3 ms·
Does this not strongly suggest IQ tests are too crude?
by ggm 3y ago
Does this not strongly suggest IQ tests are too crude?
- bugbuddy 3y agoYes, and that if you want to believe in something you can always come up with the correct sounding justification. In this case, it’s the use of obviously formulaic IQ test formats, thus easily targeted for training, to justify claims that we have AI with intelligence equals to the average human of 100 points. This is pure BS to anyone who has not sold their soul to the AI bandwagon for profit or otherwise.
- p0w3n3d 3y agoThis Stanford-Binet IQ test was created to tell less intelligent kids from average, to let them grow in special school programs. They don't measure all intelligence, just a part of it. I mean one can go there and get 140 and boast oneself, but there are some IQ 90 guys there in the world earning six figures, so the good grade on this test does not mean one is great in every field of living
- somenameforme 3y agoIt wasn't a full specturm IQ test, but some random mensa test that looks like the online 'test your IQ' nonsense. And the software was given precise written descriptions of the visual questions after performing too poorly otherwise. This completely removes the element of visual-spatial understanding that the questions are testing to begin with! But I think there's also a more salient point. Correlated abilities mean different things for different groups. The ability to do simple math rapidly is generally going to correlate with intelligence for a human. That doesn't mean a calculator, which can do simple math millions of times faster than the fastest human, is thus millions of times more intelligent.
- qeternity 3y agoNo, because these tests are designed for humans. Cross-comparison makes no sense. It's like asking if a 100 meter dash is too crude because a Ferrari can do it faster.
- dbspin 3y agoIQ tests are incredibly crude. The amalgamate a series of distinct measures of visual, verbal and mathematical reasoning - primarily utilitised based on ease of measurement, rather than completeness of assessment. My undergrad thesis involved developing a neurocognitive battery of tests (to explore cognitive deficits related to diabetes). The array of cognitive modules you can test (and that can be defective) is dizzying. You can score a couple of standard deviations over the median on stanford-binet, but be severely functionally impaired due to anterograde amnesia, unable to speak due to Broca's aphasia, or unable to find your way out of a room due to visual agnosia -- to give some concrete examples. There's also no capacity (due to the pen and paper nature of IQ tests, and the culture bound cognitive aspects they measure) to assess proprioceptive intelligence, musical ability, affective comprehension, explicit or implicit long term memory and numerous other aspects of fluid intelligence that concretely impact an individuals capacity to complete real world 'intelligence' dependent tasks. Performance on IQ tests can be highly dependent on cultural approaches to test taking, and priming effects in IQ testing have withstood the replication crisis. The mathematical aspects of IQ tests are dependent on familiarity with the kinds of operations tested (and unsurprisingly scores increase with practice), and similarly literacy is required for and influences verbal scores. While learning math and acquiring the ability to read and write certainly do have an impact on cognitive function, it would be ludicrous to suggest that the don't depend on latent abilities IQ tests literally can't measure. So while IQ tests certainly have their uses, but to consider them a worthwhile measure of human cognitive capacity, let alone machine intelligence, is extremely dubious.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MichaelZuo 3y agoHow did you not come across raven's progressive matrices? Which sidesteps all possible cultural biases at least.