3 ms·
> The idea behind the current c2rust tool is that you'd do a one-shot conversion to Rust and then gradually do refactoring passes over the barely-Rust code to c
by Animats 3y ago
> The idea behind the current c2rust tool is that you'd do a one-shot conversion to Rust and then gradually do refactoring passes over the barely-Rust code to convert it to correct C code.
I've seen what comes out of the transpiler. Nobody should touch that code by hand. It's awful Rust, and uglier than the original C. Modifying that by hand is like modifying compiler-generated machine code.
> This is actually why C23 made VLA support semi-mandatory.
C23 doesn't actually use that info. You can't get the size of buf from buf. I proposed something like that 12 years ago.[1] But I wanted to add enough features to check it.
[1] http://animats.com/papers/languages/safearraysforc43.pdf http://animats.com/papers/languages/safearraysforc43.pdf
- jcranmer 3y ago> I've seen what comes out of the transpiler. Nobody should touch that code by hand. It's awful Rust, and uglier than the original C. I can't disagree here. I think the original idea was to rely on automated refactoring tools to try to make the generated Rust somewhat more palatable, but I never was able to get that working. > C23 doesn't actually use that info. True; the intent is to require it so that it can be leveraged by future extensions. The C committee tends to move glacially.
- Animats 3y agoThe real problem is not translating code. It's translating data types. If you can determine that a "char *" in C can be a Vec in Rust, you're most of the way there. It's no longer ambiguous what to do with the accesses. This is where I think LLMs could help. Ask an LLM "In this code, could variable "buf" be safely represented as a Rust "Vec", and if so, what is its length?. LLMs don't really know the languages, but they have access to many samples, which is probably good enough to get a correct guess most of the time. That's enough to provide annotation hints to a dumb translator. The problem here is translating C idioms to Rust idioms, which is an LLM kind of problem.
- galangalalgol 3y agoThey have made some improvements here recently. There is a lot less unsafe generated. The rest is more idiomatic too. The cost is that it will be throwing panics everywhere until you fix the faulty assumptions it asserted. I like the new way better.