6 ms·
New York will send National Guard to subways after a string of violent crimes
- 34679 3y ago"Passengers are free to refuse the searches and leave the station." But are they free to take public transportation to work?
- jghn 3y agoAlso, what happens in practice if they refuse. Years ago in a different major US city, the local authorities had set up semi-random TSA style checkpoints for subway stations as a pilot project. When I was on my way home from work they were set up at the station where I'd get on the subway. I refused and left, deciding I'd rather walk home. I got about 5 mins down the road when I realized a couple of large men were running after me. They were clearly cops, though plain clothes. As they caught up to me one pushed me so I'd stop and they blocked my path. Gave me all kinds of grief, wanting to know why I refused. There was an obvious implication that I'd done something wrong. I gave a few cursory answers to their questions, then started responding with "Am I being detained". The latter only incited them further. Thankfully at some point they gave up instead of actually detaining me. They chewed me out, told me they were going to radio their buddies at upcoming stations so I wouldn't try to get on there either, and stormed off.
- h2odragon 3y agohttps://notthebee.com/article/crime-is-down-but-new-york-is-mobilizing-1000-national-guardsmen-to-do-bag-checks-in-nycs-subway-system https://notthebee.com/article/crime-is-down-but-new-york-is-...
- bhpm 3y agoUber and Lyft shareholders rejoice?
- rightbyte 3y agoIt is a really bad idea to make soldiers do police work. They were not recruited with the kind of mental stability in mind that you need to deal with all the BS cops need to deal with.
- bhpm 3y agoThe optics are also really, really bad. I recall putting my bags through a scanner and walking through a metal detector when I visited Beijing in 2018. My first thought was “wow, must suck to live in a police state like this, can’t even take transit without being searched.”
- galuggus 3y agothe optics maybe be bad but violent crime is extremely low. I've never felt fear of being mugged or attacked in China.
- para_parolu 3y agoThe more totalitarian country is the more government protects monopoly on violence.
- bhpm 3y agoYour perception of your own personal safety is not an objective measure of crime and should not form the basis of a policing strategy. https://apnews.com/article/trump-bragg-new-york-manhattan-nypd-4c0cb6ef067b2e3f2358ec9542c900cd https://apnews.com/article/trump-bragg-new-york-manhattan-ny... “crime across the five boroughs is nowhere near the levels seen in the 1990s, and while there was a rise in 2022, those figures are already trending down this year.”
- rahimnathwani 3y agoYour perception of your own personal safety is not an objective measure of crime FTFY Reported crime is not an objective measure of crime and should not form the basis of a policing strategy. When police cease to act on reports of crime, people have no incentive to report crime (except for major property crime which might be covered by insurance, and things like murder). This is why we can't trust the crime stats where I live (San Francisco).
- thmsths 3y agoThis just boggles my mind. First time I heard about this was when I saw the headline on Fox News, and I initially thought it was just an hyperbole. But now I see it repeated in more reputable media orgs and I still can't understand how this is happening. The NYPD has one of the largest police budgets in the world, they have their own intelligence division and even overseas offices, and yet they seem unable to be able to station officers on the subway and now the national guard needs to step up. How did it come to this?
- jghn 3y agoI do wonder how much of this is data driven vs a combination of fear mongering by the usual suspects and reacting to fear mongering, and thus causing its own fear issues. Granted homicide isn't the only violent crime in the world but there were the headlines a week or so ago that homicide rates were far higher in the states complaining about NYC's crime than NYC has. Is it really *that* dangerous?
- yunwal 3y agoNo, NYC is far, far safer than other large US cities. It’s the subject of attention because NYC is always the subject of attention.
- tekla 3y agoNo. NYC crime is lower than almost every major city. It's always fun when finding out someone who lives in a rural area has a higher per capita crime rate than NYC while they complain about how NYC is a crime shithole.
- psunavy03 3y agoPer capita crime will still be more densely concentrated in areas of higher population density. So yes, NYC could have a lower crime rate than a rural area by number of people, but still have it be much more "in your face" because all those crimes are happening in a smaller geographical footprint. And crime being "in your face" as opposed to happening where you don't notice it is what makes people think "wow, this is a shithole."
- inemesitaffia 3y agoJordan Neely
- mjhay 3y agoThis sounds like just sensational panic being exploited by Hochul to distract from her incompetence. The MTA is a mess, but it's a mess because of mismanagement by the state of NY. Crime has been trending downward. There was an increase in major crime in January, but it's dropped again. Barring some strange explation otherwise, that can be chalked up to a statistical artifact against a long-term decline: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/06/nyregion/nyc-subway-crime.html https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/06/nyregion/nyc-subway-crime... > In mid-2022, there was about one violent crime per one million rides on the subway, according to a New York Times analysis. Since then, the overall crime rate has fallen and ridership has increased, making the likelihood of being a victim of a violent crime even more remote. Last year, overall crime in the transit system fell nearly 3 percent compared with 2022 as the number of daily riders rose 14 percent. > The downward trend stalled early this year, with the number of major crimes in the transit system jumping in January before dipping again in February. Through March 3, there had been three homicides in the system, compared with one in the same period last year, according to police data. Overall, major crimes, including felony assaults, burglaries and grand larcenies, have increased 13 percent so far this year, the data shows.
- John23832 3y ago> This sounds like just sensational panic being exploited by Hochul to distract from her incompetence. The MTA is a mess, but it's a mess because of mismanagement by the state of NY. This 100%. Sensationalism. She's just using high profile recent issues to _look_ like she's doing something.
- DinaCoder99 3y agoSometimes it seems like violence is the only solution modern american politicians can conceive of, even if it's an insane waste of both money and human effort and doesn't work. How can this do anything but embarrass the city?
- kylehotchkiss 3y agoI love it. Just sitting here daydreaming how nice transit in San Diego could be if the trolley had just one or two officers per station and one on the train. The residents of mega apartments built on the stations would actually use them. The parking situation downtown could improve. The evening congestion would lighten. People would rather struggle with parking and traffic even if they live at a transit station with the trains in their current unpoliced state.
- anon291 3y agoPolicing is a climate issue, for those who care.
- ctvo 3y agoThis is quite the backdoor to bring back stop and frisk[1]. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop-and-frisk_in_New_York_City https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop-and-frisk_in_New_York_Cit...
- djohnston 3y agoAll the enforcement won’t matter if the DA continues to release repeat offenders. A tiny minority of people commit a significant proportion of crime in the city, whether they’re detained at the end of a glock or an M4 doesn’t change the long term outcome if they’re back on the streets the next day.
- John23832 3y agoAs a New Yorker, let me just say that the idea that there has been an increase in crime on the subways is overblown. There have been some "high profile" incidents, but by the raw numbers the crime on the subway has been down year over year. WAY fewer people use the subway/transit daily than did 5 years ago. Even percentage-wise the numbers are down.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoWhy Jordan Neely then?
- old_lakey 3y agoI would think increased police presence on the trains and platforms would be a more effective use of resources, and would also deter other (much more common) problems on the train that don't involve guns and knives. MTA commuters will be inconvenienced without feeling much safer, and the narrative that NYC is some crime infested hole that needs to have the military sent in to establish martial law will continue. NYC is incredibly safe, so much safer than where I live now in the NY capital region. Seems like a weird move on the part of Governor Hochul, I'm not sure what constituency it's supposed to play to.