3 ms·
You don't have to think that whoever is leading at 80% "necessarily" will win. People remember close elections, like Florida in 2000 or Ohio in 2004, where you
by rayiner 3y ago
You don't have to think that whoever is leading at 80% "necessarily" will win. People remember close elections, like Florida in 2000 or Ohio in 2004, where you couldn't tell until all the votes were counted who had won.
But Trump's election-day lead in key swing states was not close. In Georgia, at 10:55 pm, Trump was ahead by 12 points and over 350,000 votes as of 11 pm ET with 72% of precincts reporting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cp_drtD7cMc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cp_drtD7cMc. As of the next morning, Trump was ahead in Pennsylvania by more than 10 points with 70% of the precincts counted. Then, over the coming days, Biden somehow pulled ahead--not just in one state, but in several.
If you go back to the dawn of cable news election coverage, I think you would be hard pressed to find an example where a candidate was behind 10-12 points on election night in key swing states but went on to win those states. My dad and I have been watching CNN election night coverage since the mid-1990s, and we both went to bed thinking that Trump had not only one, but had done so decisively.
- tptacek 3y agoThis bounced around in my brain all day yesterday and I think it's a miserable example. You might be right in general, I don't know, but 2020 isn't the right data point to use. The situation in 2020 was unique. If you had tasked state governments with coming up with an election process that would guarantee alarming late-breaking swings, you couldn't have done better than what Pennsylvania did. Because of COVID, mail-in ballots strongly correlated with party affiliation. Meanwhile, the Pennsylvania government set up ballot counting rules that ensured those ballots would be counted late. The state literally set up the conditions for one party's results to come in first, and in states like PA (and now GA and AZ) the margins are so thin that any structural effect like that is going to produce the same outcome. You're going to say "well that's my point", but my argument is that 2020 is sui generis, and that states are going to do a bunch of things differently in 2024, beyond just the fact that Democrats are going to vote in person about the same as they did in 2016.
- rayiner 3y agoHow is 2020 not the right data point to use? The first sentence of the article is: "Thirty percent of Americans claim, despite all evidence to the contrary, that the last presidential elections were 'rigged.'" To your average person, the 2020 election results cannot be explained based on their past experience--which is the only way most people are capable of understanding anything. So what you believe about the results depends on who you trust. And lots of people don't trust Democrat-run counties to count votes correctly. They don't trust courts, who regularly do things like find new constitutional rights in a 235 year old document. Nor do they trust CNN anchors, who have dropped all pretenses about what they think about the "deplorables."
- tptacek 3y agoThey don't believe that because they're innumerate, they believe that because the 2020 election was conducted under extraordinary circumstances that are unlikely to repeat. The rest of your points thus have the causality reversed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]