5 ms·
A lot of people, including the author of this article, seem to think it's unfair that Mozilla is not giving equal complaint time to both platforms. That's the
by wvenable 15y ago
A lot of people, including the author of this article, seem to think it's unfair that Mozilla is not giving equal complaint time to both platforms. That's the fundamental issue here.
Maybe, all things being equal, that would be a fair complaint but all things are not equal.
First of all, the limitations of iOS and app store are well known and retread at least once a month on HN since the site opened. Mozilla certainly did complain about iOS years ago and decided ultimately to abandon the platform. We're talking about Windows now because Windows 8 is due to be released.
Secondly, Firefox's primary platform is Windows and they already have working version of Firefox for Windows 8 with a Metro UI for x86. Only a minor technical limitation keeps them from releasing it for ARM -- that's not true of iOS.
Lastly, there is a still a chance Microsoft might cave on this issue. We know from years of experience that Apple won't.
- ajross 15y agoPost-lastly: there's the simple point that Firefox for Windows is an actual product that could be shipped near-immediately. There is no Firefix for iOS, precisely because Apple has never allowed it. I think the broad point is valid though: Apple's platform control is no more morally justified than Microsoft's. And at least in the abstract they deserve equal scorn. But the specifics here are that Windows 8 on ARM won't run an app that can clearly be shipped (and will be for x86). That's a problem with a reasonable hope of being fixed, so it makes practical sense for Mozilla to whine about that first. Post-post-lastly: it bears mentioning that if Safari was as bad as IE, Apple might draw more fire. It helps a lot to have a browser that doesn't lag the state of the art.
- wvenable 15y agoTo the people who say "Where's the moral outrage" about Apple, I have to wonder if they haven't been paying attention for the last 4 years. Lots of people and organizations have led the charge against Apple. It seems the only organization actively complaining about the limitations of Windows 8 right now is Mozilla. In terms of equal scorn, Microsoft hasn't gotten much scorn at all.
- billpatrianakos 15y agoWhat you're missing here is that Apple bans everyone equally while Microsoft does not. What I mean by that is the App Store doesn't discriminate on an individual basis. Apple is generally consistent in their "unfairness". Looking at what Microsoft is doing, their decision to restrict Firefox immediately struck me as an anti-trust monopoly issue. They're not restricting Firefox on the basis of some policy that applies to everyone but singling out one piece of software. The argument in this article is a red herring. This isn't about fairness. It plays on the whole Apple v. Microsoft thing and tries to drum up sympathy and or guilt by playing the "you're just hating on MS because it's trendy" card in a way. It really looks like Microsoft has decided to restrict Firefox capabilities on ARM devices so their browser can have a leg up and deliberately and negatively impact the user experience of Firefox on certain devices. Framing this using Apple and it's policies/practices are an attempt at misdirection. If you take this attempt to play the Apple v. Microsoft card out of the equation and for a moment pretend Apple never banned FF and FF never even tried to get on iOS what you're left with is Microsoft unfairly discriminating against one company in an obvious attempt to stamp out any competition. It's a pretty cut and dry case of ant-trust once you weed out all the distractions. Edit: clarified the first sentence of last paragraph. Added the words "Framing this using".
- wvenable 15y ago> What you're missing here is that Apple bans everyone equally while Microsoft does not. You could not have this more backwards. The fundamental issue that Metro apps cannot write to executable memory pages. This is a fundamental security feature of both WinRT and of iOS. Browsers download code off the Internet JIT compile it to native code and execute it. This is what Firefox needs to do. It's not like Windows 8 is checking for Firefox.exe and refusing to load it. What Mozilla wants is an exception to the normal rules for applications on ARM Windows 8. Microsoft makes exceptions for their own applications (Office and IE) but that's it. These are the same sort of exceptions Apple make for their apps on iOS.
- notatoad 15y ago>What Mozilla wants is an exception to the normal rules for applications on ARM Windows 8. i think where the frustration is coming from is that windows gave them exactly that exception on x86 windows 8. they created a special class of applications for third party browsers, that can run JIT'd and native code in metro mode. now, with ARM, they've decided to revoke that exception for no apparent reason other than "because we can", and it seems more than a little unfair.
- bzbarsky 15y ago> There is no Firefix for iOS Sure there is. It hasn't been worked on much precisely because Apple wouldn't allow it anyway, but Ted Mielczarek ported Firefox to iOS a while back. See https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=676585 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=676585 and https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=680878 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=680878 and https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=681602 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=681602 and so forth.
- wavephorm 15y agoWhy don't they send that to Cydia?
- bzbarsky 15y agoThere is an experimental iOS port of Firefox, for what it's worth. It's only technical limitations from Apple's side that prevent it being actually released to users.
- ricardobeat 15y agoThe reason that Apple does not allow other engines in iOS is simple: it keeps all performance and security issues restricted to a single code base. That's good for users too. Considering that browsers implement the gross of their functionality (rendering + javascript) according to standards, there is no reason to have two different platforms that do exactly the same thing. As long as the standard is not owned by any private individuals, this is beneficial, and the same would apply to Windows tablets. That said, leaving everything on the hands of Internet Explorer scares me, so maybe this fight should be supported :)
- nextparadigms 15y agoWhy wouldn't Microsoft be able to use the same excuse then. There are always advantages and disadvantages. The questions is what is the compromise you're willing to live with? Apple, much like the US Government thinks security trumps everything, including individual liberties, "for their own good".
- ricardobeat 15y agoIndeed they could, I just said that. This lock might force MS to make IE's engine as good as WebKit. I don't see any problem as long as the standards are kept open and the engine doesn't belong to a single entity.
- rbanffy 15y agoYou got the lock-in strategy backwards. It exists to allow the incumbent not to improve their products while maximizing their profits because they don't have to compete.
- ricardobeat 15y agoWe are talking browsers here, there isn't much differentiation, it's a basic service. Even then, mobile safari is the most advanced one...
- greggman 15y agoYou do realize this isn't about Windows 8 on Desktops right? This is about Windows RT on ARM Tablets. This is about Apple iOS tablets vs Microsoft Windows RT tablets. That's it. It is NOT about Windows8 on PCs. Re-read the article. As such it does seem rather valid that Mozilla is complaining about Windows RT tablets but not Apple iOS tablets
- rbanffy 15y agoWindows on ARM is where the action will be. It's about countless millions of corporate machines built around cheap and energy efficient hardware running corporate applications through a browser. Microsoft wants to make sure it's their browser.
- recoiledsnake 15y ago>Windows on ARM is where the action will be. I thought you were the first to predict doom and gloom for Windows 8 in general every time :)
- contextfree 15y agoWindows RT isn't Windows 8! (Actually, I personally expect the success of this first iteration of Windows-on-ARM to be limited, but for it to see more success over time in future versions and as the app catalog slowly expands. Wonder what they'll do about naming when the next versions come along - will the counterpart to Windows 9 be Windows RT 2? Anyway, I think Mozilla is thinking long-term. There is little chance for any significant change in the Windows 8 version of Windows RT at this point, but if they start now maybe they can pressure Microsoft into improving the situation for future versions.)
- rbanffy 15y agoI don't think Win8 on ARM will be a huge success. Not even a moderate one. What I think, and Microsoft seems to agree, is that ARM based devices will dwarf the x86 PC market, driving it to irrelevance. The x86 PC is Microsoft's cash-cow and they have nothing to replace it. So, again, Windows on ARM is where Microsoft is going and whatever action MS gets, will be from it. Won't be much, but if they manage not to screw it up, it may grant Microsoft a few more years. And yes, they are doomed. Good riddance.