This sounds dreadful to me. Your peers will judge you based on THEIR ability and knowledge. Which in the IT industry is a problem because most developers are o

This sounds dreadful to me. Your peers will judge you based on THEIR ability and knowledge. Which in the IT industry is a problem because most developers are overly confident about their abilities. So you will end up with good developers being given poorer rankings. I much prefer developers being judged on their ability to meet business outcomes.