2 ms·
We have really good efficient gold recovery. The problem is that its socially and actually toxic: socially because it destroys poor economies to turn them into
by ggm 3y ago
We have really good efficient gold recovery. The problem is that its socially and actually toxic: socially because it destroys poor economies to turn them into recovery stations littered with PCBs and bad stuff, and actually because gold recovery typically involves burning things, like associated plastics, and use of stuff like Cyanide which winds up in the waste water stream, peoples body fat, you-name-it.
So this technique may well be less "efficient" but if it's less toxic, and uses another waste stream, it can be worth it.
I wonder when, if ever, it will be viable to grind up chips and things to extract gallium and other trace elements which represent high cost supply chain risks (most viable rare earth mines are chinese because the west is lazy about maintaining their own sources)
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoYou mention a social problem, but it's an economic / capitalist problem; countries have been exporting and trading e-waste to the highest bidder that in turn sends it to the cheapest labor to get any value out of it. Waste should be processed as close to the source as possible, and waste should not be exported unless it actually gets processed properly, that is, if exporting to a country with good recycling facilities instead of putting it in landfill/incinerators. But the checks and balances for that are poor. IIRC / I have no source and may be making it up, in western countries, plastic is ticked off as "recycled" when it's been separated and baled up; if it's then exported and burned, landfill'd or chucked in the ocean doesn't matter anymore, the country fulfilled its pledge of recycling plastic.
- kragen 3y agocyanide is not a brand name, gallium is not a rare earth element, and almost all rare earth elements are cheap and abundant worldwide consequently i am also skeptical about your grasp of the things i don't know about, like the economic effects of pcb recycling on poor economies
- ggm 3y agoFair. The abundance isn't the problem the state of the mines for rare earth and other things is. A couple of options in Australia went to sleep when China cut prices and they haven't woken up afaik. Same with lithium options the price makes Western clean extraction much less profitable and we're not short of cheap lithium. Snark is frowned upon here. Complaining I capitalised cyanide is pretty snarky but your substantive points stand. Am I right in thinking your dislike of my shallow economic statements should not be read as believing you think pcb recycling has no downsides? Because you would be in a very small room if you said it's only good to send dead pc parts to Asia and Africa for teardown. Even the vendors now say they know this isn't all peachy.
- defrost 3y ago> A couple of options in Australia went to sleep when China cut prices and they haven't woken up afaik. It'd be more accurate to describe what happened was a number of resource producers went all in on an anticipated surge in lithium demand for EV and home batteries globally that was much smaller than predicted.
- suoduandao3 3y agoI do wonder, based on the 'state of mines' question, whether phytomining won't be a major source of resources in a more circular economy. The solarpunk in me loves the idea. The Engineer in me blanches at the economic realities. Investing in commercial phytomining is definitely on my 'if I win the lottery' list.
- kragen 3y agopcb recycling can easily be done in an extremely polluting way, and that's the easiest way to do it, and i've definitely seen that cause problems. i've made myself sick doing it, in fact, though not seriously. what i don't know is how prevalent it is for people to cause problems by doing pcb recycling on an ongoing basis, which i wasn't doing. it depends on the local social context, but i'd think that in most of the world it would be pretty common for their neighbors to oblige them to stop, even if they managed to avoid poisoning themselves in the process (which would also make them stop, in a sadder way) with respect to capitalizing 'cyanide', there is a fable told by aisopos about this https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/public/gdcmassbookdig/fablesofaesoptex00unse/fablesofaesoptex00unse.pdf https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/public/gdcmassbookdig/... > When people go on a voyage they often take with them Lap-Dogs or Monkeys as pets to while away the time. Thus it fell out that a man returning to Athens from the East had a pet Monkey on board with him. As they neared the coast of Attica a great storm burst upon them, and the ship capsized. All on board were thrown into the water, and tried to save themselves by swimming, the Monkey among the rest. A Dolphin saw him, and, supposing him to be a man, took him on his back and began swimming towards the shore. When they got near the Piraeus, which is the port of Athens, the Dolphin asked the Monkey if he was an Athenian. The Monkey replied that he was, and added that he came of a very distinguished family. "Then, of course, you know the Piraeus," continued the Dolphin. The Monkey thought he was referring to some high official or other, and replied, "Oh, yes, he's a very old friend of mine." At that, detecting his hypocrisy, the Dolphin was so disgusted that he dived below the surface, and the unfortunate Monkey was quickly drowned. while i am not advocating drowning you in the mediterranean, i think it's reasonable that, if someone thinks 'cyanide' is a brand name, we should ignore their opinions about the toxicology of cyanide; and, if they express those opinions with great confidence, as you did, we should probably also ignore the other opinions they express with great confidence