4 ms·
> I disagree, and I always upgrade the RAM even though I don’t like paying more. Why? Because it puts pressure on developers to keep the bloat under control. S
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> I disagree, and I always upgrade the RAM even though I don’t like paying more. Why? Because it puts pressure on developers to keep the bloat under control.
Shouldn't you be doing the opposite then? Keeping the baseline amount so you can know what it's like for people without a large budget and stop patronizing the applications without acceptable footprints in that circumstance?
> In that world you’d have all the software growing in memory use without bound.
We already live in that world. In the 90s you could run Netscape Navigator on a machine with 8 megabytes of memory. I've seen individual browser tabs use more gigabytes than that.
And not all of this is Electron bloat. The Stable Diffusion XL model is ~13GB. In general the quality is going to be proportional to the model size. So for the thing to get better, people need machines with more memory. And 8GB is already too small.
- chongli 3y agoShouldn't you be doing the opposite then? Keeping the baseline amount so you can know what it's like for people without a large budget and stop patronizing the applications without acceptable footprints in that circumstance? I'm not a developer of native Mac apps. If I were, I would definitely have a baseline machine for testing. The Stable Diffusion XL model is ~13GB That's not a baseline consumer application. See my other reply (re: grandma and little Billy). If you're developing a native Mac app for grandma and little Billy, Apple probably doesn't want you shipping a 13GB model with it. This is an example of the point I'm trying to make: find a way to compress the model so the end user doesn't have to deal with that kind of bloat (or host it in the cloud).
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> I'm not a developer of native Mac apps. If I were, I would definitely have a baseline machine for testing. You expect every developer to buy a second Mac? They're all doing what you're doing and paying more for the machine with more memory because other applications need it, and then their application runs fine on that machine so they don't even notice the problem for the people with 8GB. > That's not a baseline consumer application. It will be before any of these new machines go out of support.
- skydhash 3y ago> You expect every developer to buy a second Mac? It's very easy to check the memory usage of your project (it's kinda in your face on XCode). If you do a few minutes test or let the app stay open for a few hours and usage has ballooned to a few GBs, that usually means you have a leak somewhere to fix.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoBut the developer of exactly the app using all your memory is writing it in Electron from Windows and has never used XCode.
- skydhash 3y agoThere’s a lot of profiling tools. There’s even one in the browser’s inspector. It’s not something exclusive to XCode. You can even use Task Manager/Activity Monitor/System Monitor in a pinch.
- chongli 3y agoAnd is there any wonder Electron has such a terrible reputation? The thing that really bothers me is that if you look at what regular home and office users were doing on their computers in the 90's it's almost identical to what those users are doing right now, except in the 90's they had orders of magnitude slower computers with orders of magnitude less memory. Yet in many cases those 90's computers were MORE RESPONSIVE than what they have today. All of those countless billions of investment in technology hasn't done a damn thing for the productivity of Sally the office worker or Billy the 6th grader. Arguably, it's made their lives worse (viz. social media's deleterious effects on mental health). Now everyone's pushing the heck out of AI and all I see is high schoolers using ChatGPT to cheat themselves out of an education. They can't read (critically), they can't write, they can't even spell! So in light of all that, why should we be pushing more and more computing power (and memory, the original issue) on regular users who aren't getting any benefit (broadly, to their way of life) out of it? Gosh, now I sound like a luddite!
- 3y ago
- thfuran 3y ago>We already live in that world. Nah, the treadmill stalled out years ago.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe CPU treadmill did because Moore's Law petered out. RAM keeps getting cheaper and applications keep using more of it.
- thfuran 3y agoRAM usage has barely budged for years. Taking the '90s as baseline again: In 1991, you could get a brand new PowerBook 100 with 2 MB of RAM. In 2001, you'd get a new PowerBook G4 with 128 MB of RAM, a 64-fold increase. But in 2013, a MacBook Air came standard with 4GB, and we're looking at only 8GB in 2024.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoYou're taking as your example the thing people are complaining about. 8GB of DDR5 is ~$24 retail, and that's the amount Apple is putting in their $1000 laptop. PCs of the same price typically have 32-64GB. You're also using a time period that includes COVID and when the DRAM manufacturers got busted for price fixing.
- thfuran 3y ago>PCs of the same price typically have 32-64GB. That's not a run of the mill consumer set up. >You're also using a time period that includes COVID and when the DRAM manufacturers got busted for price fixing No, I'm actually including two separate time periods where they were busted for price fixing. They were doing it in the late '90s too.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> That's not a run of the mill consumer set up. It kind of is, e.g. Steam hardware survey has more than 80% of people with at least 16GB of RAM and almost a third with 32GB, and that's a measure of installed base rather than new computers. You can now find 64GB in <$550 laptops: https://www.newegg.com/p/1TS-000D-110E6?Item=9SIA7ABJ459240 https://www.newegg.com/p/1TS-000D-110E6?Item=9SIA7ABJ459240 > No, I'm actually including two separate time periods where they were busted for price fixing. They were doing it in the late '90s too. They started doing it at the end of the '90s. By then PowerBooks were already coming with 64MB and PowerMacs with 128MB: https://everymac.com/systems/apple/powerbook_g3/specs/powerbook_g3_300.html https://everymac.com/systems/apple/powerbook_g3/specs/powerb... https://everymac.com/systems/apple/powermac_g3/specs/powermac_g3_333_mt.html https://everymac.com/systems/apple/powermac_g3/specs/powerma... In the second case it started only 3 years into your measurement period instead of 7, and then right after that was COVID. It's only now that the prices are starting to resume their historical downward trend and they're still slightly above where they were when the price fixing started in 2016. But that explains why it's not a factor of 64 during this period. It's still the case that 8GB of DDR5 is ~$24. What reason is there to not include $100 worth on a $1000 machine? Or, if some excuse for that could be generated, why isn't there a $1100 machine with four times as much?