8 ms·
The FBI took -- and mysteriously returned -- their server
- RyanMBoland 15y agoI'm a student at the University of Pittsburgh. From that point of view, this seems like a perfectly fine action to take. The FBI agents may have disrupted service to a few hundred users, but these threats were affecting thousands of people. I don't know if these anonymous email threats were unprecedented or not, but they certainly present a huge challenge to law enforcement. What would have happened if the people responsible didn't just stop? Of course, you could subscribe to the view of the conspiracy theorists among us who feel that the FBI did actually catch the people responsible and are now employing them. :P
- BryanB55 15y agoI pretty much agree, they talked about "innocent peoples privacy" but if they are truly innocent then it shouldn't matter if the FBI sees their information. If my data were on that server and I was doing nothing wrong I really don't think I would mind handing it over to the FBI to help find even the smallest threat to our country.
- RyanMBoland 15y agoBut, was anyone's personal data really on that server? If it's an anonymous emailing service I would think that just the service was disrupted.
- BryanB55 15y agoCould be. I'm curious to hear why my comment was down voted though, regardless of whether there was information on the server or not. It seems a lot of people are always screaming "privacy!" and when I mention I'm willing to give up some privacy to protect the safety of other people and our country others do not agree with me. What is it you think will happen if the FBI gets a hold of your data on a server? This of course is just my opinion and I respect everyone else's opinion but I would like to hear a counter argument.
- AkThhhpppt 15y agoYou're getting downvoted because you've just rephrased the "if you've nothing to hide, you've nothing to fear" argument. Here, have a counterargument: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=998565& http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=998565...;
- BryanB55 15y agoThanks. I'll look it over.
- DanBC 15y agoGathering, pre-processing, entering, and storing information costs time and money. Having more data about more people increases the risks of false positives ("Innocent Bob is a terrorist!") and false negatives ("Terrorist Ann is innocent!"); and raises the risks of faulty data being gathered, processed and entered. So, having data about innocent people just increases costs and decreases quality.
- sopooneo 15y agoRight to privacy is fundamental in the United States. People should never have to respond to the argument that if they are truly innocent they won't mind some breach.
- CWuestefeld 15y agoUp-vote because many people feel this way, so it's important to discuss. But I strongly disagree. From that point of view, this seems like a perfectly fine action to take. There's certainly an argument to be made in support of your statement. If we were to work in a purely utilitarian manner, there would be little room for argument. But the design of the structure of civil rights we have in America doesn't work that way. We recognize that people have certain inherent, inalienable right. Even if stripping someone's rights would save tremendous tragedy, our philosophical underpinnings prevent it. We don't condone torture (unless you're the current President or his predecessor), even when we might be able to extract information that could save many. We could save many thousand people who are sick, and destined to die, waiting in vain for organ transplants. Just pick somebody's name out of a hat, and divide up his organs -- a liver, a heart, a couple of kidneys. For each life we took, we could save four or more others (not to mention improving others with cornea transplants, etc.). But despite the fact that utilitarian balance says that the net benefit to society would be positive, our system will not even contemplate such an action. Those examples are extreme, but they illustrate the point that we don't take actions that injure innocent people (and remember, everyone is innocent until proven guilty) even when they can save many others.
- RyanMBoland 15y agoI think that you've taken this too far. We can't make blanket statements about peoples rights and expect them to be applicable in every situation. In this case, a legal authority made the decision to interrupt a service for a small period of time in order to investigate a terrorist act that was disrupting the lives of thousands of people daily. If this was, say, a service that was providing medical assistance to elderly people, I don't think the same decision would have been made.
- BryanB55 15y agoI agree... In one case you're talking about killing someone and taking their organs to give to others and in the other we're talking about disrupting someones email usage to prevent bomb detonation. Can we see the difference here? I still don't see any reason that I would not give up my private information on a server in order to protect our country and thousands of lives... looking up some counter arguments though. I can't think of any good ones off the top of my head.
- bbit 15y agoThis is expected. If you run a business on a service dedicated to keep what you do hidden expect to have some visitors. It's no different then megauploa where people with legit files got all butt hurt when they knew megaupload was sketchy at best.
- biancabronx 15y agoScary stuff. The state of privacy in society today is nothing short of scary.
- ahi 15y agoA smaller issue in this story but still important; what kind of data center gets a search warrant and server pulled, and doesn't immediately notify their client? Are they legally prohibited from doing so? Then they let the FBI put the possibly compromised server back on the network? WTF?
- Karunamon 15y agoSeems to be SOP from all of the data center horror stories that I've heard.. site/apps go offline, datacenter or domain registrar gives you no useful information of any kind, truth later found out via third party or lawyer work.
- maratd 15y ago> Are they legally prohibited from doing so? Yes. They can be charged with obstruction of justice or interfering with an investigation.
- ahi 15y agoStill doesn't make much sense. The client is going to figure it out. Also, a search warrant doesn't give the Feds the ability to put it back. Maybe with a national security letter for the purpose of putting spyware on it? But even then the server owner is going to notice that their server went missing for a couple days. "Must have gone for a long walk. Glad it's back," is not how I would approach it.
- maratd 15y ago> Still doesn't make much sense. On the contrary, it makes perfect sense. It gives the FBI or any law enforcement agency sufficient leeway to do as they please, which is always the intent of such laws. > The client is going to figure it out. The only thing the client knows is that their server isn't working. Not that they are about to be raped by the feds.
- ahi 15y ago
- lincolnwebs 15y agoIf that were my server, I'd pull the data needed and burn the hardware. Never use it again.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Nrsolis 15y agoNFW. I'd build a new machine from scratch, at a different datacenter, using pristine code and data from backups. Once a machine has been in an adversary's possession, not even the data is safe. That said, the FBI probably just imaged the drives. They're not as clueful/devious as many think they are.
- alecco 15y agoThey do hire clueful contractors once in a while.
- Nrsolis 15y agoCorrect. But the guys were probably Special Agents and were from the data forensics group that are recruited into the DoJ specifically for their IT skills. It's also possible that there was a Special Agent + Contractor team working. BTW, they are probably not very happy that video evidence of their activities was captured and published. Don't look for them to make that mistake again.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- koeselitz 15y ago>> "That said, the FBI probably just imaged the drives. They're not as clueful/devious as many think they are." I would agree, but it also doesn't seem like some kind of act of charity that they plugged the thing in and tried to reconnect it and made sure it was apparently working before they left.
- patrickgzill 15y agoHere is my question... If you rent an apartment, even though you don't own the building, you have "rights of tenant in possession". Basically the apartment is "yours" and you have rights. If a search warrant is to be served to search your place, it gets served on YOU, not the owner of the buildng. If you rent server space, like a rack in a datacenter, that space is "yours". So should the search warrant have been honored?
- corin_ 15y agoGenerally speaking you aren't renting server space, you're renting server equipment i.e. the rack, hardware, power, networking, so I would imagine that would or at least could be the difference.
- patrickgzill 15y agoGood point, it would in fact make a difference. I read the article, they do say "colocation"; besides which, XO Communications does not rent servers as far as I know. So that seems to point that they were renting the physical space that their servers are in. Would it make a difference if they were just renting a partial rack, or a full rack that goes all the way down to the floor and is enclosed? I don't know ...
- corin_ 15y agoSurely even then the rental contract would specify the equipment they rent, not the space - the data centre could move their rack to a different physical location at any time.
- patrickgzill 15y agoI will tell you that unless something is on fire in my rack, no one from Level3 will even touch anything - and even then they would hit the fire suppression button and leave the room. They do not touch anything in a customer rack. (I have two racks in a local facility owned by Level3). The contract I signed, had a clause that said if they had to move me somewhere else, they would pay all costs of doing so. I don't know how standard a clause this is.
- matthew-wegner 15y agoI've been in a situation where a server was temporarily pulled by feds. They almost certainly just duplicated the drives with legally-sound forensic software.
- cnbeuiwx 15y agoIm surprised nobody is discussing the reason for the pull. Obviously the FBI has copied all the data on the server and are now using a backdoor in the encryption or brute force cracking to get into the information. There is no such thing as safe data once the physical server is confiscated, and people shouldnt trust standard encryption algorithms to be safe from backdoors. Microsoft Windows has had backdoors for a long time I reckon. Some of it are called "bugs" once its discoved and fixed with Windows Updates. Other stuff gets introduced that way as well. Or they could have port knocking techniques built into the closed source kernel to allow people who know the code to enter the computer without any trace.
- corin_ 15y agoIf you were the FBI, and you had a backdoor already built into the software running on that server, would you really confiscate it and take four days to use it rather than leaving it running and hoping nobody notices you came by to activate it, and/or having it be activated over the network?
- protomyth 15y agoI wonder if we've got to the point where it might actually be worth putting a camera into the server case that streams to another site? You really only have to keep under an hour of video.