4 ms·
Oregon OKs right-to-repair bill that bans the blocking of aftermarket parts
- Spivak 3y ago> Like other repair bills, a number of device categories are exempted, including video game consoles, HVAC and medical gear, solar systems, vehicles, and, very specifically, "Electric toothbrushes." This is such a silly list. Video game consoles are literally no different from iPhones and contain less sensitive data. If your goal is to create less waste this should be an easy win. God can you imagine how dangerous the roads would be if you could install aftermarket parts in vehicles /s
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sidewndr46 3y agoAnd then imagine how dangerous it would be if someone could just fix their HVAC unit on their own! Or their own solar charge controller! What would the world come to next?!
- kayfox 3y agoIIRC you have to be licensed to purchase most refrigerants in Oregon. Your typical HVAC refrigerant R134a has a global warming potential 1430 times CO2.
- sidewndr46 3y agoI don't see how that is relevant. If I want a refrigerant, I go buy it. If I need a license, so be it. This isn't like getting a CDL. You take a course on proper handling & disposal and agree you'll follow it. Since you brought up refrigerant I'll go ahead and point out almost anyone can buy propane anywhere, including kids. It's a great refrigerant, it just can't have any trademark or patent protection. To compare this to the DRM placed on tech products, I'd need to have a cryptographically signed refrigerant bottle to recharge my AC.
- JohnFen 3y agoIt sure makes it clear which businesses were more lavish in their briber.. ahem.. lobbying efforts.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- teitoklien 3y agoThis is a horrible bill, those software locks have made stealing iPhones a unappealing incentive. Considering so many exceptions carved out for other devices, it seems like a bill was made for thieves to steal attractive high end gadgets to sell them for parts in the after market. It certainly doesnt make sense either from consumer standpoint or environmental standpoint considering the amount of exceptions it has added to the list. Now it’ll be appealing to steal phones again… Great !
- naitgacem 3y agoThis is a terrible take. Just because thieves exist we should all lose the right to repair our own stuff if we so choose? If they want to pair parts that's fine, but not providing the calibration software or whatever is NOT. regarding the exceptions, I think a better situation would be NO exceptions, rather than claim bills like this are useless because of exceptions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]