3 ms·
France amending its 66-year old Constitution to include abortion is a “world first.” Few Europeans would assert that their constitutions already guaranteed such
by rayiner 3y ago
France amending its 66-year old Constitution to include abortion is a “world first.” Few Europeans would assert that their constitutions already guaranteed such a right before those country’s regulated abortion under civil law. The ECHR has repeatedly declined invitations to find such a right in the EU Declaration of Human Rights. Meanwhile, many in America denounce the Supreme Court for observing that our 235 year old constitution isn’t any different from those (often much younger) European constitutions in that respect.
- hef19898 3y agoPeople dennounce the SCOTUS for throwing out precedent, and allowing state laws threating access to family planning and directly threatening the life of women. The age of the, honestly, sub-par constitution of the USA has nothing to do with it.
- pjc50 3y agoThe SCOTUS found two different answers in the "text" of the constitution depending on who was appointed to it. Which is the risk of a pure legalistic approach; it's difficult for a right to survive against a majority that actively oppose it.
- boxed 3y agoOr in this case a minority with the will to actually fight over it.
- hobs 3y agoTo be clear, a majority of people in the USA support access to abortion, its the fact that a minority court was packed with gerrymandered districts and a political party dead set on ending democracy that we got here.
- ThrowawayTestr 3y agoI figured it was because the Democrats never bothered to make it a law.
- rayiner 3y agoThat narrative turns the facts upside down. Was the Supreme Court wrong to ignore public opinion in 1973, when the citizens of every state banned abortion through their duly elected legislatures? Or is it wrong to ignore public opinion now? In reality, the Supreme Court in 1973 subverted democracy by striking down abortion laws every state had adopted through the democratic process. In 2022, the Supreme Court restored the issue to the democratic process.
- pjc50 3y ago> In reality, the Supreme Court in 1973 subverted democracy by striking down abortion laws every state had adopted through the democratic process. In 2022, the Supreme Court restored the issue to the democratic process. This is basically true, and a really serious indictment of democracy in America. All sorts of important rights, such as racial equality and equality of marriage (not just gay marriage, but interracial marriage!) had to be secured through legal action against a tyrannical and indifferent majority.
- rayiner 3y agoIf the majority doesn’t think something is a “right” then how can it be a right? Where does it come from?
- hobs 3y agoIt in no way turns facts upside down, it simply responds to the word majority and the current events, it's the facts to say that the supreme court did the opposite in the 1970s.
- rayiner 3y agoIf you think “democracy” matters, then the Supreme Court got it wrong in 1973 (by overturning laws that states adopted through the democratic process) and got it right in 2022 (by returning the issue to the democratic process).
- Levitz 3y agoYou can support access to abortion and disagree that there is a constitutional protection for such right. These are two different matters.
- a_gnostic 3y agoRoe vs. Wade was not about abortion, so much as it was about PRIVACY; Namely between you and your doctor.
- rayiner 3y ago“Privacy” isn’t in the constitution either. Griswold all but admits that, asserting that the privacy right can be found in “penumbras” (I.e. that it’s manufactured out of thin air).
- a_gnostic 3y ago4: The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized. 5: No person shall […] be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation. 9: The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people. 10: The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people. "Because you say so! …Is not good enough for me. "Because you say so! …They take our liberty! "Because you say so! …With guns to our heads! "Because you say so! …They want patriots dead!" -Right Arm of Wyoming https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YQVyesTRLWU https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YQVyesTRLWU
- peoplefromibiza 3y agowell... it's not the simple. First of all, the Constitution can be changed, like it has been in this case. Secondly, it says that “The law determines the conditions under which [..] (it) is exercised” So it can be made hard enough to challenge the right to abortion, like it is now in Italy, where it is virtually fully granted, but practically impossible in some areas, due to a Constitutional reform (ironically) that transitioned the healthcare from a national system to a regional one. So it depends on who's in charge in the region. Since 2001, a decisive transition is taking place, from decentralisation to true federalism, according to the principle of subsidiarity. As of 2001, the national health fund has been abolished and substituted by taxation yield directly attributed to Regions and autonomous Provinces https://www.salute.gov.it/resources/static/primopiano/unione/03.pdf https://www.salute.gov.it/resources/static/primopiano/unione... (PDF, page 92)
- a_gnostic 3y agoThe Tenth Amendment makes explicit two fundamental constitutional principles that are implicit in the document itself. •The federal government is only authorized to exercise those powers delegated to it. •The people of the several states retain the authority to exercise any power that is not delegated to the federal government as long as the Constitution doesn’t expressly prohibit it. https://tenthamendmentcenter.com/the-10th-amendment/ https://tenthamendmentcenter.com/the-10th-amendment/
- flanked-evergl 3y ago> The ECHR has repeatedly declined invitations to find such a right in the EU Declaration of Human Rights. Why can't the EU Declaration of Human Rights not just be amended to include it?
- throwaway11460 3y agoWhy would it, though? It already guarantees body autonomy. So does my country's constitution. No need to be more specific - actually that might be for the worse - states/lawmakers could start arguing it has to be explicit about every possible procedure like in the abortion case.
- flanked-evergl 3y agoSome people who are against abortion do not consider a fetus as part of the mother's body.
- hef19898 3y agoAs George Clooney so brilliantly pointed out in Three Kings: Necessity and Priorities. The EU has a lot stuff on their plate, from Ukraine to Gaza. One thing at a time. And yes, it seems that for the time being, abortion is not really ubder threat in the EU at the moment, so they can focus on other things. I applaud France for doing this, and hope the EU, and more member nations, do follow suite in the future.
- throwaway11460 3y agoWell then they should understand that a mother might choose - or be forced - to stop supporting the fetus with her body. It's not like they're cutting the fetus open, they're cutting the mother open (or giving her drugs). They might say - it killed the fetus. Yes. Sometimes people disconnect the life support.
- flanked-evergl 3y agoThat is surely something you can take up in discussion with people who are anti-abortion, but back to my original question: Why can't the EU Declaration of Human Rights not just be amended to include a right to abortion?
- skhunted 3y agoHighly intelligent legal experts in the form of Supreme Court justices determined that states can’t ban abortions. Other equally intelligent legal experts in the form of Supreme Court justices determined otherwise. Both sets of people wrote cogent opinions in support of their position. What is one to make of these facts? The Constitution says what you want it to say and you can write a well written, well reasoned argument supporting what you want it to say. Our Constitution, in reality, is much more than the words written in it. It’s morphed due to judicial precedent over the course of 200 or so years.
- boxed 3y agoIt's more fundamental than that even. The constitution is in fact powerless without people. That's it. If you don't have the people there's nothing the constitution can do about it. Might is right, in that dead people don't get to decide anything. If the next generation growing up decided to not respect Congress, then in a generation the entire institution would cease.
- rayiner 3y agoThe point of comparison to European constitutions is that their highly intelligent people are smarter about what they’re willing to make up out of thin air. European constitutions have way more meat on them out of which to read in a right of abortion than ours.
- skhunted 3y agoAnd people much more versed on the law than you and I (I know you are a lawyer) believe it wasn’t made “up out of thin air”. You didn’t understand the point I made. Your opinion and whether or not abortion in the U.S. is a constitutional right is not objectively the correct one. Well meaning experts with more expertise than you disagree with your characterization.
- rayiner 3y agoWhen Roe was decided, a liberal law professor stated that it is “bad constitutional law, or rather because it is not constitutional law and gives almost no sense of an obligation to try to be.” Hardly anyone defend’s Roe’s original reasoning anymore, because it makes no sense. That’s why over the decades the defense of Roe has largely been reduced to the assertion that it’s precedent. It’s the left’s Lochner. Invoking “experts” is unavailing because those experts are not speaking within the scope of their expertise. Their assertions are in the realm of moral philosophy, not law. It’s a religious edict within the church of secular humanism.
- silent_cal 3y agoI thought Ireland did this too?