8 ms·
The Brotherhood of Morons
- ericyd 3y agoI got part way through and quit. I appreciate the author's perspective, but I'm kind of tired of people so adamantly avoiding empathy. It's easy to say someone is acting stupidly; it's much harder to put yourself in their shoes and understand why they might be acting that way. I dunno, maybe there is some wisdom I missed because I didn't finish it.
- theragra 3y agoAgree. Moreover, I don't agree with the author that some people are just stupid and that's it. Especially, with the surgeon example. I really don't think a surgeon can be stupid per se. That should be very rate occurrence. More like people do stupid things all the time. Including author, who is too smug, which I also consider stupid.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoAbentmindedness is often mistaken for stupidity. In my area, we have at least two world-ranked labs. We have Nobel Laureates, driving around. I encounter "stupid" drivers, all the time. I am one, too. I'm no Nobelate, but I'm smarter than the average bear.
- SamPatt 3y agoThis is the problem with redefining commonly used terms like stupid. We tend to view it as lacking intelligence, and intelligence we often define as something like IQ, but the author explicitly rejects that and makes it about destructive (to themselves and others) behavior. The doctors were likely not stupid according to the standard definition, but were harmful towards both their patients and themselves, thus stupid according to the new definition. If the article didn't bother bringing up intelligence at all and instead focused on destructive behaviors, it would have made more sense.
- drewcoo 3y ago> This is the problem with redefining commonly used terms like stupid. Maybe like Eskimos have many words for snow, we need many words for stupid. Or idiots should learn to use thesauruses. /s
- slowmovintarget 3y agoWe have many words. Foolishness and stupidity are common companions, but one does not require the other. Intelligent people behave foolishly all the time. The distinction is one of a failure of either imagination or effort. We have other words like ignorance, incompetence, impairment, and none of these require a lack of cognitive ability, though the latter implies diminished capacity. Bombast, however, typically seeks to oversimplify for the sake of provocation.
- nazgulsenpai 3y agoThe "smugness" of the author is what made me close the tab 3 sections in. And totally agree, some of the smartest people I know are also the most aloof.
- postexitus 3y agoGood point. Interesting that he claims all groups of people contain a certain percentage of "Morons" but then he says he only surrounds himself with brilliant people, which, by definition, makes him the moron.
- xanathar 3y agoI quote: > "The remainder are simply stupid. This is approximately the composition of the organization writ large. The number of people at this organization who dislike their job, their stakeholders, and their salary but don't leave even though they no longer have the energy to work is astonishing, and that alone is enough to constitute stupidity as per Cipolla's definition." Because, apparently, a person cannot be burned out and at the same time still need food, a home, or whatever they needs a salary for, not to mention they might be on temporary visas and cannot risk being unemployed or any of the other billions of totally sensible reasons keeping them from leaving their jobs. So to answer your "maybe"... nope, no empathy, no wisdom.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- pdimitar 3y agoWell then we should further separate the stupids: (1) those who are not actively malicious because they are burned out or even with awful health conditions and cannot bring themselves to be more productive and benevolent but still need the paycheck and (2) the a-hole MBAs or careerists who simply use the company as a trampoline to a better paycheck somewhere else and to tell with the consequences if they set back 1000+ families' financial well-being.
- cstrahan 3y ago> It's easy to say someone is acting stupidly; it's much harder to put yourself in their shoes and understand why they might be acting that way. This statement presupposes that there is a reason. Many people simply act completely irrationally, so the only "reason" for their actions that one can come up with is the overly reductive "well, their neurons fired in such a way that resulted in them doing <whatever>". I suspect avoiding generalities would assist discourse, so here's a concrete example to analyze: consider a senior (maybe even staff level) software developer, trying to write a loop. He writes a bunch of code, runs it (via tests, or executing the software itself), and finds that it doesn't work. So now he he changes the "<" to "<=". Still doesn't work. Now he changes that to ">". Still doesn't work. Now he changes that to ">=". Still doesn't work. Now he thinks "prime numbers are sometimes important, hm...", so he rounds the end of the range to the nearest prime number. Still doesn't work. Now he increments by two, instead of one. Still doesn't work. On a whim, now he changes the numeric type from an integer to a float, though he (of course) couldn't explain why that would change anything (all other things being equal in this scenario, it wouldn't). It still doesn't work. Etc, etc, etc. This sort of pattern continues for the next couple hours until the code happens to work for the scenarios tested (though is still incorrect and will eventually fail in production). What is the "reason" for this behavior? Or, more importantly, why would someone regularly engage in such behavior? Why, as opposed to reasoning about the code, instead spend hours being superstitious, cargo culting, guess-and-checking, etc? Why never once consider pre-/post-conditions, loop invariants, sketch out a small informal proof by induction, etc? Yes, some instances of bad decision making are due to unfortunate circumstances (stress, mental health, etc). But there are times where people simply demonstrate that they are, putting it kindly, not competent. That doesn't make them any less deserving of love and care, but they are still (with no negative sentiment or judgement intended) incompetent.
- RandomLensman 3y agoBecause the behavior "worked" (i.e., solved a sufficient number of problems) in the past? Maybe because it is easier than other approaches?
- ericyd 3y agoI totally agree incompetence exists in the world, and totally agree it can be frustrating to observe or deal with. If the article had been titled "Brotherhood of Incompetence" I might have reacted differently. Even so, I find the author's stance to be off-putting. They write > The first kind reads about "stupid people" and laughs. And then go on to suggest that this is the "wrong" reaction, that stupid behavior is an insidious societal ill that should be treated with grave seriousness (obviously I'm exaggerating the author's words a bit). I find that laughing about circumstances which are both 1) outside your control, and 2) annoying is a much better response than stewing in my negative emotions and blaming the world for being incompetent. Better for my personal health, and better for those around me in that I'm not so bitter and unpleasant. All that said, I love your closing line > That doesn't make them any less deserving of love and care, but they are still (with no negative sentiment or judgement intended) incompetent. This aligns very much with my personal perspective.
- dboreham 3y agoIt's just an algorithm.
- helpfulContrib 3y ago[dead]
- low_tech_love 3y agoThere is no wisdom, it's supposed to be a rant. I don't think empathy applies to this kind of wide-ranged broad-stroked text. If he was attacking someone specifically and there was some side to the situation that he was willingly ignoring I might agree with you, but I think in this specific case (i.e. just a brain dump) this is interesting; you either identify with it or you don't, and both reactions are just as valid. I for example identified completely, and enjoyed the text. You might be thinking now "oh ok, another asshole to go with the first one", but let me try to justify my view. I believe that the stupid people he describes are not "accidentally" stupid, or simply people who don't know better. These are people who are willingly, intentionally stepping on other people's toes as a way of life. Some people are just like that: they don't see it as a fundamental, basic tenet of social life to respect others, solve problems through dialog and --- yes --- have empathy towards them. Some people think that bothering and pushing themselves (and their views) against others is their god-given right; as if manipulating those around you (in all the possible meanings of manipulation) is not only a valid attitude but possibly the only way to achieve anything. I don't feel bad to discriminate against such people. Actually, I think it's unfair and disrespectful to bundle them together with those who are honestly ignorant or dumb, who can't really help but do stupid things because they don't know better. If we can't have honest conversations about this, i.e. about the differentiation between these two groups, all we are doing is validating and reinforcing the behavior of the first group (by not holding them accountable).
- ericyd 3y agoI agree that there are people in the world who regularly trample on common notions of ethics and morals. It is really sad and frustrating that such people exist. I still find empathy to be a better reaction than blame and contempt. It is foundational to the way I choose to live my life. And with this response, I'm pushing my values on you in a way which is probably immoral! The author suggests that this "Brotherhood of Morons" is a recurring theme in their writing. The recurring theme is my writing is a simple mantra which I find brings me peace: we are all just humans doing our best in a difficult world.
- pdimitar 3y ago
- ouraf 3y agoBeing a bit more empathic to the author, the frustration expressed is understandable and it's VERY HARD to put yourself in Ben Shapiro's shoes, even if it is for the greater goal of being able to call him stupid without being considered "apathetic".
- nataliste 3y agoFTA: >Then there is the third kind of person who, upon reading anything like the quote above, immediately insists that the complainant must secretly be the insufferable one, because actually smart people don't experience frustration for reasons unknown. The implication is that they're the smart ones because they live in a world where the ultimate marker of intelligence is not the ability to discern sound action from unsound, but instead a grotesque meta-intelligence which manifests as the inexplicable belief that no action is ever deserving of contempt, and any deviation from this belief is a humility problem. Their judgement usually comes with a vomitous attempt at a cutting remark which, coming from individuals best described as a sentient LinkedIn posts, invariably morphs into the flaccid "you aren't as smart as you think you are" or "you sound insufferable". >I just wanted to take a moment to tell the third group to go fuck themselves.
- ericyd 3y agolol definitely didn't get this far in the article, sounds about right
- jsd1982 3y agoThe smug is hard to get past; stopped reading a few paragraphs in.
- borbulon 3y ago> What Taleb calls the Intellectual Yet Idiot (IYI) - someone who has the mannerisms and interests of a superficially intelligent person but who nonetheless is unable to self-reflect or deal with nuance, such as the Harvard-educated Ben Shapiro. I worked in Harvard Square for 5 years (dead center, across the street from Curious George, between the Greenhouse and the Coop), and it was always my assertion that Harvard is full of Well-Educated Idiots.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI had an art teacher that had a poster on his wall: "An education is no substitute for intelligence." Some of the smartest people that I've ever met, had little to no education.
- pdimitar 3y ago[waves to say hi] I never studied computer science, I can't code a graph path-finding algorithm out of memory and yet I've been told by many former colleagues that I am one of the best programmers they ever met. Which is quite hilarious because I still think I am quite bad, to this day, after 22 years of career. And no this is not humble-bragging, more like to outline how different our perspectives on ourselves can be from the perception of everyone else. But this approach, I think, is what is keeping me intellectually honest. I am self-indulgent for like 2-3 days a year and the rest of the time I always think I have to learn yet another thing, and to practice it well.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI'm a high-school dropout. GED. I have a couple of friends that are quite rich, and run a successful company. Both dropouts. I think that she never even got her GED.
- boxed 3y agoFunny.. but that sounds like Taleb.
- twic 3y ago
- fvdessen 3y agoI remember at the beginning of the Ukraine war, that the Ukrainians were very hopeful to win it, as the Russian military leadership was taking completely stupid decisions one after another. And they still are doing very stupid things, but they are not losing, at that's because the steady work of a large group of determined people, even of stupid people, even with a lot of mistakes, usually ends up with greater success than what a few genius can achieve on their own. This is why most religions favor the weak and the 'idiots', and why wise people remind smart people to not insult idiots, because at the end of the day they do most of the work and make most things happen
- steve1977 3y agoI guess the most “successful” setup would be masses of stupid people manipul… lead by a few geniuses.
- empath-nirvana 3y agoI couldn't get through the whole insufferable mess, but I'm going to argue with this point. > The first type, my favourite commenters, whose grim-faced no-nonsense corporate visages grace standups across the world. Thanks to their fearless leadership and keen business sense, I have it on good authority that all projects are scheduled to move from red status to green status despite all those risks unfortunately materializing, which is no one's fault in particular. Despite the various challenges we have faced over the years and lack of forward progress, I think this retro is the one where things are going to change. I have someone like this on my team, and let me tell you, I _adore_ this person. He is not an idiot. We tell him the unvarnished truth about what is going on, and he massages it into something that is closer to what upper management wants to hear. It actually takes a lot of intelligence to do this in such a way that it isn't blatantly dishonest and also doesn't get your project cancelled. Being brutally honest with upper management about the status of your project is a sure fire way to _lose your job_ at many companies. And by the way, the people he's reporting to are _also_ not idiots and realize that the message is being massaged and have to read between the lines and so on up the chain. I'm going to close with this quote: > But most days, if you’re aware enough to give yourself a choice, you can choose to look differently at this fat, dead-eyed, over-made-up lady who just screamed at her kid in the checkout line. Maybe she’s not usually like this. Maybe she’s been up three straight nights holding the hand of a husband who is dying of bone cancer. Or maybe this very lady is the low-wage clerk at the motor vehicle department, who just yesterday helped your spouse resolve a horrific, infuriating, red-tape problem through some small act of bureaucratic kindness. Of course, none of this is likely, but it’s also not impossible. It just depends what you want to consider. If you’re automatically sure that you know what reality is, and you are operating on your default setting, then you, like me, probably won’t consider possibilities that aren’t annoying and miserable. But if you really learn how to pay attention, then you will know there are other options. It will actually be within your power to experience a crowded, hot, slow, consumer-hell type situation as not only meaningful, but sacred, on fire with the same force that made the stars: love, fellowship, the mystical oneness of all things deep down. > Not that that mystical stuff is necessarily true. The only thing that’s capital-T True is that you get to decide how you’re gonna try to see it. -- David Foster Wallace
- mwenge 3y ago
- codevark 3y ago[dead]
- baerrie 3y agoYes people are stupid but many are stupid, smart, and clever all at different times and in different ways. To simplify that there is a class of stupid people responsible for everything wrong is to imply the inverse that there is a class of smart people that are responsible for everything right which is totally elitist and ridiculous
- SamPatt 3y agoThere's a lot of truth in this, but I struggle with the conclusion of "avoid stupid (destructive) people at all costs." While I don't doubt this is best for personal satisfaction and sanity, it feels lacking in compassion. An example: I have teenage children, and they have some friends in school who fit the stupid description from the article (destructive behaviors). They grew up in unstable homes and didn't have good relationships / behaviors to learn from. My kids recognize their friends' poor decision making, and are sometimes dumbfounded by their behavior. It gives my kids a realistic view into the lives of others. Also, even destructive people aren't destructive all the time (at least at that point cutting ties is the obvious choice). It would be easier, and perhaps safer, to push my children to not associate with them - is that really the best policy?
- rayiner 3y ago> It would be easier, and perhaps safer, to push my children to not associate with them - is that really the best policy? Yes, because a child's peers have more influence on their development than your parenting: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-scientific-fundamentalist/200809/the-50-0-50-rule-why-parenting-has-virtually-no-effect https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-scientific-funda... "Behavior geneticists contend that the rough rule of thumb when it comes to the determinants of child development is 50-0-50, that is, roughly 50% of the variance in personality, behavior, and other traits is heritable (influenced by genes), roughly 0% by the shared environment (what happens within the family and is experienced by all siblings), and roughly 50% by the nonshared environment (what happens inside and outside of the family, not shared by siblings)." As an adult, you might be able to compartmentalize dysfunctional people and evaluate their behavior in a neutral manner. But children are not rational like adults. Their frontal cortex isn't fully developed until their mid-20s.
- JamesBarney 3y agoYeah, to expand on this, peer groups probably have a larger impact on your child's outcome than parenting when looking at a long enough time horizon.
- lbhdc 3y ago
- aredox 3y agoVery ironic to read this... when Taleb is himself behaving more and more like an inhinged idiot - and no, I am not talking about his takes about the Middle-East, I am talking about his general behaviour and "reasoning"...
- icyberbullyu 3y agoMisanthropic narcissism, the article. I'm smarter than everyone la la la la. What's the solution? Just sit around and bask in how smart you are while the hoards of depth-grovellers endlessly toil away for nuggets of neoplasmid. You are smart. We are dumb. I get it.
- angiosperm 3y agoDidn't.
- ergonaught 3y agoHe’s clear enough what he’s talking about (and what the original book talks about), and that this isn’t about intelligence, but you couldn’t tell it from the bulk of comments as I write. I’ll just stop there.
- stevefan1999 3y ago[flagged]
- boblob-law 3y agoReal "idiots" are people that have convinced themselves that they are not "idiots". We all do and say stupid idiotic things all the time.
- jihadjihad 3y ago"When a true genius appears in the world, you may know him by this sign, that the dunces are all in confederacy against him."
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- bigbillheck 3y agoBeing incredibly angry all the time is no way to live your life.
- corytheboyd 3y agoGood lord, I hope I never work with this person. It’s true that some people produce more output than others, but shitting all over under-performers just discourages and humiliates them. Absolute garbage human being behavior. The mature, productive move is to try to help. If you truly cannot level someone up you may need to make a difficult decision, but that doesn’t at all mean you need to be a huge dick.
- NickC25 3y ago>The mature, productive move is to try to help. If you truly cannot level someone up you may need to make a difficult decision, but that doesn’t at all mean you need to be a huge dick. I've been on the receiving end of this before. The problem is there are a lot of folks out there with tremendous subject matter intelligence, and often times they are pushed into management. A good amount of these folks don't really have the skills to deal with people as people, not as subordinates. They "teach" to the best of their ability, but this, sometimes, comes up short, and their way of dealing with the people they can't "teach" often involves making a tough decision. They don't think their way of doing things is dick-ish, and in my case, the person wasn't intentionally trying to be a dick, he just happened to act in a manner that made everyone think he was. Human relationship dynamics are tricky, and doubly tricky in the working world. Everyone is different, and this can make things outright impossible when it comes to setting expectations and managing people in a uniform or case-by-case way. Thankfully, I don't manage people for a living.
- theamk 3y agoI don't see author discouraging and humiliating anyone.. author's advice is pretty straightforward, and most of the text is justification of that action: > I'll be making some moves to rectify this, even if it means having to spend more energy working elsewhere - the risk of a fool destroying our department's budget and putting me out of a job is too high So they will be moving away from their department to some other one. Based on their other blog posts, I am sure they will say it all diplomatically and without burning any bridges, with some made-up reason about passion or self-improvement or company vision. This seems to be better for everyone - author will be happier, department they left might be happier too. (Trying to level-up everyone is a noble goal, but is a very hard work. Trying to level-up someone who does not want or can not level up, all while you have your own tasks to do, is even worse and can be extremely demotivating. I don't blame author on changing department instead.)
- helpfulContrib 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- randusername 3y agoIs this satire? I feel like I'm reading commentary from a strictly classical economist lamenting that our economy is worsened by all those pesky market participants that are ignorant of economic theory and therefore make irrational financial decisions. Then there's this line: > The implication is that [my critics are] the smart ones because they live in a world where the ultimate marker of intelligence is not the ability to discern sound action from unsound, but instead a grotesque meta-intelligence which manifests as the inexplicable belief that no action is ever deserving of contempt, and any deviation from this belief is a humility problem. What about Chesterton's Fence? Or root-cause analysis? Those aren't just for code! Contempt is an ugly word, so the burden of proof should be pretty high. After all, we're trying to understand and fix and prevent "actions that harm everyone" and not just classify them, right?
- ouraf 3y agoI can find some peace by disagreeing with the author and consider stupidity as a quality for actions instead of people.
- angiosperm 3y agoIt is hazardous to comment on this topic. However, I would remind the reader of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn's maxim, "The boundary between good and evil runs through every man's heart". The time each of us spends stupid is identically that same sigma. Some are seen to keep to themselves better during such times, mostly through happenstance, though a few by bitter experience. It takes enormous effort to look back at your sigma time and reflect, which rarely returns better results than chagrin. Keeping consequential actions better confined to the >sigma times is the best we can hope for.
- noSyncCloud 3y agoThe linked story[0] is just as good if not better. 0: https://ludic.mataroa.blog/blog/i-accidentally-saved-half-a-million-dollars/ https://ludic.mataroa.blog/blog/i-accidentally-saved-half-a-...
- Simon_ORourke 3y agoThe author presupposes perfect knowledge. Take my precious role where the head of the IT department squandered a year's budget on some half baked reporting system cooked up by a big player in corporate data systems. Now to the outsider this may have looked like stupidity at the time, but it was actually banditry according to this analysis, since the IT manager was getting foreign golf vacations paid for entirely by the company selling in their half baked reporting system.