4 ms·
Gold recovery from e-waste by food-waste amyloid aerogels
- mistrial9 3y agolet's do a thought experiment.. think of a modern passenger airplane. That airplane has thousands of specialized parts really.. each one made of plastic or metals or other.. together, it makes something that has enormous, powerful benefit.. to travel over water and mountains and neighbors, to get to a destination and very quickly. Each of those airplane parts could be "recycled" at the end of life, but a) they are unique to their purposes, not made to be generally recyclable and b) the materials are often very low cost in terms of the raw material inputs.. manufacturing starts to mature like that.. so any recycling value for just the materials, is likely low from the material point of view alone.. Now, with that example in mind.. think of a PC computer or server rack mount computers .. each part could be taken out.. the value of the material itself, and the lack of recyclable design.. makes each part very low value and difficult or impossible to recycle.. and here is the conclusion.. The very high value of the complete device or airplane, is completely lost once more than a few parts are removed. The "value chain" of reuse is destroyed quickly.. with the scrap being far, far less value than the thing it came from.. this is a giant loss of energy in more than one way, and a giant source of waste in the deepest sense..
- r00fus 3y agoYour analogy would break down as, if the airplane were intact and had good chain of custody, then the owner would at the very least sell it to a junkyard that would part out the most valuable parts. More likely it would be sold to be reused. The challenge is the capitalist strategy of manufactured obsolescence that make valid products turn into complete junk to sell new product. That and the proliferation of cheap ill designed products are the largest source of waste in the world.
- infinite-hugs 3y agoWhile recycling may not be cost effective in some cases, for what it’s worth there is a thriving remanufacturing market of airplane parts.
- ggm 3y agoWe have really good efficient gold recovery. The problem is that its socially and actually toxic: socially because it destroys poor economies to turn them into recovery stations littered with PCBs and bad stuff, and actually because gold recovery typically involves burning things, like associated plastics, and use of stuff like Cyanide which winds up in the waste water stream, peoples body fat, you-name-it. So this technique may well be less "efficient" but if it's less toxic, and uses another waste stream, it can be worth it. I wonder when, if ever, it will be viable to grind up chips and things to extract gallium and other trace elements which represent high cost supply chain risks (most viable rare earth mines are chinese because the west is lazy about maintaining their own sources)
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoYou mention a social problem, but it's an economic / capitalist problem; countries have been exporting and trading e-waste to the highest bidder that in turn sends it to the cheapest labor to get any value out of it. Waste should be processed as close to the source as possible, and waste should not be exported unless it actually gets processed properly, that is, if exporting to a country with good recycling facilities instead of putting it in landfill/incinerators. But the checks and balances for that are poor. IIRC / I have no source and may be making it up, in western countries, plastic is ticked off as "recycled" when it's been separated and baled up; if it's then exported and burned, landfill'd or chucked in the ocean doesn't matter anymore, the country fulfilled its pledge of recycling plastic.
- kragen 3y agocyanide is not a brand name, gallium is not a rare earth element, and almost all rare earth elements are cheap and abundant worldwide consequently i am also skeptical about your grasp of the things i don't know about, like the economic effects of pcb recycling on poor economies
- ggm 3y agoFair. The abundance isn't the problem the state of the mines for rare earth and other things is. A couple of options in Australia went to sleep when China cut prices and they haven't woken up afaik. Same with lithium options the price makes Western clean extraction much less profitable and we're not short of cheap lithium. Snark is frowned upon here. Complaining I capitalised cyanide is pretty snarky but your substantive points stand. Am I right in thinking your dislike of my shallow economic statements should not be read as believing you think pcb recycling has no downsides? Because you would be in a very small room if you said it's only good to send dead pc parts to Asia and Africa for teardown. Even the vendors now say they know this isn't all peachy.
- blacksqr 3y agoPeople have been trying for over a hundred years to find ways to extract gold and other precious metals efficiently from seawater, where the supply is virtually unlimited but extremely dilute. When I saw this article my first thought was, maybe this is finally the stuff that could do it.
- pests 3y agoThe Shai-Hulud of the sea.
- euroderf 3y agoDesert Power TNG
- pg_bot 3y agoI think you could extract Vanadium from seawater by farming sea squirts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanabin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanabin
- fbdab103 3y agoNOAA claims there is 1 gram gold / 100 million metric tons of seawater[0]. Even if you could refine it, there has to be other valuable materials at significantly higher concentrations with a plausible profit margin. [0] https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/gold.html https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/gold.html
- tecleandor 3y agoThat's ten grams per cubic kilometer, and given the volume for the Atlantic Ocean I can see in Wikipedia [0], that'd be 3100 Metric Tons of gold, that is around the global yearly production of gold [1]. It's a big number, but yeah, probably there's something else more expensive. Like salt. At today's price, that's around $650 of gold per cubic km. A cubic km of Atlantic water, having a salt concentration of 3.3%, would have around 32 million metric tons of salt. At today's cheapest price of 8$ per ton of salt in brine (that I don't even know if it's correct, but i got it from here [2]), that'd be $240 million per cubic km. Way more profitable per cubic km of water (if you don't factor the cost of moving 32 million metric tons of anything :D ) 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantic_Ocean 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_gold_production 2: https://www.statista.com/statistics/916733/us-salt-prices-by-type/