6 ms·
To be clear, from the article, the routers themselves cost $7,800. And, if I'm rolling out a state infrastructure, and wondering what I can put in place for th
by ghshephard 15y ago
To be clear, from the article, the routers themselves cost $7,800. And, if I'm rolling out a state infrastructure, and wondering what I can put in place for the next 10 years to serve as a foundation, you could certainly do worse than the 3945 - it's a very flexible ISR, and, all-things being equal, it's probably not worth the hassle of putting 2921s in some locations and 3945s in others. Who knows how much bandwidth you'll want on these high-speed fiber connections 5+ years from now - the 3945 is rated for 350 megabits/second (with features), the 2921 tops out at 75 megabits.
Amortized over 10 years, I would have chosen the 3945 everywhere versus sticking 2921s in some places (the ISR that would have been an alternative) and 3945s in others. Single Security Policy. Single IOS update Policy. Zero doubt as to what features will run in a particular location.
I think what most people have difficulty with is that they are comparing this decision to roll out a state communications infrastructure with the fact that they can go connect a $60 linksys wrt54G in their house and serve a dozen people without breaking a sweat. And get wireless as well! The issues involved in scaling that across the state, while looking to the future, and managing all that gear is a different challenge though.
I don't see any huge scandal here.
- clarky07 15y agoThat seems like a pretty silly argument to me. The library with 4 computers would be just fine with the $60 router. How is it any harder to manage that gear compared to managing the completely unneeded equipment that the local employees have no clue how to run. Not to mention spending $14k on upgrades for many places that don't need that particular upgrade. I don't care if it's a little simpler to buy all the same, it's absurd to spend millions and millions of taxpayer dollars on something that is completely unnecessary.
- glesica 15y agoI'm not really sure where it came from, but the Slashdot summary states that a lot of these things were never even un-boxed. If true, that's an incredible waste and far-outweighs any convenience or stability benefits gained by using homogeneous hardware. http://yro.slashdot.org/story/12/05/11/1937235/west-virginia-buys-22k-routers-with-stimulus-puts-them-in-small-schools http://yro.slashdot.org/story/12/05/11/1937235/west-virginia...
- ghshephard 15y agoInterestingly enough - I can see both sides of the argument. When I was building the IT infrastructure for SSN, I ran the company's IT and it's dozen employees on a $75 linksys (and a half-dozen Poweredge Dell Server) for the first 5-6 months. Eventually, we grew to around 20 employees, picked up a data center colo-cabinet for our customer apps and needed a bit more robustness, so I purchased a $300 used Cisco 2621xm, a couple T1 WICs for $500, and ran the company for the next year on that 3 mbit pipe - the company got to around 50 employees before we moved. For the first two years of its life I spent a grand total of $875 on routing hardware and 50 employees were able to get their work done (including code pushes to our data center) over that 3 mbit pipe. When I handed over network engineering, though, our last purchase order for networking equipment (with around 500 employees) - was north of $500K (including very hefty Cisco Discounts) (This isn't including the Data Center infrastructure - by then we had colo space in three data centers - just the corporate infrastructure for three buildings) It's hard to explain without living through it - but the decisions that make sense when you are small, and you aren't paying your network engineers $150K/year (fully loaded), and you aren't trying to figure out how to handle pager duty, and warehouse and deal with RMAs, and support various types of hardware, and worry about rotating inventory, and dealing with upgrade cycles, and manage security, and patch levels, and remote administrations - not even considering future feature enhancements and performance (75 mbits sounds great today - but what about the future?) - when you get to scale, the CapEx (the capital cost of the hardware) starts to have fewer consequences on a technology investment (particularly over 10 years) than the other elements. Not to mention that there are also political issues (Layer 8) associated with differing levels of services/features for small population centers versus large population centers. Yes - this does result in seemingly ludicrous situations like a 4 computer library being run on a ISR capable of running 350 mbits/second without breaking a sweat - but in 5-8 years from now, some technology administrator for the state will take over that infrastructure, and I can guarantee you that they won't be thinking "My God, we're over provisioned on our networking equipment" - but instead, "Thank goodness I have a few more years of runway before we have to replace all this gear." I realize I haven't fully fleshed out the argument as to why it might make sense to put these hefty branch routers into smaller locales, but hopefully it doesn't sound silly. Hey - at least they didn't roll out 6509s in all these libraries. Now that would be something I could rant against. :-)
- NoPiece 15y agoIf you are putting routers in a school that might serve a few thousand students and teachers, and a branch library that might be serve 5 patrons, you really can't afford to adopt a heterogeneous hardware strategy just to make admin easier. It is surely more cost effective to use the cheaper router, and replace them when necessary than to buy the uber-model that will still be state of the art in 10 years.
- jeffpersonified 15y agoBucket system needs into three categories (large, medium, small) and find three routers that best manage those needs. Hire a full-time government worker to facilitate categorization of each installation location and manage the installation. Replace upgrade as needed.
- ghshephard 15y agoYes - that's actually a reasonable alternative. I'm hoping that someone did the math, and looked at Option #1: $7800 Cisco 3945, $2800 Cisco 2921, $900 Cisco 1921 vs Option #2 - $7800 Cisco 3945 across the board) and then compared it with the costs of having to prematurely replace those 2921s/1921s when they realized the 75 mbits/second wasn't what it was in 2012 (or some service modules with cool feature (Telepresence?) wouldn't work in the 1921) Another thing to realize - they probably get one chance to upgrade their infrastructure like this. Sticking a 3945 in now means they can save money on upgrades for the next 10+ years.
- joelhaasnoot 15y agoGovernment money also seems to sometimes dry up as priorities are shifted - who says there'll be money over the next 10 years for upgrades.
- antiterra 15y agoI think you meant homogeneous, as in all the routers being the same?
- jeffpersonified 15y agoIt hardly seems like managing gear would be all that difficult at this kind of margin. Hire someone full-time at 100K annually who manages the systems and upgrades when necessary.
- dclowd9901 15y agoThis is pure, unadulterated nonsense. There are plenty of ways to manage everything you mentioned with a tiered approach to the IT needs of the municipalities of the state without resorting to grossly over accommodating every location. Hell, they could've even used some of that money for regional IT management positions, putting people back to work. Shame on you for justifying this nonsense in any way shape or form. This is textbook waste ala bureaucratic laziness.
- sliverstorm 15y agoTen years of IT wages seems a bit more costly than some fancy hardware, particularly when you remember the pension.
- thaumaturgy 15y agoDoes that in any way change his argument that the money could have been put to better use?
- readme 15y agoI don't think it does. In the example put forth in the article, the library had only four computers! In the case of just this one library, they could have had: ipads, kindles, more computers, more books and other media. I think it's kind of a no-brainer that this is a prime example of incompetence in government.
- bricestacey 15y agoThey would also need to hire someone to manage those devices which would cost maybe 2x the router year after year. It'd suck too (not going to get a competent person in that position).
- thaumaturgy 15y agoMy company provides free I.T. services, support, and sometimes equipment to non-profits and other community organizations. We would be happy to be the on-call techs for stuff like that. I would be surprised if there wasn't somebody in their area that does the same.
- ChristianMarks 15y agoThe nonsense about $60 linksys devices was addressed in the article. Did you bother to read it? CISCO quoted a $487 router. You expect the taxpayer to foot the bill because you're too lazy to keep track of which router you've installed at each location? I deal with bureaucrats like you all the time. This is the last place I would have expected to find them.
- moonchrome 15y agoThe bureaucrats I deal with would buy the various routers at best prices and then proceed to build a software system to track which router was installed where that would cost > top of the line routers and would be built by a company friendly to the person making the decision. Initial costs would be low to win the bid but many "required changes" would ramp the bill up. They would create software jobs and get optimal router pricing - if that's not efficiency I don't know what is !
- ChristianMarks 15y agoThose systems exist--CISCO has been selling them for years. Or have we identified another area ripe for disruption?
- Swannie 15y agoCISCO also sells Monitoring-aaS, which will do discovery, monitoring and upgrade for $xxx/device/yr.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- moonchrome 15y agoI can assure you that any existing software would fail to meet the requirements (hint - primary requirement being related to/friends with/lobbying the decision maker).
- sp332 15y agoThe other thing is that the bids had to be submitted very quickly or they risked not getting any funding at all. In that light, they can't really be blamed for not doing research into the most efficient allocation of money! (To be clear, I blame the stupid bid process that rewards rushed decisions and punishes anyone who stops to think.)
- keithpeter 15y agoYes, I have been there, bid by fax with 6h turnaround in one case but that was only a few thousand. Fix the process.