3 ms·
I can't speak to averages but I'll say car traffic into Boston is at least as bad as ever and commuter rail is still way down relative to pre-pandemic. So, yes,
by ghaff 3y ago
I can't speak to averages but I'll say car traffic into Boston is at least as bad as ever and commuter rail is still way down relative to pre-pandemic. So, yes, people take train but a huge number of people drive. (I try to take train the rare times I go into the office although it takes about the same 2 hours as driving.) And the commuter rail is totally impractical to use for an evening event.
- gwbas1c 3y agoHah, I was about to respond roughly the same thing: Taking the rail into Boston is so impractical that it's easier to drive. FWIW: The T/Commuter Rail (apologies for blending the two) has more than 90% of US rail accidents. I noticed a ton of maintenance problems the last time I rode it (in 2021) and I don't know if/when I'll try it again.
- ghaff 3y agoI know there have been efforts to improve things but service was also cut back during the pandemic. (There are some express trains again.) I'll still take it preferentially for 9-5ish situations like one I'll have next week but it's not actually any faster in general (though I can sort of relax for most of the trip) and is totally unusable for going in for an evening play. And that's almost certainly a pretty good commuter rail system by large urban US standards. (Not as good as NYC of course.) So, to my original point, saying "don't drive" is essentially equivalent to saying stay out of the city in general.
- bedobi 3y agoCar skeptics are not saying “don’t drive” They’re saying “allow viable alternatives to driving”
- ghaff 3y agoYou wrote "Private automobiles do not belong in cities." I'm not sure what's ambiguous about that. Certainly if you tell me I don't belong someplace, I would take that literally.
- gwbas1c 3y ago> pretty good commuter rail system by large urban US standards I used to take the Caltrain from Palo Alto to San Francisco. The line from Kingston to Boston doesn't even compare. Caltrain: Tinted windows, comfortable seats. I'm comfortable using a laptop to check email while I ride to work. MA Commuter Rail: No tint on the windows, seats so bad I'm uncomfortable using a laptop. I wouldn't call MA commuter rail "Good" by US standards. It's treating MA residents like a captive audience, and then the politicians and leaders scratch their heads and wonder why we'd rather clog the freeway with luxury cars instead of taking the train.
- wolverine876 3y agoWhy makes it impractical for an evening event? I've seen in other cities that, bizarrely to me, the rail shuts down before the end of sporting events, concerts, and other things that would attract people to the city. Maybe they don't want drunks?
- ghaff 3y agoThere are very few nighttime trains and it would take me a good extra hour to get home even once I caught one of the sparse trains. If I had to take the train in for a play I'd simply pass.
- wolverine876 3y agoOut of curiosity, how hard would it be to take a rideshare home? Too expensive?
- ghaff 3y agoYes. Probably close to $100. (I'm about 45 miles outside.) And probably hard to get a driver later at night. I do book a private car to and from the airport but I'm not going to do that for a random evening out. (The small theater I have a subscription to also has a free parking deal at a nearby garage so that doesn't even factor in.)
- bedobi 3y agoMeanwhile in Tokyo 40 million people virtually all take the train, and those who do drive never experience traffic or gridlock
- Panzer04 3y agoI like to think of PT as placing an "upper bound" on how bad traffic can get. If PT is faster than sitting in a car, people will take PT instead, alleviating congestion. This more or less results in traffic getting worse until it reaches the speed of PT, at which point people start switching transport modes and it stops getting worse. If the train took the same amount of time as driving I'd take the train every time - driving sucks, whereas I can read or watch videos on the train. This works because (grade-separated) PT can (at least relative to roads) take on an effectively unlimited amount of extra commuters without getting slower, as pretty much all of its costs and transport times are fixed, whereas roads just continually get slower with additional traffic. This is part of the problem with busses and the like - they get caught up in traffic, so unless they get their own dedicated lanes you won't get the same traffic-reducing benefits as you would with heavy rail and the like.
- ghaff 3y agoWhen I was an undergrad there was I think one bus route I took in 4 years because it was marginally quicker than walking an extra 15 minutes to catch the subway depending on where I was. My preference within the city when I'm there these days is subway or walk. But the connection to the subway really only works on a commuting timetable and, if I'm going to park on the outskirts anyway to catch the subway I'll mostly just drive in.
- jprete 3y agoIt's very, very possible for public transport to be overloaded to the point where people have to wait for another train because there's just no room left. Some NYC subway lines are like that routinely during rush hour.
- Panzer04 3y agoYeah, that's why I specified "relative to roads" :P. There are capacity limitations, they are just much more generous than the alternatives.