihelions 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lmm 3y agoYes. LEO is "halfway to anywhere" but only halfway, boosting up to a high earth orbit requires significant amounts of fuel, getting all the way out of earth's gravity well takes more, and to get to the sun would take even more than boosting all the way out of the solar system. If they put them in an orbit "next to" the ISS then atmospheric drag would eventually carry them down until they burned up (even the ISS itself needs to be regularly boosted or it would eventually fall down) but that way it's unpredictable and uncontrolled (and there's always the risk of them hitting a satellite or something), a planned re-entry burnup is generally thought to be safer.
- bagels 3y agoYes. Dropping in to the atmosphere is safer and infinitely cheaper than any other choice but not sending things to orbit in the first place.
- thorum 3y agoIs it not possible (yet) to return them to the surface in a controlled manner via a SpaceX capsule of some kind? (Or just not seen as worth the expense?)
- duskwuff 3y agoThe only such capsules available are already being used to return astronauts. There isn't enough spare capacity for returning much else -- and certainly not 2.6 metric tons of batteries.
- mandevil 3y agoThe Space Shuttle was weird and unusual in that it was the only spacecraft ever capable of bringing significant payload back down to Earth. It cost a whole lot of payload up mass to get that capability (every flight had to carry the reentry protection for that huge payload bay, even if you didn't actually need it) and it was used on several occasions- things like Palapa and Westar (STS-51A), Solar Max, and all the SpaceLab missions- but on many other flights the payload bay came home ~empty and all that protection weight could have had better uses. All that comes home in current spacecraft (Dragon, CST, Soyuz, Shenzhou) is the small compartment with the people in it, and each of them even leaves the "orbital module"- all the fuel etc. behind to be burned up in the atmosphere. (Progress cargo flights burn up, but Cargo Dragon is actually recovered so some amount of cargo can be returned fully to Earth, but its mostly scientific stuff that is coming back in there right now as I understand it.)
- KennyBlanken 3y agoThat's because the Space Shuttle was designed to be a spy-agency space cargo van (with parts from nearly every congressional district to guarantee it would sail through congressional approval despite being hideously expensive and impractical.) Make everyone go "ooo, lookie at the science teacher doing experiments to see how [plant/animal] acts in space, everybody!" so they pay no attention to the spy satellite in the cargo bay (or the different spy satellite, or other equipment, being brought back.)
- bagels 3y ago
- sdenton4 3y agoI would imagine that breaking them up instead of dropping as a single unit could be beneficial - higher surface to volume ratio, leading to more thorough burn up in the atmosphere.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoThe trade-off is a less-predictable trajectory. (I don’t know the margin of error for this splashdown. Breaking it up might have been the safer move.)
- eru 3y agoI guess it also depends on how small you break them down.
- krallja 3y ago“The uncontrolled disposal of the pallet, however, was not part of the original plan. It was made necessary by a disrupted spacewalking schedule following the failed launch of a Soyuz rocket in 2018, which forced NASA astronaut Nick Hague and Roscosmos cosmonaut Alexey Ovchinin to make an emergency landing in the Kazakh steppe. This event led to a backlog in the disposal of such equipment. Normally, old batteries would be placed inside an HTV and jettisoned from the ISS to burn up on re-entry.” https://gizmodo.com/massive-iss-cargo-pallet-reentry-earth-march-2024-1851317508 https://gizmodo.com/massive-iss-cargo-pallet-reentry-earth-m...
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoWould that be different? Is there any benefit to burning up the batteries in a HTV vs letting them drop?
- geerlingguy 3y agoControl - the HTV is automated to descend with a preset profile, so it would not just come down at random after a bunch of orbits.
- dotancohen 3y agoThe current tragedy has the batteries just minutes away from hitting London or Berlin. A controlled reentry would be much further from large population centres.
- sokoloff 3y agoIs the current event a tragedy? It seems maybe a tragedy in the literary genre sense of the word more than in the disastrous event sense of the word.
- dotancohen 3y agoThat's what I get for typing on a phone with autocorrect. The word should have been "trajectory" though I concede that I may have spelled that incorrectly enough for the autocorrect to mistake the word.
- rob74 3y agoSaw this on the news yesterday here in Germany with a headline like "ISS debris might hit Earth" and briefly feared a Gravity-like scenario - but the speakers's tone of voice didn't fit, and soon it became apparent that it was "just" a battery pack...
- MrGilbert 3y agoI mean... the pack is the size of a car and weights roughly the same (2.6kt), so.... it's not a triple A battery. But yeah, it's not a Gravity scenario, either.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 3y agoIt's amazing that we're already in the reentry time window and they haven't posted an updated prediction.
- Aachen 3y agoOrbit, to check when it's above you and (if it then hits atmosphere) you might see it: https://www.n2yo.com/satellite/?s=47853 https://www.n2yo.com/satellite/?s=47853 | https://www.satview.org/?sat_id=47853U https://www.satview.org/?sat_id=47853U
- richx 3y agoThis is a map of the affected area in Germany. It seems to miss Berlin, but many large cities in the Ruhr valley are affected. https://www.bbk.bund.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/Krisenmanagement/Weltraum/bodenspuren-karte_download.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=2 https://www.bbk.bund.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/Krisenmanage...
- tullianus 3y ago"Affected" is a strong term. The line along which re-entry was predicted to occur is three times the circumference of the Earth (as you can see in the OP article), and a small fraction of that line passes through the borders of Germany.
- narag 3y agoI read somewhere that they're considering abandoning the ISS in the future and "deorbiting it". Is this for real? If yes, wouldn't it be possible to move it to a higher, safe orbit instead? Maybe even taking it to Moon's orbit?
- a3w 3y agoThe fuel needed to get two small capsules to the moon is expensive, since you start on earth. The fuel required for all of the ISS is way too much. Also, if you pick a random place on earth, there are no humans there. You might find roads, mostly, it is water, and if not, the only sign of humand life is most likely roads, or nothing at all. I do not recall who used google earth to test this, and of course, a large scatter area for debris would alter this probability equation.
- spacemark 3y agoNot even remotely possible in a practical sense, for so many reasons. Summed up by it wasn't designed for it. Radiation, fuel consumption required for the delta V, supply vehicle capabilities, generation of space debris, regulatory compliance, design lifetime, etc. If it was practical, they'd be doing it instead of Artemis.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoDepends if you want to use nuclear or not. It's very possible if you have a nuclear rocket lifting it, but that's at least a decade away.
- dmd 3y ago> at least a decade away Just like it was in 1950!
- 1970-01-01 3y agoIt's in active development. https://www.space.com/nasa-darpa-nuclear-thermal-rocket-draco-2026 https://www.space.com/nasa-darpa-nuclear-thermal-rocket-drac...
- dclowd9901 3y ago> While some parts may reach the ground, the casualty risk – the likelihood of a person being hit – is very low They probably ought to put a number to this. When a person says "odds are very low," they usually mean like 1:1000. When a scientist says it, they mean like 1:100000000000000.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- yosito 3y agoYesterday I saw a large object burning up in the atmosphere over Thailand. Is there a website that tracks objects that have recently burned up in the earth's atmosphere where I could look it up and see if I can find what it was?
- Fabricio20 3y agoI'd give https://in-the-sky.org/satmap_worldmap.php https://in-the-sky.org/satmap_worldmap.php a try, it might not contain the debree you are looking for however. Make sure to check the checkboxes below the map! At least you can go back in time and maybe spot the deorbit procedure or similar.
- curiousObject 3y agohttps://fireballs.imo.net/members/imo_view/browse_reports/ https://fireballs.imo.net/members/imo_view/browse_reports/ There are two reports from Thailand at around that date
- araes 3y agoLooks like related events. An orange fireball at 19:00 in NE Bangkok and then a green fireball in SE Bangkok at 21:00. Fireball reporting's a cool one I had not seen before. I'll add https://www.keeptrack.space/app/ https://www.keeptrack.space/app/ to the list of suggestions. Although it may be more intimidating than helpful. Neat site though, has 3D globe height tracking and in the upper right you can filter with the layer menu for "rocket bodies" and "debris". Very few sites I've found that can filter for debris objects. Be careful if your GPU is low-end though, it can be a resource hog. Also, satellite.js and https://github.com/shashwatak/satellite-js/wiki/Sites-using-satellite.js https://github.com/shashwatak/satellite-js/wiki/Sites-using-... which is where I found KeepTrack
- djbusby 3y agoOr a website where its got curated video of things burning up in the sky. Always awesome.
- ls612 3y ago
- steelbrain 3y agoI was curious so looked it up, this is what the batteries look like: https://spaceflight101.com/iss-expedition-47/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/ISS-Battery-ORU.jpg https://spaceflight101.com/iss-expedition-47/wp-content/uplo... (from https://archive.is/D1qbD https://archive.is/D1qbD / https://spaceflight101.com/iss-sets-up-for-battery-switch-c2v2-testing/ https://spaceflight101.com/iss-sets-up-for-battery-switch-c2...) I wonder how they would remake the battery chemistry if they were to use all the latest advancements.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 3y agoThe second link has dimensions, and they're huge: about 1 by 1 by 0.5 meters, weighing 169 kg each. https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20050215412/downloads/20050215412.pdf https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20050215412/downloads/20... has some more details. The "deadface load" (a term basically not seen anywhere except in these batteries) seems to be related to discharging them to a safe voltage (possibly at end of life before disposal, or generally before maintenance). "From 2017 to 2021, the nickel-hydrogen batteries were replaced by lithium-ion batteries." according to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_system_of_the_International_Space_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_system_of_the_Inter...
- NikkiA 3y agoProbably the same, NASA has been making batteries out of Lithium where appropriate for 60 years, so they chose that chemistry for a reason (most likely its non-toxicity and relative safety for a crewed space station)
- krallja 3y agoThis article has a photo of the pallet after its “deorbit toss” by Canadarm: https://gizmodo.com/massive-iss-cargo-pallet-reentry-earth-march-2024-1851317508 https://gizmodo.com/massive-iss-cargo-pallet-reentry-earth-m...
- a3w 3y agoNeed banana for scale.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago
- perihelions 3y agoAren't nickel salts toxic heavy metals and environmental pollutants? This is the type of battery they're deorbiting: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickel–hydrogen_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickel–hydrogen_battery ("...chemical reduction of Ni(III) into Ni(II) in the cathode") There's a closed industrial city in Russia so heavy with nickel pollution, you can supposedly taste it, - "“When gases are coming out of the pipes, you feel it,” says restaurant owner Eldar Aliyev. “From copper it has a sweet taste; from nickel, a different taste. Now, though, you taste it less.”" https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2016/sep/15/norilsk-red-river-russias-most-polluted-city-clean https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2016/sep/15/norilsk-red-r... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norilsk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norilsk
- userbinator 3y agoRelative to the whole earth, this is an absolutely tiny amount. "The solution to pollution is dilution."
- teraflop 3y agoAs a point of comparison, the total amount of nickel in the Earth's oceans is approximately 1 billion tons.
- HlessClaudesman 3y agoOK thats a big number, but we are talking about spreading heavy elements around the atmosphere, some portion of which will end up in the soil, then in us. Let's examine a reductio ad absurdum of a medium term future where we have 1000x more space vehicles all taking space dumps into the atmosphere. Would that be best practice? Is there a better norm we could establish today?
- CaptArmchair 3y agoIf de-orbiting is your concern, then I would suggest taking a step back and considering the impact on our atmosphere of increasing the number of launches. This isn't a theoretical question. There's growing awareness among researchers that there's a need to research how the gasses and particles produced by rocket launches at scale could have an impact on the atmosphere. https://newsinteractives.cbc.ca/features/2023/rocket-pollution/ https://newsinteractives.cbc.ca/features/2023/rocket-polluti...
- happytiger 3y agoWe are so lucky we have such good and big oceans.
- tetha 3y agoI got an alert about this in KATWARN yesterday. It was kinda funny and curious for a second that this wasn't about yet another WW2 bomb, but instead an alert about... objects from space? Hah. I'm too far north to see much I think, but my parents live pretty close to the ground path. Maybe they can take some cool pictures.
- jll29 3y agoAt 1719 CET yesterday, the NINA citizen warning app ( https://www.bbk.bund.de/EN/Home/home_node.html https://www.bbk.bund.de/EN/Home/home_node.html ) triggered a German wide alert. Usually, small regions are marked to indicate bad weather situations like storms, floods, I have never seen a country-scope alert before. Since the whole of Germany was marked in orange, I read the explanation was a low-likelihood threat warning caused by ISS battery debris (rather than an invasion from the East).
- junon 3y agoWtf Nina didn't tell me anything at all, I have those alerts set on high. That's... concerning.
- dotancohen 3y agoFunny thing is, the ground track of this debris goes right over both London then Berlin after the estimated reentry point. Any late pieces just might reenter over one of those two WWII rival cities.
- InCityDreams 3y ago"Don't mention the war."
- jamiek88 3y agoRival cities! What a delightful way to describe the ww2 relationship!
- kimi 3y ago"The reentry will occur between -51.6 degrees South and 51.6 degrees North" -> "We have no f** idea of where or when it will come down, but at least we can assess it won't hit Santa Claus".
- zipfelchappe 3y agoExactly. We can't calculate the re-entry of some batteries, but we managed to land on the moon half a century ago.
- kataklasm 3y agoThat's partly because the drag effect of the atmosphere depends on the solar activity. Meaning, depending solar activity an object will start aerobraking higher up or lower down in the atmosphere. That of course drastically impacts the time it takes the object to fall out of orbit and since we can't really predict solar activity we cannot precisely predict when nor where this battery pack will hit the ground.
- krallja 3y agoThe Moon landing was powered and had lots of telemetry. This is an uninstrumented, unpowered box that was released over three years ago.
- blueflow 3y agoGo to the nearest pond and skip rocks. Try to predict how many times a rock will skip. This is a fundamental problem with chaotic probability.
- superjan 3y agoYes, and: “which is now predicted for around 18:56 CET on 8 March +/- 0.4 day” Prediction specified down to the minute with but the error bars are measured in days.
- globalnode 3y agoif this was china dumping stuff back to earth can you imagine the media storm? here its like oh well, we dont care so neither should you.
- dotnet00 3y agoPresumably you're comparing to the hysteria around the rocket falling back to Earth from some time ago. While the hysteria was a little overblown, there was a pretty important difference, these batteries were heavy and dense, making them pretty likely to pretty much entirely burn up on the way down. The rocket body was large and lightweight, so it was more likely to have debris survive all the way down to the surface. On top of that, this was an exceptional circumstance, the planned controlled disposal ended up becoming unavailable and potentially grounded for months, while the batteries were an increasing safety hazard. On the other hand, that rocket was intentionally designed this way with no regard for attempting to perform a controlled reentry.
- jerlam 3y agoChina's already re-entered two space stations. Do you remember any media storm?
- globalnode 3y agosure i do, 2021 there was some hysteria
- lupusreal 3y agoCurious that you phrased it as a hypothetical. And I don't remember any hysteria about pollution from China's reentries, just some about their developing space capabilities in general.