9 ms·
The largest climatized reading space
- lisper 3y agoHow ironic that this is in China where what you are and are not allowed to read is strictly controlled by the government. Indeed, if I posted this comment while in that library, I would very likely be arrested.
- nicolas_t 3y agoIt’s been illuminating seeing the hong kong public library « harmonized » after the national security law. No books criticizing the cpp are allowed nowadays. You won’t find cartoons by Zunzi anymore nor will you find back issues of Apple Daily. The entire political history of hong kong as recorded by published media has been sanitized to ensure that the overly sensitive overlords find nothing that might prick their ego. So it doesn’t matter if the public library is a nice space with good architecture and a comfortable reading space. If only the official sanctioned viewpoints are available then it fails at the real objective of libraries: To allow people to enrich their mind by giving them multiple viewpoints so that they may forge their own opinions.
- sandspar 3y agoOnly the official sanctioned viewpoints are available on all of our current LLM chatbots, and yet we still enjoy them and find use in them.
- dudisubekti 3y agoYou could just bring your own book you downloaded with VPN and read it there. Having a public reading space is always nice
- Aunche 3y agoContrary to popular belief, China does not give a damn about what any random particular individual reads or even writes. It's not exactly an efficient use of resources to jail everyone who says something they find objectionable on the Internet. China's censorship and punishment mostly aims at maintaining the legitimacy of the Communist Party.
- lisper 3y ago> Contrary to popular belief, China does not give a damn about what any random particular individual reads or even writes. Try to get through Chinese immigration wearing a T-shirt that says "Tienanmen Square 1989" or "Free Tibet" and I'll bet you will find that they care quite a lot.
- exitheone 3y agoThe CCP control is strictly about blast radius. Individual citizen in their homes are rarely subject to any enforcement action. Even talking critically on social media in small circles is mostly fine (apart from simple "bad-word" filters that just remove whole messages). The moment you reach a wider audience or "disrupt public harmony", they come down on you.
- hnbad 3y agoYeah but ultimately that is far more dangerous, no? The law enables severe punishments that are applied arbitrarily by those tasked with enforcing it. Knowing there is a clear and reliable line you can't cross allows for opposition movements to take advantage of that line and build within the narrow demarcations. Arbitrary enforcement means you can never know if someone in charge has it out for you that day because you probably already broke laws that could be used against you before coming anywhere near actively participating in political dissent. As the common wisdom goes: Al Capone was not arrested for being a crime boss but for tax evasion. Why bother setting clear boundaries on what behavior is or isn't anti-revolutionary if you can just make sure everyone already violates the law based on technicalities and then just decide who you want to arrest for it as necessary?
- emsixteen 3y agoThis is ironic in the same way that Alanis Morissette's song is. Beautiful space. I'm sure it's a great place to spend some time.
- flanked-evergl 3y ago[flagged]
- paganel 3y agoThere are lots of books that don't get published in ideologically-controlled Western countries anymore. For example trying to write a balanced biography of the military leader that got us (Romania) into WW2 [1] alongside the Germans has become next to impossible, you'd risk breaking several anti-genocide laws. That was not the case before our accession into the NATO and EU ideological structures (the mid-2000s). What's funny is that the one biography of Antonescu [2] that is not entirely about how "he was a very bad genocidaire" has been written by a person of Jewish ethnicity at a very small printing house (almost self-published), I guess the powers that be thought that it would have looked bad were they to go after a Jewish person who had tried to be impartial to Antonescu. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ion_Antonescu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ion_Antonescu [2] https://www.libris.ro/maresalul-ion-antonescu-o-biografie-tesu-TES978-606-95323-5-5--p28595245.html https://www.libris.ro/maresalul-ion-antonescu-o-biografie-te...
- n4r9 3y agoThat's a little vague. Do you have examples of banned biographies, and the reasons given for the bannings?
- paganel 3y agoThe banning happens before anyone gets to publish anything, so, no, I cannot tell you exactly what samizdat copies of Ion Antonescu biographies there are in the wild. What I can link to is stuff like this [1], meaning the US Embassy here in Romania openly and actively calling out several City Halls for still having streets named after Ion Antonescu. > Several cities and towns still named streets after Ion Antonescu, the Romanian dictator from the Second World War, and some local authorities refused to change the name despite requests from the Wiesel Institute. After the Wiesel Institute repeatedly requested, in February, Constanța City Hall to change the name of Ion Antonescu Street, Constanța Mayor Vergil Chițac stated in the press that the evaluations of Antonescu's activity are controversial and contradictory and the City Hall will consider renaming the street after members of academia review the topic (via google translate) Hope that that clears up the "vague" thing. [1] https://ro.usembassy.gov/ro/romania-raportul-international-privind-libertatea-religioasa-in-anul-2021/ https://ro.usembassy.gov/ro/romania-raportul-international-p...
- sandspar 3y agoYou can't read whatever you want in America either, yet we still have bookstores. The Chinese government controls a handful of things very tightly and is laissez-faire about many other things. Also you wouldn't be arrested. Chinese people aren't automatons. They know how to get around silly rules, just like we do.
- hereme888 3y agoWhat? I've never read a law passed by Congress that makes any reading material illegal. Are you referring to the inappropriate sexual books pandered to little children in schools?
- sandspar 3y agoExamples of publication bans might include the government level publication ban on mass shooter manifestos. And the quasi-government Amazon bans of books. America also sees activist-led retractions of scientific studies. More prosaically, non-legitimate possession of classified material is illegal.
- philipkglass 3y agoMore prosaically, non-legitimate possession of classified material is illegal. People who leak classified material can be prosecuted, if discovered, but the press is not bound by classification directives in the United States. It was established in this 1971 court case around the classified Pentagon Papers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Times_Co._v._United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Times_Co._v._United_S...
- cratermoon 3y ago> What? I've never read a law passed by Congress that makes any reading material illegal. That's correct. In the US, we have the First Amendment to prevent government interference, and the genesis of that law goes back to John Milton's Areopagitica. On the flip side, that same document gives private business broad economic freedom, and businesses are not afraid to use their economic power to suppress or bury ideas that threaten their profits.
- l3mure 3y ago> Some of the tentacles of Total Literary Awareness have been unraveled by literary historian Claire Culleton. Delving into the Bureau’s 234-page file on commercial publisher Henry Holt, she uncovers evidence of Hoover’s “custodial relationship” with the pillars of the Cold War book market. > Holt employees sent the Bureau all manner of literary foreknowledge, from book proposals to page proofs to advance copies—so much material that an editorial staffer wrote Hoover with the news that “I am beginning to feel like a member of the FBI myself.” > Predictably, Hoover and his ghostwriters were asked to provide blurbs for The Hidden Russia and other anticommunist titles. Just as often, however, the Bureau was granted uncommon rights of pre-refusal. Holt editor Milt Hill, for example, asked FBI contacts for “advice as to whether we should do or not” a McCarthy autobiography, receiving a green light since it “would be a friendly book from a Bureau standpoint.” > Books less kind to the Bureau were rejected with its help at Holt and other firms. The manuscript of Fred Cook’s muckraking The FBI Nobody Knows, eventually published in 1964, was refused at Random House (home of The FBI Story) after publisher Bennett Cerf shredded professional ethics by forwarding a copy to Hoover. > Editorial informants such as Cerf, recruited in the wake of the Lowenthal embarrassment, made it practically impossible to criticize the FBI through a major New York publisher without costly delay. With the FBI fed the minutes of editorial board meetings at Time and Life, Fortune and Look, the Reader’s Digest and the Daily Worker, points along the full spectrum of U.S. print culture were opened to Bureau pre-awareness. To adapt Louis Nichols, there was now most always a body poised to throw itself between the presses. https://theamericanreader.com/total-literary-awareness-how-the-fbi-pre-read-african-american-writing/ https://theamericanreader.com/total-literary-awareness-how-t... Of course that all stopped after the 70s/80s, right?
- egypturnash 3y ago"Climatized"? Is this a fancy way to say "it has air conditioning" or does it mean "this building is so big it has its own microclimate without any attempt on our part to make this happen"?
- nuthje 3y agoI gather it's a way of saying it's climate controlled, i.e. heated or cooled depending on the season. I suppose as a contrast to calling any semi-random outside space the largest reading space.
- foobarbecue 3y agoNot in the original title, so either it was removed over there or extraneously added over here. Merriam-Webster says that "climatized" means "acclimated" so I don't think it makes sense as used here.
- egypturnash 3y agoNot entirely extraneous; the second paragraph of the page begins with "The library boasts the world’s largest climatized reading space and China’s largest load-bearing glass system[...]"
- Paul-Craft 3y agoI assume you were joking about a building being so large it has its own microclimate, but I have been inside a building that has its own rain clouds. The building housed a styrofoam factory. It was always hot and humid in there, probably due to the manufacturing process itself, but not uniformly so. Certain spots would be extra humid, which would cause water vapor to rise up to the ceiling. There were enough particulates in the air for it to then condense into droplets that looked like clouds, which would then create a very light drizzle 20-50 feet away. I fucking hated that place.
- sandspar 3y agoThe styrofoam wasn't negatively affected by the moisture?
- hereme888 3y agoI started browsing some of snohetta.com's designs... my brain could barely comprehend how astounding and magnificent some of their designs are. Truly amazing stuff.
- dappermanneke 3y agoa space to cultivate community, as long as said community is entirely nonthreatening to the CCP
- perihelions 3y agoWhat are the greatest libraries / reading spaces of the western world today?
- outime 3y agoOodi in Helsinki is a quite interesting concept, although not the best if you want to be in complete silence.
- Paul-Craft 3y agoFunny, I would have thought if anyone valued a quiet space to read without being bothered, it'd be the Finns. Looking at the pics on Wikipedia[0] though, it does look like there are some quieter spaces one can duck into. From what's pictured in the wiki article, it does look more like a tech company office crossed with a community center than a public library to me. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_Central_Library_Oodi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_Central_Library_Oodi
- Gravityloss 3y agoSnohetta's design looks quite similar to Oodi in places, I must say. It's just a lot bigger. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_Central_Library_Oodi#/media/File:Central_Library_Oodi_in_Helsinki_04.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_Central_Library_Oodi#...
- sandspar 3y agoThe British Library, maybe, famous as being the haunt of Karl Marx, as well as of Lenin, Bram Stoker, and Arthur Conan Doyle.
- trompetenaccoun 3y agoThere has been a real boom in building such modern libraries and bookstores all over China in recent years, cities have been competing with each other in building the coolest looking one. They're very popular with the Chinese version of Instagramers. Though I don't seen many people actually using them as libraries in most cases, especially long term once the novelty wears off. Trends come and go fast in China. Very close to BJ, the BinHai Library for example was pretty much empty when I was there last time, apart from people going in to take photos of the admittedly beautiful design. But when most of the upper shelves have fake books in them (I kid you not), it says a lot about how far China's dedication to reading goes. The average Chinese isn't interested in intellectual stuff currently, it's all about making money and reading is basically only for students to get good grades and strike well-paid jobs. Don't get me wrong, there's a lot of cool modern architecture that imo doesn't get enough recognition. It's sadly rarely practical though, it's more built for prestige than anything else. The top down planning has a lot of advantages and there's certainly a lot of bold designs that architects couldn't get approved in any democratic place these days, where there are endless committees ultimately settling for the most plain and boring construction, the lowest common denominator. But these party officials also aren't really thinking about what the people need, what would make cities more livable. It reminds me a bit of Albert Speer's Germania vision. Certainly impressive and cool to look at, but maybe not a place you'd want to live long term.
- graemep 3y agoIt struck me that the article was talking about the building a lot, but very little about the books. Thanks for explaining.
- ThrowawayTestr 3y agoWell yeah it's an architecture website.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoIt's not uncommon in not-china either, public libraries are prestige buildings but it often feels like the purpose of them - books - is lost in favor of the prestige aspect. I mean I'm only seeing a few images actually showing books, and those are only three shelves tall. I'm also seeing high ceilings, literal hills made out of steps but without any apparent function other than maybe crowd photo ops, and some reading tables. But the amount of books is about the same as a small local library or bookstore. What happened to the multi-storey repositories? Endless rows of categorised books? I don't get it.
- TOMDM 3y agoBeautiful building. A large open space with lots of hard materials though, I hope sound isn't an issue. The ceiling looks like it might be sound dampening though?
- flanked-evergl 3y agoI don't think you need sound dampening in China to keep people quiet.
- fsiefken 3y agoI like the stairs, until I wondered how handicapped or elderly people would get tp their sought after books. While I was a regular when I was young, visiting once or twice each week to bring and get as much books as I could carry. I now read less often, and what I read are mostly e-books. I do sometimes sit in VR reading an epub for the ambiance.
- mark_l_watson 3y ago[flagged]
- keiferski 3y agoThis “democracy requires ugly buildings” sentiment seems to be a meme lately, and it’s not one I like very much. It’s also not true - plenty of periods that were arguably more democratic had better planned urban spaces than contemporary ones. The problems with architecture are more due to culture and economics than anything else IMO.
- aspenmayer 3y agoThis line of reasoning (“democracy requires ugly buildings”) came up in Lex Fridman's recent interview of Tucker Carlson[0], and was made in reference to Tucker Carlson's admiration of the city of Moscow, especially its subway stations, which Carlson noted in his coverage of the city in a segment after his recent interview with Putin. I don't really understand the rationale. Starve the beast type posturing leading to defunding of public services leads to poorly performing public services, which just becomes a kind of self-fulfilling prophesy, but for some reason this is surprising to some on the right and used as a kind of post-hoc reasoning or justification for the initial defunding. Perhaps some others can shed some light on how this thought process or logic works from the perspective of someone who is conservative. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f_lRdkH_QoY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f_lRdkH_QoY
- keiferski 3y agoHaving been to a number of cities around the world, I don’t think the issue is funding. Certainly the NYC or SF public transit systems get plenty of funding, much more than say, Poland, which has a very clean metro system in Warsaw. The difference is more attributable to culture and enforcement of laws on littering, graffiti, etc. Somewhere like Tokyo for example doesn’t need an oppressive government to keep the subway clean.
- aredox 3y agoThe both-sides-ism in this comment... The mostly peaceful Jan 6 rioters came in at the very minimum with the intention to overthrow the elected, legal government and ignore the votes of the majority. And some of them came in with the intention to take hostage some, and lynch some.
- nsypteras 3y agoNot sure how comfortable the "climatization" is given that many people in the pictures are wearing winter coats inside. Hopefully it's not sweltering in the summer...
- itishappy 3y agoThere's snow outside...
- dublinben 3y agoThis is an artificial hill covered in artificial trees illuminated by artificial lights, sealed in glass so they can maintain an artificially habitable atmosphere. In other countries, you can just read outside on a real hill, under real trees, in the light of the real sun, breathing in non-polluted air.
- wnc3141 3y agoSnohetta definitely my favorite architecture firms. They strike that balance between having creative ideas and nuanced and functional execution
- angiosperm 3y agoNot so many books there, though, unless they are hidden away underground. I will take the New York Public Library, which has a good reading room with lots of tables, and a very good collection.
- eej71 3y agoI like the space, but I think that's because it loosely resembles a Frank Lloyd Wright space. https://franklloydwright.org/frank-lloyd-wrights-larkin-and-johnson-wax-workspaces/ https://franklloydwright.org/frank-lloyd-wrights-larkin-and-...
- JoshGG 3y agoThat was my first reaction as well. Very much inspired by the wright work. It does look cool! I wonder about noise levels with all the hard surfaces and open space.
- karaterobot 3y agoThis is certainly a cool looking space. I could see myself walking through it with cathedral-like awe. I don't know if I would want to browse the stacks here, being as they are in short cases separated by many stairs. I don't know if I would actually want to read here for any length of time, it seems sterile and echoey, with no privacy. I don't believe there has been any modern architectural innovation which surpasses a cozy nook with a wing-backed chair when it comes to pure reading enjoyment. Keep trying though. I sometimes wonder, as I did with Rem Koolhaas' Seattle Central Library design, whether architects spend a lot of time actually using or working in libraries. I guess the brief isn't "make the best library for patrons" but "make a library which can symbolize the glory of our city and its wealth".