2 ms·
I imagine that lots of “vulnerability detection software/SaaS” is built on that kind of tools plus queries developed for specific vulnerabilities. OTOH, my exp
by dragonwriter 3y ago
I imagine that lots of “vulnerability detection software/SaaS” is built on that kind of tools plus queries developed for specific vulnerabilities.
OTOH, my experience with these systems has been that they are popular with enterprise ISOs, but have very high inaccuracy (lots of false positives, and lots of misses on the kind of vulns they purport to detect), and while they are marginally useful, they seem do more for security checklist compliance than for security.
- pentaphobe 3y agoAgree on inaccuracy, but I don't think that this reduces its value as much as you posit. Ultimately other forms of static analysis won't guarantee my code is good, but I still use linters. Similarly, tests (unit, integration, etc..) won't prove that nothing can go wrong - but I'm not going to stop writing them. I'd love to be using a "perfect" language which could prove my program correct at compile time, and would presumedly also make static analysis borderline magical for these use cases - but until that's an option I think there's a place for all these tools. (Beyond simply ticking compliance boxes) With all that said, false negatives are indeed a hard problem - and one not helped by large orgs having painful bureaucracy around false _positives_. Some of this appears to be the fault of tooling (need better filtration, deferral, weighting) but much of it seems a side effect of institutional silo's rather than a lack of perfect analyses. TLDR; pobody's nerfect, but more info generally better than less