4 ms·
The 'space age' was ahead of its time. And I don't mean that in a positive way: 'putting a clown on the moon' (to quote Tom Lehrer) was an enormously expensive
by eru 3y ago
The 'space age' was ahead of its time. And I don't mean that in a positive way: 'putting a clown on the moon' (to quote Tom Lehrer) was an enormously expensive project with 1960s technology for at best questionable utility. (Apart from winning a pissing contest with the Soviets.)
Similar for the Concorde.
Nowadays, we would be much better placed to put people in space. But fortunately we are perhaps wiser (or perhaps forced to be wiser against our own impulses), and are still not lining up to re-ignite manned space flight.
I'm all for space exploration, but manned space exploration does not (yet?) make sense, and neither does space tourism so far.
- emchammer 3y agoI disagree with that cynicism, though. I saw Apollo 11 three times when it came out, and I still get excited when I see the sense of purpose and detail in everybody involved. It was a singular event that occurred at this conflux of technology and hubris, like Christopher Columbus' landing. It took so long for everybody to sort out their feelings on what this meant, that an entire subculture sprung up based on the idea that it was all faked by a contemporaneous sci-fi director. It's okay to appreciate those kinds of wins from time to time. And anyway the astronauts brought back a moon rock to give to the Soviets.
- zabzonk 3y agonot sure what this means - perhaps 13 rather than 11?
- eru 3y ago> I saw Apollo 11 three times when it came out, and I still get excited when I see the sense of purpose and detail in everybody involved. I think you are proving my point? Manned spaceflight is strictly for entertainment and pissing contests only. So we should finance it like entertainment, instead of making random tax payers suffer for your amusement. > And anyway the astronauts brought back a moon rock to give to the Soviets. Yes? Obviously you are going to be all smug and rub your success in your adversaries face. --- Btw, just to be clear: I also find space flight inspiring, and I hope I live long enough to see the vast bulk of humanity living in space habitats (while still increasing the absolute number of humans on earth). I want to see space elevators (via active support) and all that good stuff. Two things: (1) The early manned space flight barely contributed to these long term goals. It's only recently thanks to the private sector that launch costs are starting to come down. And the other big advances are coming from better robotics and better computing, both of which are being developed on trajectories so far largely independent of space exploration. (2) I don't want to force other tax payers to suffer for my flights of fancy. Just like I don't want to have to finance other people's pet projects with my tax money, either.
- panick21_ 3y agoI kind of disagree. Yes the person on the moon wasn't that important but all the technology outside of the moonlander itself had nice utility. Its just that the US kind of messed up its space investment strategy. Instead of leveraging all the parts of Apollo it was systematically killed. Had the doubled down on Apollo and simply continued investing in the technology they could have done impressive things. The could have built a Saturn 1C as a workhorse rocket for the military and commercial. And then have the Saturn V as your super heavy for the occasional deep space probe, huge telescope or space station. The Apollo capsule could incrementally be made reusable and could continue to be used for LEO or occasional moon missions. During Apollo they were already deep in development on second generation version of the different components. This was not actually finically unsustainable, it was just financially unsustainable while also investing in Shuttle. And because a Saturn 1C wasn't considered, the military built itself up with Titan rockets instead.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe Saturn 1B looks vaguely like Falcon 9 if you squint appropriately. The H-1 engine is in the same thrust class as the Merlin 1D (it just weighs twice as much). So, one can imagine the S1B evolving over the years into something like a F9, with the first stage being recovered. The idea of designing boosters to minimize cost rather than maximize performance also goes back to the late 60s. The biggest problem is government contractors have different incentive structures than SpaceX does.
- panick21_ 3y agoIt would really be the government driving to a unified architecture, making the apart commodity and create enough demand. It would need actual long term strategy.
- eru 3y ago> I kind of disagree. Yes the person on the moon wasn't that important but all the technology outside of the moonlander itself had nice utility. Counterfactually, all the tax payer money wasted on manned space flight would have been used for something else, and would have driven some other technology, and at that other spending would have had direct utility. (Especially if the money had been left in the tax payers pockets.) See 'What Is Seen and What Is Not Seen' https://www.econlib.org/library/Bastiat/basEss.html?chapter_num=4#book-reader https://www.econlib.org/library/Bastiat/basEss.html?chapter_... > Had the doubled down on Apollo and simply continued investing in the technology they could have done impressive things. You really need to learn to start thinking in terms of opportunity costs. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opportunity_cost https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opportunity_cost > [...] it was just financially unsustainable while also investing in Shuttle. I agree that the Space Shuttle was an even greater waste than the Apollo program. They overshot their projected cost per kg to orbit by 100,000% (one thousand times). But I hold that approximately all manned space flight is a waste of tax payer money.