3 ms·
I hope the FCC does take this lead in trying to censor the net, ahead of requiring all the "private" carriers to do so. Government attempts for increased contro
by mindslight 18y ago
I hope the FCC does take this lead in trying to censor the net, ahead of requiring all the "private" carriers to do so. Government attempts for increased control have to come sometime, and I'd rather have that happen on a single network so that the workarounds are developed before the majority of people are affected.
- jmtame 18y agoI thought the current requirement was that websites were required to verify age before allowing users to enter? You make it sound like the ISPs are doing this job, which I wasn't aware that they were.
- mindslight 18y agoI believe what you're referring to is the regulations on collecting data on people under 13. Which is why you've got to check those meaningless 'I'm over 13' boxes. Annoying and pointless, but not really censorship. The bulk data taps are much more worrying, and those are mandated on the ISPs (look what happened to the Qwest CEO). The next thing forced onto the ISPs will be mandatory proxying of certain connections (like the system that recently snagged wikipedia in the UK).
- tdavis 18y agoUh... why should anyone be allowed, much less required, to censor the net?
- mindslight 18y agoThe net threatens the status quo, so the status quo will attempt to control the net. Stronger attempts to put the net.genie back in the bottle are coming. I most certainly agree that the net should not be censored, but stopping censorship will not happen through democratic means - the herd is easily panicked with tales of child abuse, terrorism, organized crime, etc. The control will be defeated through technical means - pervasive encryption seamlessly integrated into every day applications, such that filtering "bad stuff" from "normal usage" is impossible. All I'm saying is that I'd like to see one ISP blaze the trail of total control (and thus become the technical battleground) instead of all of them at once.
- tdavis 18y agoAh, so you'd rather have one established technology to circumvent than numerous being worked on in parallel. Gotcha. I will stick with my irrational assumption that the Internet at large is safe from this shit, at least until I'm too old to care ;)
- mindslight 18y agoMore like I'd rather have a sandbox that gives an advance look at what's coming to the rest of the net. My assumption is only slightly weaker - the long term internet is fine as privacy technology will outpace politics, but there will be turmoil as they battle.
- mike_organon 18y agoYou make an interesting point, analogous to building an immune system slowly from small diseases, so one big disease can't kill you or an entire population. Similarly, small-time malware over the years has made us stronger against major internet attacks by governments or mafias. However, it's a risky path - from what I've read China's firewall has enough holes for business to get by with annoyances, but it is very effective at keeping most people from learning what they shouldn't.