9 ms·
World War II 'rumor clinics' helped America battle wild gossip
- WFHRenaissance 3y ago[flagged]
- h2odragon 3y agoSee also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_propaganda_during_World_War_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_propaganda_during_Wor...
- glenstein 3y agoI think a good rule of thumb for wiki citations is that they should facilitate a deeper dive into specifics rather than kick things back up to a higher level of generality. In short they should zoom in rather than zoom out. It doesn't appear that the rumor clinics mentioned in the article bear any connection to the government-run initiatives discussed in the Wiki article. There's one section on "careless talk" but it is much less detailed than the Smithsonian article and not necessarily about the same thing.
- h2odragon 3y agoThe public embrace of propaganda and indoctrination in WW2 was so fierce that it resulted in "Normalcy" chants later. The connection between Government efforts and newspaper columnists might not have been explicit in this case; but the mood being set was very much part of the reason people were willing to participate in such excesses of orthodoxy.
- Waterluvian 3y agoI can imagine some governments (especially the Soviet government) standing this kind of thing up simply to use for propaganda. Decide whatever you want to be "the general consensus of what's on everyone's mind" and talk about it on the government's terms.
- shadowgovt 3y agoInformation filtering is pretty standard in wartime (and other states of emergency). It's justified because misinformation kills, and the wartime laws allow for some limited suspension of civil rights to protect national integrity. People seem to forget, sometimes, that from a legal standpoint the US government can, for example, still draft individual citizens; there's lots of individual liberties (including the right to not be put in danger of life) that get suspended in wartime. And, of course, this is definitely an avenue for bad actors to take advantage of information asymmetry to mislead the public. US history has multiple examples of this occurring. They tend to be exceptions, but they are worth knowing.
- llm_trw 3y agoYou don't have to imagine anyone but the US government doing the same. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States One need only read the original pamphlet which gave rise to the saying "Yelling fire in a crowded theater" to realize that the theater was on fire, and possibly in the middle of a nuclear meltdown too. It's been kind of shocking to see that for the last 8 years the party which is supposedly against tyranny to side with tyranny in the name of fighting tyranny.
- ThisIsMyAltAcct 3y agoWorth noting that Schenck v. United States was overturned more than 50 years ago.
- llm_trw 3y agoYes, but for some reason after Trump won in 2016 people started quoting Oliver Holmes everywhere as a reason why free speech needs to die. Along with misquoting Popper on why we must destroy freedom to save it.
- shadowgovt 3y agoThat is one of the great tensions of the US Constitution. "Free speech is free speech unless it's treason."
- roenxi 3y agoWWII is a sad example of one of the last wars before mass media. The clearer the picture of the front became, the harder it is to believe these plucky little propaganda outlets. It is possible that we're looking at the start of WWIII; the global military situation has been escalating in alarming ways for years now. This time really would be different because the public will have a much clearer picture of what happened in the lead up and why. I can say with some confidence that, based on what has happened from Vietnam to Ukraine, the media consensus leading in to and during WWII was a patchwork of lies.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- VinLucero 3y agoIt’s almost like we need a third space to discuss topics as a society outside the context of work, home, and religion. Get outside of your bubble!
- diggan 3y agoWe need a reintroduction of small scale, local coffeehouses as a meeting point for strangers and neighbors to discuss topical subjects: > In 17th- and 18th-century England, coffeehouses served as public social places where men would meet for conversation and commerce. For the price of a penny, customers purchased a cup of coffee and admission. > "places where people gathered to drink coffee, learn the news of the day, and perhaps to meet with other local residents and discuss matters of mutual concern." > The absence of alcohol created an atmosphere in which it was possible to engage in more serious conversation than in an alehouse. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_coffeehouses_in_the_17th_and_18th_centuries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_coffeehouses_in_the_17...
- TimTheTinker 3y agoGetting out and just listening and talking, in person, with people across political and religious spectrums is enough to quell the "us vs them" feeling, at least in my experience. We have so much more in common than our emotions tell us otherwise. And the vast majority of people in any camp aren't crazy wingnuts. We just hear the crazies more frequently since (a) crazy people tend to be a lot more vocal, (b) people in power have more voice, and (c) concentrated power and/or wealth often tends to subtly (or not so subtly) corrupt people. Getting out and talking in person diffuses so much of the tension that tends to build from reading websites with vocal, somewhat-crazy people (e.g. reddit and many news platforms).
- TimTheTinker 3y ago> concentrated power and/or wealth often tends to subtly (or not so subtly) corrupt people. I wonder if one reason for that is that power and wealth tend to minimize the negative feedback people experience from mistakes. People seem to drift towards craziness more when there's no "ground truth" to provide immediate negative feedback when you do something wrong -- like compilers yelling at you, or the needs of plants/animals for farmers, or gravity and friction for rock climbers. Living and working daily close to these kinds of constraints seems to keep us sane and humble like nothing else. Healthy communities also naturally provide at lot of good, hard constraints. The social consequences from being a bad actor can be incredibly motivating to think and live decently (unless you're really rich, unfortunately). NB: I don't think the negative character effects from wealth are a good argument against capitalism or property ownership. But it does reinforce that we need democratic governments with elected officials who faithfully represent the common people's interests.
- WesleyLivesay 3y agoAn interesting article for sure. There were all kinds of things done by the various nations during the war to control the information available to the populous and to try and influence their beliefs. I do think it is interesting that this article never uses the word "propaganda" to describe what was being done by the newspapers here. It undoubtedly was propaganda, but in the modern world that word carries a very negative connotation so it is only described as counter- or anti-propaganda.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoIs fighting fiction with fact really propaganda?
- ochoseis 3y agoIn reality, it’s often cherry-picked facts fighting each other.
- Andrex 3y agoFacts can be paired with other facts in a way deliberately designed to mislead.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoThat's true but I think it's disingenuous to say that countering enemy propaganda must also be propaganda. It doesn't have to be.
- DinaCoder99 3y agoNobody is forcing you to call it anything—you could just as easily call it "marketing" or "news". Anyway, "fact" is a convenient fantasy in most cases when you actually mean "strong belief grounded in sources you trust".
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y ago
- declan_roberts 3y agoAs they say, “truth is the first casualty of war” At the same time we were running these clinics we also had entire regiments of the US government developing the most effective way to lie to both our enemies and our population.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ahmedfromtunis 3y agoI think that the reason behind the astonishing rise of fake news is partly due to people wanting to believe things that they know are, at least, not totally true. Unfortunately, I have witnessed this firsthand where the desire to "own" the other side grows faster than that of getting to the best (possible) answer. Winning at all costs is indeed a dangerous game to play.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thfuran 3y agoYou think people are only recently starting to want to believe false things?
- optimalsolver 3y agoI want to believe that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bagels 3y agoI think that the acceptance and celebration of this kind of thinking has increased, or, maybe I'm just more exposed to it through media.
- wrs 3y agoThese columns are an accidental historical source just to know what the rumors were, since they would almost never be written down otherwise. At least historians of our era will have terabytes of rumors in Facebook/Twitter to examine. (Or will they?)
- nerdponx 3y agoIt will all be "accidentally" deleted when someone decides they don't want to pay the storage bill anymore, like what happened with Myspace.
- slimsag 3y agoThat, combined with the proliferation of information being distributed as text-in-pictures or voice/text-in-video form will make it computationally difficult to search.
- gamepsys 3y agoIn the world where general computing continues to become cheaper over time both of those are not problems in the long term.
- philipkglass 3y agoOptical character recognition and audio transcription are improving at such a pace that I don't think this will be a significant barrier for future historians. Even now, on a computer with modest resources (e.g. laptop without dedicated GPU), whisper.cpp makes it practical to transcribe hours of podcast audio or other speech. And the transcription only needs to be done once. https://github.com/ggerganov/whisper.cpp https://github.com/ggerganov/whisper.cpp
- bobthepanda 3y agoyou would probably run into the bigger issue of how to search for what is truly relevant. will the researchers of 3000 be able to tell the difference between AI or content-farm clickbait vs decent primary and secondary sources? even today we have issues determining if what sources from antiquity say is true.
- duxup 3y agoLocal news stations in my area address things in a very similar fashion. They will address a specific claim, cite sources, go over the facts. They do a fairly good job addressing the “truthy” aspects of the claim and why it doesn’t prove the rumor as well.
- loceng 3y ago"Don't be a sucker!" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8K6-cEAJZlE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8K6-cEAJZlE A 1947 educational video series by US government to help educate the population on tactics used by fascists.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoUS National Archives: https://catalog.archives.gov/id/24376 https://catalog.archives.gov/id/24376
- duxup 3y agoI like the introduction on this one. It presents sucker as a neutral thing, some guy taken in by criminals looking to steal their money via typical non political methods. Then later they show how deception works similarly for far more serious topics.
- standeven 3y agoThe Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) has an active campaign to battle disinformation, especially from foreign sources. They even used Soviet propaganda-style ads on Twitter to convey their message. (1) Of course, the Twitter comments below the ads are full of people/bots/agents claiming that CSIS is in the pocket of Trudeau, legacy media, the WEF, etc. 1- https://www.cbc.ca/amp/1.6955717 https://www.cbc.ca/amp/1.6955717
- verisimi 3y ago[dead]
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoDepends on which the situation requires.
- standeven 3y agoCan you cite a single example of CSIS creating misinformation?
- verisimi 3y agoWho has the truth that they can judge something to be a lie? Or is all this just a political football?
- user3939382 3y ago[flagged]
- standeven 3y agoWhat would it take to prove that CSIS is trustworthy?
- suoduandao3 3y agoCSIS as an institution acting against the interests of an entrenched governing party/oligarch bloc. Particularly if it leads to a change in leadership and they do it again. Yes, it's a high bar. Intelligence agencies have a lot to make up for.
- srtysetry 3y agoRumors + military = mess I remember when my sub was on a six-month deployment. The rule was, when you're talking to family and friends back home, you don't talk about other sailors, period. We had a guy who got kidney stones. His wife heard a rumor that he had some type of STD. She got mad and went and slept with some rando guy, ended up getting some actual STDs herself, and there were divorce papers waiting for him when the ship returned home. But the military runs on rumors. They're the only source of entertainment soldiers and sailors have most of the time. And in the weird mental stimulation vacuum that is life at sea, people will literally start swinging at you if you question their preferred rumors. Antisemitic, racist, classist, secret society crap ... they love it.
- smcl 3y agoIt sounds like that marriage was on the edge and bound to break up sooner rather than later, if all it took was a rumour for one party to run off and hook up with a random, get STDs (plural!) then file for divorse. To be honest this sounds a little bit like everyone who told it heard from a friend-of-a-friend...
- bluGill 3y agoThe story is common enough in many similar ways to things I know have happened that I'll believe it. The details may change, but lots of people cheat on their spouse, suspicions make them more likely to do that, and STDs are common enough to not be surprised if someone gets them (though multiple STDs is a little less common) I don't know if the given story is true - it also is a urban legend feel. However it is true for a number of other people in similar situations.
- instagib 3y agoBeing away for long periods of time is bad for most relationships. I remember very high divorce rates for some career fields and a lot of cheating going when deployed.
- SkyMarshal 3y agoMilitary service already puts abnormal strain on most marriages. It's hard on relationships even when you're not at war.
- throw0101d 3y agoHasn't it been shown that facts don't change people's mind, but (generally) makes them hold tighter to their view? > Belief perseverance (also known as conceptual conservatism[1]) is maintaining a belief despite new information that firmly contradicts it.[2] Such beliefs may even be strengthened when others attempt to present evidence debunking them, a phenomenon known as the backfire effect (compare boomerang effect).[3] For example, in a 2014 article in The Atlantic, journalist Cari Romm describes a study involving vaccination hesitancy. In the study, the subjects expressed their concerns of the side effects of flu shots. After being told that the vaccination was completely safe, they became even less eager to accept them. This new knowledge pushed them to distrust the vaccine even more, reinforcing the idea that they already had before.[4][5] * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belief_perseverance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belief_perseverance * https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2023/01/24/facts-dont-change-minds-social-networks-group-dialogue-and-stories-do/ https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2023/01/24/fa... * https://www.discovermagazine.com/mind/why-is-it-that-even-proven-facts-cant-change-some-peoples-minds https://www.discovermagazine.com/mind/why-is-it-that-even-pr... * https://archive.is/BicuE https://archive.is/BicuE ; https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/02/27/why-facts-dont-change-our-minds https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/02/27/why-facts-dont... Perhaps useful towards that are more sitting on the fence?
- duxup 3y agoIs it "facts" or just how it's presented and such? I can imagine "False, that's not true here is a link" doesn't do much. Humans are not just fact consumers, there's all sorts of nuance to social interaction that aren't "facts".
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoYes. Verification of facts is not always easy. That's why, for practical reasons, we defer on many things to people we trust (or are intimidated into "trusting") as authorities, unless we have a reason not to. And reason is like a muscle. You must practice it, and you must not only practice it, but also practice self-discipline. A practiced intellect backed by vice will only be better at rationalizing bad things.
- 23B1 3y agoThis would be great these days if the fact checkers hadn't already outed themselves as propagandists as well. Good luck finding truth in the forthcoming miasma of Old Internet.
- kossTKR 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zombiwoof 3y ago[flagged]
- krapp 3y agoIt's almost as if instilling a deep mistrust of all mainstream news and status quo knowledge in favor of even more politically biased alternatives cultivates a populace which paradoxically believes itself to be free thinking iconoclasts while being easier to manipulate by the very system they think they're above. Or something.
- lupire 3y agoWe've had charlatans and demagogues forever. New religions popping up all throughout history, claiming a unique andnphony "truth" .
- lupire 3y agoI assure that even in the rosy past, people had disagreements of both opinion and fact.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- neilv 3y agoRelated is my favorite bit of counter-propaganda: US War Dept., "Don't Be a Sucker", 1947. https://archive.org/details/DontBeaS1947 https://archive.org/details/DontBeaS1947
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- masfuerte 3y ago> Other reports insisted that scrap metal drives did little for the war effort In the UK they didn't. A great many railings were removed and then dumped rather than melted down. This article is about London but it happened nationwide: https://greatwen.com/2012/04/17/secret-london-the-mystery-of-londons-world-war-ii-railings/ https://greatwen.com/2012/04/17/secret-london-the-mystery-of...
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoAge old problem? How to be an open society, without being open to manipulation. I tend to think only education. But the 'right' actively fights that too. Typically on 'religious' grounds, to keep people ignorant. So, even the solution is demonized. But if you try to do something, you are called a fascist for curtailing 'free-speech'. Edit: What about counter marketing. In "Seveneves", the government had people that manipulated narratives, for pro-democracy. So it was manipulation, but to do-the-right-thing, which was fighting the other government that was a secretive dictatorship like USSR/North Korea type. Often wondered if that would work at all, but it would have to be secret or if ever found out it would be pilloried for being 'manipulative'. So, how can a 'free' side ever fight 'non-free' sides without becoming the enemy and using the tactics of the 'non-free' side .
- default-kramer 3y ago> Often wondered if that would work at all, but it would have to be secret or if ever found out it would be pilloried for being 'manipulative'. Why would it have to be secret? All major governments do plenty of manipulation, and it's not even really a secret. The specifics may be a secret, but the fact that they are doing it is just business as usual.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI was thinking that manipulation would become non-effective once someone knows they are being manipulated. So to be most effective, it would have to be un-known. We all know governments manipulate. Generally. But what is the current specific manipulation that is still secret, and thus we are influenced by something without knowing we are being influenced, or even are confident we are not being influenced. or guess, we could be in such a jaded time that people don't believe anything, even if something is true. In such a jaded time, is manipulation easier or harder?
- photochemsyn 3y agoThe Institute For Propaganda Analysis (1937-1942) is an interesting and unmentioned case - their agenda was to examine all propaganda efforts (including advertising) and expose its internal mechanisms, which they classified into about seven categories IIRC. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institute_for_Propaganda_Analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institute_for_Propaganda_Analy... Closing statement (1942): "The publication of dispassionate analyses of all kinds of propaganda, 'good' and 'bad', is easily misunderstood during a war emergency, and more important, the analyses could be misused for undesirable purposes by persons opposing the government’s effort."
- bloopernova 3y agoThe intensity of activity and change from 1939 to 1945 is astonishing to me. Heck, for the USA, the support of the Soviet Union and Britain via Lend Lease was amazing enough, but then the Pacific theater demanded a humongous amount of hardware too. A total war production economy is an awe-inspiring thing to consider. And on top of all that, these people fought an information war at home! What was different then, that allowed people to dedicate themselves so utterly to the cause? If a similar situation happened today, would we rise to meet it?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ganzuul 3y agoAccording to A Century of the Self current Western society is engineered for something like WWII never to happen again. In philosophy post-structuralism followed. It does hinder a single narrative from dominating but it also hinders people from finding meaning in work. Hopefully mankind's next philosophy does not include war.
- ragnot 3y agoCould you explain more about how society is engineered to not let WWII happen?
- mr_toad 3y ago> What was different then After Pearl Harbor many people considered a land invasion of the continental USA to be a real possibility. Nothing like an existential threat as a motivator.
- dhdodjddkdj 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ajoy 3y agoReally impressed with how Finland is "arming" the public with the tools to combat misinformation: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jan/28/fact-from-fiction-finlands-new-lessons-in-combating-fake-news https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jan/28/fact-from-fict... Hint: They start real early. Also this (from article) : "Fake news, Kivinen said, is not a great term, especially for children. Far more useful are three distinct categories: misinformation, or “mistakes”; disinformation, or “lies” and “hoaxes”, which are false and spread deliberately to deceive; and malinformation, or “gossip”, which may perhaps be correct but is intended to harm."