4 ms·
Foucault has strengths and weaknesses, makes good points, makes bad points, but is almost always read by people as part of or adjacent to some other ongoing edu
by defrost 3y ago
Foucault has strengths and weaknesses, makes good points, makes bad points, but is almost always read by people as part of or adjacent to some other ongoing education. Foucault gets debated and recognised for having pros and cons.
Diamond, unlike Foucault, is damn near airport departure lounge fodder; historians and sociologists generally encounter general members of the public who are uncritically fans of Diamond and near venerate the GG&S book for radically changing their world view, etc.
It's that association that grates after a while .. it can be as relentless as those who approach mathematicians with their novel proofs for squaring a circle.
- Der_Einzige 3y agoI have read both, and Foucault is 100x the charlatan than diamond is. Foucault is responsible for significant amounts of fashionable nonsense within the academy.
- defrost 3y agoC'mon now, he was pretty spot on about that pendulum ... /jk
- Radim 3y agoTo paraphrase Roosevelt: "He may be a charlatan, but he's OUR charlatan!"
- DiscourseFan 3y ago>fashionable nonsense If you believe that critiquing the prison-industrial complex is fashionable non-sense, then I think I know where you lie politically.
- Der_Einzige 3y agoI (unfortunately) read most of his works alongside a lot of the post-modernist cannon while participating in speech and debate. While he may give some interesting speculative reasoning about the nature of state power, he's ultimately fashionable nonsense. Lacan, Zizek, Foucault, and Derrida are The 4 horsemen of the epistemological apocalypse.
- DiscourseFan 3y ago>Lacan, Zizek, Foucault, and Derrida are The 4 horsemen of the epistemological apocalypse. We should probably just go back to Rhene Thom and Morphogenesis, except that even that theory has lost face. A hundred years of denying the importance of Hegel's Logic has led to a significant loss in the progress of human civilization.
- throw4847285 3y agoA Kant scholar once told me that the difference between Kant and Hume is that Kant described simple ideas complexly and Hume described complex ideas simply. To apply that to Foucault and and Diamond, Foucault explored complex ideas obtusely and Diamond explores dumb ideas simply. Sure, the academy has a bias towards complexity. It is slightly self-justifying. But let's not be black and white thinkers and assume that the opposite is true, and that airport reading by somebody with no historical credentials must be some secret truth the academy doesn't want you to now. It might just be popular bunk.
- DiscourseFan 3y agoContemporary anthropology is...not very good. Latour's critiques are still quite strong and very difficult to overcome; perhaps anthropology as a field is fundamentally flawed. I haven't read Diamond, but I could understand, if you're a liberal academic and you see a text, almost like Nietzsche's Geneaology of Morals, that just says that the strong always conquer the weak because of totally contingent conditions, it will seem horrifying because, as a liberal, you genuinely believe in personal agency and social justice and all that fun stuff. But go back and actually read Marx, go and read all your favorite Frankfurt school thinkers: they will say, the conditions that we have been placed in are a real illusion of nature: even if the so-called nature of things is a construction, it is one where the reality of it is undeniable for us. Therefore, the goal of critique, even in that Marxian, Kantian sense, is to raise consciousness to shatter that real illusion precisely by illuminating this so-called "natural" process. For Marx, revolution is a natural result of the development of Capitalism, but Capitalism also dissolved history, and temporality, so the naturality of revolution must be immanent in every moment of its development: its like Walter Benjamin said, we must bring about a real catastrophe, as opposed to the constant "accidents" of human suffering under the system that come about with almost mechanical regularity. In any case, I don't remember Marx ever being either an academic, or particularly hard to read in most cases, even if a thorough familiarity with German Idealism is a great help to understanding him more deeply. Even Foucault was technically an academic, but only because he helped organize a nearly successful revolutionary movement that managed to extract the concession of an entire university (Paris VIII) out of the government which he then ran, and is still being run by his students and colleagues to this day.
- NeuNeurosis 3y agoIf someone wanted to read more into the theory(s) you highlighted do you have any recommendations on where to start? I ask because I have not heard either of those ideas put that way of the real illusion being undeniable and needing to shatter that real illusion by raising consciousness, or the idea of "Walter Benjamin said, we must bring about a real catastrophe" Any recommendations are welcome. Context no background in German Idealism just some cursory understanding of Marxism and Nietzche.