5 ms·
SCOTUS wants Congress to do its job of making laws, instead of having an unconstitutional fourth branch of government exercises all the powers of the other thre
by rayiner 3y ago
SCOTUS wants Congress to do its job of making laws, instead of having an unconstitutional fourth branch of government exercises all the powers of the other three branches. The system of checks and balances you learned in school has become a farce, with agencies making rules with the force of law, prosecuting violators for breaking those rules, and adjudicating those violations in their own administrative court systems.
- ethanbond 3y agoCan companies not escalate these types of battles into the traditional justice system?
- rayiner 3y agoYou can appeal, but that’s not the same. For adjudications, the courts defer to the agency’s findings, as if it were a lower court (which it isn’t). You can also appeal rulemakings. But that creates this crazy system where the executive branch makes the law, and then random interested parties hold up the law in the courts for years. So the executive branch and judicial branch both have their fingers in the pie—the only branch that doesn’t is the one that’s actually supposed to make the law, Congress.
- ethanbond 3y agoCongress obviously passed laws that authorize the executive to create and enforce rules. Everything you’re describing as some huge travesty sounds like a sensible and meaningful optimization of a system that already tends to be extremely overburdened. I don’t want every single corporate rule breaking attempt to immediately compete with murders for courtroom time. Obviously everyone should have the right to use the justice system if they need to, and they do have that right.
- rayiner 3y ago> Congress obviously passed laws that authorize the executive to create and enforce rules Those “rules” are equivalent to laws. The whole point of a written Constitution is to enforce fundamental structural constraints on the government, such as Congress rather than the executive being the one that makes laws.
- ethanbond 3y agoAnd one of those “constraints” is that Congress is empowered to create federal agencies to execute its laws. The rules under those agencies are backed by enabling legislation, and if you disagree with the connection between a rule and its enabling legislation, you can go to court and make that argument. I think what you’re really getting at is you’d prefer a far more dysfunctional government, since the actual moral/legal foundation would be no different. All of the federal agencies and their rules are derivative of Congressional acts, and again, if you disagree you can just go to court. Exactly as it would be if, for some reason, we decided that congress had to pass every single individual rule and sub rule and subsubrule and subsubsubrule exception 2 infraction 6 exemption 16.a and if, to combat any assessment of infraction, you had to go directly into the actual judicial system. All the legal basis is identical, the only thing that’s different is how wildly ineffective it’d be. If that’s your goal, just say it so we can move on.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aaomidi 3y agoCongress has passed laws delegating authority about certain aspects of a certain section of laws to these agencies because they can react faster. You and I both know congress won’t be able to do anything, which effectively means a ruling against these would kill all federal regulations.
- rayiner 3y agoIf our government can’t accomplish the most basic tasks of being a government without violating our constitution, then we should just admit we are a failed state and disband.
- beowulfey 3y agoAh yes, that would certainly be far better.
- aaomidi 3y agoI do not want to actually live in a system where _elected non expert_ people are making decisions for health, communications, space travel rules, internet access, business rules, agriculture, flight regulations, etc. Someone getting elected is not qualified to make these decisions. They are however, somewhat qualified to represent the will of the people they represent by setting up agencies with missions to address these problems that hires experts to solve them. Our country has a lot of failures. Executive agencies are not one of them.
- rayiner 3y agoOur constitution creates a republic, governed by elected representatives. Not an expertocracy where our elected representatives simply serve to appoint and facilitate the work of Harvard graduates who actually run the country. The rightful government is the one the Constitution created, not the pretender to the throne we have now.
- dctoedt 3y ago"By your fruits ye shall know them." One could venture that most people care far less about a government's fidelity to any particular abstract written standard than they do about whether the government does an acceptable job keeping things running.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoThere has been a huge push by corporations over the last two decades by corporations successfully lobbying federal agencies to let them self-regulate and the resulting disastrous consequences for our health, safety, and the environment. The Boeing MAX second shitshow is on the front page of HN. Both are the direct result of the FAA "trusting" Boeing to self-regulate/inspect etc. The FRA has let rail freight companies do basically whatever they want. Result? East Palestine, not to mention the railroad industry having free reign to leave trains parked bisecting towns and counties, blocking fire trucks, ambulances, etc. Deregulation of the mortgage industry? Yeah, that's worked so well...twice now. Self-driving cars? That's been going so well, with some company's vehicles caught repeatedly violating traffic laws, and one even killed a woman walking across a road. USDA? The meat processing industries have pushed hard to self-regulate their inspections while we have ever-growing incidents of food contamination...and the number of inspectors has been slashed. ATF? Doing a fraction of the inspections and enforcement they used to because of staff and budget cuts. OSHA? Same. Fraction of the inspections they used to. To then come up with "federal agencies are run amock and need the USSC to reel them in" is a truly wild hot take. What's actually happening is that these disasters are prompting agencies to put back their regulations and folks like you are pretending that this is some new big-bad-wolf crackdown on the poor poor corporations which are currently all enjoying record profits...
- rayiner 3y ago> To then come up with "federal agencies are run amock and need the USSC to reel them in" is a truly wild hot take I agree with most of your points until this one. The only question for the Supreme Court is whether the Constitution allows what has become a fourth branch of government that effectively subsumes the other three. Whether that fourth branch is doing a good job or bad job, or could be doing a better job, is besides the point. Even as a law student reading the case notes in my admin law textbook (https://faculty.westacademic.com/Book/Detail?id=335338 https://faculty.westacademic.com/Book/Detail?id=335338), it seemed pretty clear to me that the justifications for the whole scheme were contrived. In fact, all of the problems you mention are arguably caused by the fact all these important decisions are being made by a court branch of government that isn’t in the Constitution and sits outside the system of checks and balances. The people you can vote on aren’t actually the ones running the country. And the ones running the country are people you can’t vote on. For example, inspecting airplanes seems like exactly the thing the executive branch should do. But deciding that airline makers should be allowed to self-inspect airplanes? That seems like lawmaking Congress should do. And that change never would’ve gotten through Congress.
- dctoedt 3y agoPutting it in software terms: The administrative state is arguably the result of a lot of incremental hacks adopted to cope with decades of changing conditions — and the fact that political polarization (and our imbalance of power favoring small rural states) has made it impracticable to try to modify the "code" in a "proper" fashion. (Not least this is because it's the production version that would have to be modified, with little opportunity for beta testing.) Sure, there's lots of code smell. But the code runs, more or less. Continuing to run the existing hacked version seems preferable to the alternative of giving up and shutting everything down.
- rayiner 3y agoBy “proper” you mean “legal” and that makes all the difference. If the highest law of the land requires your OS to be a micro kernel, then sorry you’re not putting the GUI in kernel space, even if that would improve performance. And if you’ve already done that, well we gotta rip it out. One of the great virtues of Anglo culture—one that’s unfortunately been diluted to a great extent in America—is its formalistic, rule following nature. Our tolerance of fundamental departure from the formalism of our Constitution should be a matter of shame, in and of itself. But the complaint here isn’t merely aesthetic—about “code smell.” The ways in which we have ignored the constitution has changed who runs the country. And that’s bad for the country. No matter who you vote for, the actual running of the country will be done by the same corporate-friendly center-left bureaucracy. That’s not just frustrating to the right, it’s also ultimately frustrating to a large swath of the left. Every four years election promises go into the black hole of the administrative state, where they make at most minor changes in how the country is run.
- dctoedt 3y ago> If the highest law of the land requires your OS to be a micro kernel, then sorry you’re not putting the GUI in kernel space, even if that would improve performance. And if you’ve already done that, well we gotta rip it out. Except nothing in the highest law in the land requires the OS to be a micro kernel. The nondelegation doctrine [0] arose from a needlessly-cramped (and result-oriented) interpretation of the Constitution's grants of federal power. That interpretation was correctly jettisoned in the New Deal's response to the societal threats posed by the impact of the Great Depression. Again: • The vast majority of software users couldn't care less whether the OS is a micro kernel — they just want code that works, with reasonable reliability and efficiency. If it's not unreasonable to describe the existing OS as being a micro kernel, then let's just move on. • By the same token, the vast majority of citizens don't care how government is structured, they just want responsive, reliable service that doesn't needlessly intrude on their lives and isn't excessively costly. It's not at all unreasonable to say that delegation to agencies is not inconsistent with the Constitution's grants of federal power. So let's just move on and spend our time and energy on actual problems, instead of trying to return to the imagined doctrinal purity of yesteryear. • When actually changing the "kernel" (the Constitution) is difficult or impossible, as now, then workarounds are needed. Moreover, trying to do a complete rewrite of the running production system (i.e., a constitutional convention, à la 1787) would be reckless. • The administrative state is not unaccountable — we still have elections (at least for now), and administrative regs do change when administrations do, as we've seen repeatedly in recent years. [0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/nondelegation_doctrine https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/nondelegation_doctrine (which has links to selected law-review articles at Penn, Notre Dame, and Stanford).
- alphabettsy 3y agoI don’t believe it’s possible or reasonable for Congress to make all laws and regulations for every part of our society. I think the only thing at question should be the scope of delegation and there are arguments to be made about that. IMO this argument is an attempt by small government conservatives to dismantle most/all regulatory oversight and rule making knowing full well that congress cannot meaningfully substitute.