4 ms·
Another annoyance of "fiction tropes taken for reality" happens in movies and games, where people have become so accustomed to seeing camera flaws that some sta
by Terr_ 3y ago
Another annoyance of "fiction tropes taken for reality" happens in movies and games, where people have become so accustomed to seeing camera flaws that some start to believe the presence of those flaws indicates "realism"... Even when the truth is the exact opposite--unless the player-avatar is supposed to have inferior mechanical eyes.
For example, Depth of field, lens flares, chromatic aberration without wearing glasses, etc.
- thfuran 3y agoDepth of field is a human eyes thing too. Though I'm with you on lens flare and film grain added just as stylistic flourishes rather than to convey "this scene is camera footage". It's like deliberately adding simulated compression artifacts.
- Terr_ 3y ago> Depth of field is a human eyes thing too. Not in in the dumb way games do it: You don't need to turn your entire head to make something come into focus, or aim it with with a gun.
- CrazyStat 3y agoWell, this is a limitation of computers traditionally not having eye tracking. If VR with eye tracking takes off maybe we'll get more realistic depth of field in games.
- bombcar 3y agoApparently one of the issues with VR and “3D movies” is that your eyes expect to be able to focus on anything: but you can’t; only on what the director set everything to focus on.
- strogonoff 3y agoImagine you record audio with perfect fidelity and extreme dynamic range. Now, you have the tiniest and the loudest sounds captured; how do you go about conveying this work? The answer is compression, equalization, all those tricks. And yes, that lowers fidelity, and yes, you will have to make choices as to what’s more important to focus perceptive attention. Similarly with video: many fidelity-lowering tricks serve a purpose. Film grain, aside from conveying a mood, can mask excess detail in shadows and highlights, the detail that would detract from the story you’re telling. A headlight flare can bring attention to the coming car; if your hero or villain is in that car, that’s useful. Panning over a fleeting sun flare, you momentarily focus on the environment and can use it to bridge attention between subjects or scenes. It’s all a complicated dance, and it all exists in time, inseparably from both the immediately preceding material and the larger current cultural context.
- ryandrake 3y ago> Imagine you record audio with perfect fidelity and extreme dynamic range. Now, you have the tiniest and the loudest sounds captured; how do you go about conveying this work? If you're Christopher Nolan, you just release it that way, and let your audience smash the volume-up and volume-down keys over and over throughout the movie.
- strogonoff 3y agoYeah, quite tricky if things happen in quick succession, a pin drops and and explosion follows (if your home audio can even reproduce the requisite decibels).
- strogonoff 3y agoUnless the fidelity of the material (be it visual or audial) exactly matches that of the real world[0], there is no truly accurate depiction of reality you can convey to the observer—and with any lossy representation you have to make choices as to how to represent it. You will have adopted a “look” whether you want it or not; it is very much part of your creative effort (the less of it, the more work and creative choices are left up to the observer to filter). Basing your look on the preexisting and familiar is good because your work does not exist in vacuum; your observers carry common cultural baggage in context of which it is perceived. The look furthers your creative goals—conveys a mood or a feeling, focuses observer’s attention on what you consider important, etc. Here, fidelity works against you. All the figurative flare—be it compressing dynamic range, selecting your color palette, artificially lowering the frame rate, adding motion blur, film grain, lens artifacts and literal flares, etc.—lowers it selectively. That particular kind of flare can absolutely be misplaced, sure. For example, cartoon animation styles is an example of another extreme but quite well-established look, and arguably incompatible (the fidelity is already very selective from the get-go). Less extreme is 3D animation, where lens flare and the like can sometimes look uncanny. The case of dead butterflies, similarly, exists in cultural context. In some (most?) cultures, the symbol of the butterfly would represent something very far from death. However, once the awareness of the difference between a dead and alive butterfly is widespread enough, then one simply must adapt and adopt that new context because you are risking the dead butterfly to be interpreted as an intentional statement. [0] Which is not going to be technically possible for some time, and likely not at all even in theory due to the good old map-territory conflict.
- Terr_ 3y ago> there is no truly accurate depiction of reality A bit of a nirvana fallacy there. This isn't about limitations in technology, nor (directly) about artistic choices to set a mood. What I'm annoyed at is the combination of (A) things which are not technological limitations that are deliberately simulated and (B) how I've seen them tie into factually false beliefs about "realism" among the audience. Consider: "Oh, I got one of those new e-books, and it's about Romeo and Juliet. Some of the text contains ink that is blotted or runny, which makes their relationship extra-realistic."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Anotheroneagain 3y agoSomething similar happens with loudpeakers. Some people got so used to the distorted, boomy bass that was ubiquitous until recently, that they insist that speakers that don't distort have "no bass".