3 ms·
Geographic arguments are a very common tool in pop Social Sciences, for example the correlation between landlocked states and poverty or supposed American excep
by alephnerd 3y ago
Geographic arguments are a very common tool in pop Social Sciences, for example the correlation between landlocked states and poverty or supposed American exceptionalism due to the fertile Midwest (while ignoring similar agrarian immigrant countries like Brazil and Argentina).
Furthermore, the kinds of argumements that Diamond would provide weren't actually "tested" per say. Social Sciences are a "Science" (albeit flawed in some shape or form), but are dependent on validating a hypothesis in a reproducible manner as well, hence why economics has basically become applied math since the 50s (and similar changes in other fields like Sociology, Linguistics, Polticial Science, and Anthro as well)
There isn't much difference between grifters like Perun or Zeihan and Jared Diamond.
Also, Jared Diamond doesn't have a background in Economics or Political Science - he is an Ecologist/Environmental Scientist (and one of the best ones at that), and as such reading GGS induces Dunning-Kruger for those with a background in Comparitive Politics.
- mistrial9 3y agothis comment reads like you called Jared Diamond a "grifter" e.g. diligent con and knowing thief.. maybe you did not mean that exactly?
- alephnerd 3y agoI did mean that. No one in the academic PoliSci, Sociology, or Anthropology space views him as credible. He is a great Ecologist and Environmental Historian, but he is not someone with domain experience in Comparative Politics, Political Economy, IR, and/or other adjacent fields which people try to extrapolate GGS to.
- michaelcampbell 3y ago> other adjacent fields which people try to extrapolate GGS to I don't have a dog in the fight other than having read (most of) GG&S and found his writing style laborious, but the quoted bit above seems more like an issue with those other people that Diamond. If I say "x" and people extrapolate that to things for which it was not intended, how does that make _ME_ a grifter?
- alephnerd 3y agoThe issue is Jared Diamond explicitly argues for Environmental Determinism despite it largely being bunk. He has had multiple opportunities to clear up his arguments, but he only digs deeper and deeper into it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bambataa 3y agoPerrin the guy on YouTube? What’s wrong with him?