3 ms·
The popularity of Facebook continues to puzzle me. Because its "all following relationships must be mutual" paradigm is SO BROKEN. People end up following a zil
by egypturnash 15y ago
The popularity of Facebook continues to puzzle me. Because its "all following relationships must be mutual" paradigm is SO BROKEN. People end up following a zillion people they don't give a damn about because that's what you have to do if you want to broadcast there.
I really wish Google hadn't driven off half their early adopters of G+ with their shitfit about "real names only" because it actually has asymmetrical following relationships. When anyone can see your public posts, you only have to follow people you care about instead, and the service doesn't have to do these increasingly convoluted hacks to try and only show you things it thinks you "want" to see.
If you're making some kind of social network, please save your future self - and your future users - this kind of hassle. Allow asymmetrical following.
tl;dr: I miss Livejournal.
- MartinCron 15y agoI "fix" this by hiding boring people. It's asymmetrical, but opaquely.
- machrider 15y agoBoth approaches have value. I value Facebook's closed nature, as it gives me a place to communicate with close friends and family. I live across the country from most of my family, but I see their photos and keep up with them all the time, it's great. Also, on G+, I have to put people in a circle if I want to broadcast to them (and not to the entire world), right? So I'm still following people I might not want to be following using the asymmetric approach. The stuff I post on my blog is a totally different kind of communication, and I'm happy to do it outside the context of social networking.
- lomegor 15y agoJust as a FYI, you can share to people outside of your circles, if they have it enabled. Instead of selecting a circle to share, just put their names in. Of course, this depends on the settings of the other person and doesn't disprove anything. Just wanted to tell you in case it's of any use for you.
- loverobots 15y agoConsider this: Child is born in Germany and all the family members across the world see the picture 10 minutes after he is cleaned up by the nurses. Add other family events and you are in touch with everyone. The fact that it is somewhat closed is a major plus for me, I do not want them indexed by Google /Bing and held forever
- fpgeek 15y agoI guess you haven't heard that the ship has sailed on the Bing front: http://www.theverge.com/2012/5/10/3010051/microsoft-new-bing-hands-on http://www.theverge.com/2012/5/10/3010051/microsoft-new-bing...
- mibbitier 15y ago> People end up following a zillion people they don't give a damn about because that's what you have to do if you want to broadcast there. Facebook isn't about broadcasting. Use twitter if you want to broadcast. Facebook is about sharing things with your genuine real friends and family. Asymmetrical following just leads to twitter - lots of celebrity "broadcasters" and lots of silent followers. Rather than real two way conversation.
- citricsquid 15y agoFacebook does, they have subscriptions now. You can allow people to subscribe to you and then they will see your stuff without you seeing theirs (like Twitter). Maybe they don't publicise the feature enough, but as you can see it is quite widely used: http://www.facebook.com/zuck/subscribers http://www.facebook.com/zuck/subscribers