7 ms·
S.3819 – Shrinkflation Prevention Act of 2024
- CJefferson 3y agoThis seems entirely reasonable to me -- I shouldn't have to check products every time I rebuy them to see if they are smaller. If you want to make a smaller package, change the product in a clear way.
- dehrmann 3y agoI'd rather they mandate uniform unit-volume price labeling. This feels like micromanaging.
- compsciphd 3y agolets be honest, while unit-volume pricing is useful (though to me, mostly for comparing different products), they don't always result in memorable pricing values that are easy for most consumers to remember.
- pocketarc 3y agoI agree with you - I've seen this in other countries, where whatever you buy, companies can have their easy-to-manipulate price, but there's -always- the price per 100g/litre, so it's always easy to compare, even across products of different brands. This does feel a little like micromanaging but it does seem good. If someone buys the same product every week for 10 years, they're -never- going to be on the lookout for "has this product changed this week, is it smaller now?".
- webnrrd2k 3y agoI think unit pricing is already law in California, or at least lots of products have a price per unit. It's in smaller text on the price tag on the shelf, not on the items themselves.
- usr1106 3y agoUnit prices are the law where I live. I'd say I am very price-conscious shopper. I have a clear feeling about unit prices of many products. But I absolutely don't care about package size(1) or package price. (1) of course within limits suitable for our household. It doesn't make sense to buy stuff the won't be consumed before it's getting unusable. In the very old days in Germany chocolate was only allowed to sold in certain fixed sizes. 100 grams bars had >98% market share, although several other standardized sizes were allowed, too. With EU free markets that regulation had to be abandoned because it hindered free market access. I don't know whether unit price information was introduced at the same point in time, I wasn't living there at that time. But I still hate to see 90 grams and 282 grams chocolate bars where I live now.
- pmontra 3y agoHaving the price per kg or liter on the label is great to compare across the similar products on the same shelf. I do it all the time and in some cases it's the only information I look at. However it's not much useful to combat shrinkflation because if, let's say, icecreams shrink maybe you realize it only when you open the box at home and you get the feeling that something changed. Or if you notice that a pack of food that has always been 500 g is now 450 g. You can't remember with precision the old price per kg but you definitely suspect that the manufacturer is playing the shrinkflation game.
- xnx 3y agoAlso a big fan of unit pricing, though it is almost useless on toilet paper (rolls? sheets? square inches? what about ply?). Grams would probably make more sense.
- czl 3y agoTo make a product cheaper ingredients / process can be changed. How will product quality be protected? A law against “crapification”? If laws make product changes difficult what might the second order effects of these laws be?
- indigo0086 3y agoToo late for law, prepackaged foods are mostly garbage in
- nomilk 3y agoShrinking only works once though. When a customer is duped, they adjust expectations accordingly, and some consumers even 'punish' the brand by stopping buying that product altogether. The phenomena is annoying, but I don't think legislating against it is the correct approach. Australia has had some quite amazing laws that require 'per 100g' or 'cost per 100ml' pricing on the store label, which is incredibly helpful. I'd like to see more tools of those kinds.
- instagib 3y agoiirc, many businesses have deals about companies distributing products: they can’t sell the product for less than what it is sold at store #1, they cannot increase prices for a contract length, and more. So, companies are beholden to shareholders to increase profits and must find workarounds. New packaging and new formula same great taste are things to look for. I think my laundry detergent should be over 500% more concentrated by now compared to 20 years ago.
- jacobmarble 3y agoIs this what happens when I buy a box of cereal for $4 in 2014, and the same box of cereal for $4 in 2024, but the contents weigh 20% less in 2024?
- agent281 3y agoYes.
- MangoCoffee 3y agoyes. the only thing that hasn't shrunk seems to be tech. my current laptop is a 14nm+++ Intel chip that cost 1k when i bought it. the same 1k can get you a Intel 7 or TSMC 5nm AMD ryzen. Same money, but better cpu.
- Ekaros 3y agoYou are telling me that I pay more and I only get smaller stuff? That is horrible... They are stealing silicon from our products...
- spartanatreyu 3y agoNot smaller, denser. (Although in some cases still smaller)
- captainbland 3y agoI think there's a reasonable case to be made that new GPU SKUs are also good being released at higher price points or with more inflated product names than they would have had historically. E.g. a 4060 looks a lot like a product that might have been released as a xx50 series part in more historically normal market conditions.
- barbarr 3y agoHope this gains some traction in Congress. Shitflation is a thing that's been happening as well. [0] [0] https://jonatron.github.io/shitflation/ https://jonatron.github.io/shitflation/
- seydor 3y agoDoes this apply to digital services too? Isn't it basically making inflation illegal?
- agent281 3y agoI think it means that you need to keep the size the same and increase the price or keep the price per unit the same and decrease the size. I don't think digital services are considered to have shrinkflation.
- 0_____0 3y agoI'm getting a kick out of the idea of Amazon charging the same amount for ebooks but the font size slowly shrinking over time
- rvense 3y agoYou laugh, but if pixels (or ink) was the expensive part of making a book I'm absolutely sure we'd see this.
- Ekaros 3y agoActually we do see it... Compare hard-covers to soft-covers and then to trade paperbacks... I suppose you could make thinner and denser font in last one to make it even cheaper.
- prattmic 3y agoI think the closest analog to this is digital services getting worse rather than more expensive. For example, recently rather than increasing the price of Amazon Prime Video, the price has remained the same, but the product is worse (now has ads). That said, I don’t think this bill would target something like that, as it clearly discusses the “size” and “amount” of a product.
- agent281 3y ago
- throwaway5959 3y agoOr, I don’t know, don’t add $3 trillion to the national debt in 9 months.
- blitzar 3y agoI didnt hear people complaining when their wages went up and their stonks portfolio doubled.
- throwaway5959 3y agoMost people don’t own stocks (at least not directly) and wages only went up for the bottom quartile on an inflation adjusted basis.
- dehrmann 3y agoIronically, congress shouldn't want this because companies use shrinkflation to hide inflation, and congress is just as likely to get the blame as companies if people notice.
- grayfaced 3y agoCPI accounts for shrinkflation, so it's not hidden. Turns out data collectors pay attention to the numbers.
- paulirish 3y agoThis lo-fi blog https://www.mouseprint.org/category/downsiz/ https://www.mouseprint.org/category/downsiz/ is (probably) the best maintained documentation on shrinkflation. Maintained for over a decade by a former Massachusetts Assistant Attorney General in consumer protection.
- saurik 3y ago> Not later than 18 months after the date of enactment of this Act, the Commission shall promulgate regulations under section 553 of title 5, United States Code, to prohibit any manufacturer from engaging in shrinkflation. So, this is a law which states that there SHALL be regulation--who knows what form--to solve a problem that, for all we know, can't be solved in any reasonable way... but once this law is passed, there will be a new regulatory process (I guess in this case attached to the existing agency, though watch there be new people hired to concentrate on this specific issue) which won't care if their ideas are pointless or harmful as they are legally mandated to exist? I'd like to see a meta-law which prevents Congress from kicking the can down the road like this; if they don't know how to regulate something, they should form a subcommittee to investigate the problem and come up with a concrete solution that can be considered and voted on: it simply shouldn't be possible for them to make a law which says nothing more than "we all agree we hate X and so someone in the executive branch SHALL solve it for us within two years"... legislating should be the job of the legislative branch!
- silisili 3y agoEven if you can't prevent it directly, you could regulate labeling and shaming like Carrefour did[0]. Even better if you require companies to put big gaudy warnings on their products themselves when shrank(and replacing the previous size) like cigarette companies. 0 - https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/sep/14/carrefour-puts-shrinkflation-price-warnings-on-food-to-shame-brands https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/sep/14/carrefour-p...
- compsciphd 3y agothis is what most countries that have this do. If mandated surgeon general warnings on alcohol and tobacco products are legal, I'm not sure why such a mandated warning here wouldn't be.
- euroderf 3y agoIf Chevron is overturned, this will be more grist for the mill.
- forgetfreeman 3y agoClose to half of all inflation went to increased profits. That's a coy way of acknowledging markets used public awareness of supply chain and other real issues as cover to jack up prices. How is that not profiteering?
- thegrim000 3y agoSo .. a massive conspiracy which involves nearly all companies and all industries across the entire country, which all, in unison, jacked up prices, not because of valid economic reasons, but because they're all universally run by evil greedy mustache twirling villains that are all in cahoots?
- andyjohnson0 3y ago"Massive conspiracy" is a bit of a straw man. Self-interest among a group of people with power can lead to convergent behaviour that is to the detriment of wider society. No conspiracy needed.
- donkeybeer 3y agoYou do not need to be evil villains in a dimly lit boardroom for such things. It is simply a matter of self interest, and each actor can easily independently arrive at it. There is a general atmosphere of confusion and chaos and the public knows there are issues with supply chains and manufacturing, so who's to know the increase in prices is really due to legitimate issues or just a silent hike in profiteering. The consumer is none the wiser at that moment.
- Phil_Latio 3y agoThat's just herd behavior
- dreamcompiler 3y agoThere doesn't need to be a conspiracy and they don't need to be in cahoots. They just need to all recognize a situation that allows price gouging.
- 3y ago
- throwaway71147 3y agoI don't understand this media campaign against shrinkflation, it's not Coca-Cola and Heinz' fault if inflation exists. Is it more egregious if price rises from 90 cents for a 100g ketchup bottle to 90 cents per 90g bottle, instead of 1 dollar per 100g bottle? It even has the added benefit of people eating less pre-packaged crap. As others have said in this thread, if you want to be honest with costumers make supermarkets add price/100g next to the price label.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 3y agoRaising the price in a visible way comes with a higher cost (risk that consumers will stop buying your product/pick a competitor). Doing it in a hidden way through shrinkflation means many consumers don't notice, making it easier for companies to raise prices. As the act explains, it actually is Coca-Cola's and Heinz' fault that some of the inflation exists, because some of it is just them raising prices to make more profit. Requiring price increases to be done "openly" will likely reduce inflation, by discouraging price increases.
- Spivak 3y agoLaws against shrinkflation are sunlight laws. They're so that when companies change the price of goods (which is fine) the buyer-visible price actually changes. This should actually be great for companies because it levels the playing field. You don't have to worry that your competitor is going to raise prices by shrinking and look better on the shelf next to you and you never have to change your factory to a new smaller size. It's good for consumers because it's hard to measure cost of living increases when your grocery bill number stays the same but actually is just 10% less stuff.
- captainbland 3y agoWe do this in the UK but A: it's really small, as in a person with 20/20 vision has to get physically close to the price tag to read it. And B: all supermarkets seem to offer lower "membership card" prices which don't have to list this. So, yes, but also there's other stuff you have to do to ensure that supermarkets don't make this information harder to use/make it irrelevant entirely.
- 3y ago
- namaria 3y agoThe real problem here is lack of competition. Regulators slept at the wheel and now there's 3 corporations controlling 80% of the market. So they can get away with this kind of stuff. Legislating it away is a bandaid that will fall off as soon as a different administration neglects to enforce it.
- bsder 3y agoYup. Until some government gets serious and starts breaking up any company that gets more than 20% of any market slice, this will continue. At some point, there needs to be pressure to prevent relentless maximization of economy of scale.
- xnx 3y agoCompetition in my grocery store seems high. There are multiple options for almost every product category, including a store brand right there on the shelf next to each other with price (including per unit measure) plainly listed. I wish more product categories had the price transparency of grocery stores. I'm not a fan of this type of packaging trickery, but there's no reason we shouldn't expect that. The best defense is to be a smart shopper.
- rickydroll 3y agoYou don't have a choice even when it looks like you do. https://fifthperson.com/3-companies-own-us-soft-drink-market/ https://fifthperson.com/3-companies-own-us-soft-drink-market... https://www.forbes.com/sites/anaswanson/2014/09/10/meet-the-four-eyed-eight-tentacled-monopoly-that-is-making-your-glasses-so-expensive/?sh=1def548f6b66 https://www.forbes.com/sites/anaswanson/2014/09/10/meet-the-...
- plorkyeran 3y agoThe “multiple options” are frequently all owned by the same company, and the store brand is made by one of their subsidiaries too. The wide variety of brand names is there specifically to conceal how much the industry has consolidated.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoCloudflare "protection"1 workaround: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/3819/text https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https:... 1. Keeping www.congress.gov and public information protected from the Internet Archive https://web.archive.org/web/20240307063211if_/https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/3819/text https://web.archive.org/web/20240307063211if_/https://www.co...
- whitehexagon 3y agoWe have price per g/kg/l here which should help, but in practice manufacturers keep packaging sizes the same to disguise the fact there is less inside. So now we generate much more environmental waste per unit purchase.