4 ms·

Because this debt is largely meaningless - except as a political tool. All countries have debt to the point that it’s basically a big web. What really matters

Because this debt is largely meaningless - except as a political tool. All countries have debt to the point that it’s basically a big web. What really matters is the trust in the financial system behind the debt. Do other countries believe that the US can take out more debt in good faith? If yes, then this is fine. In individual terms, this is much like having a mortgage. It’s a massive number, much larger than your annual income that you’ll be making payments on for ages. You can still get more debt (credit cards, auto loans, HELOC) because it’s expected that you’ll have a certain amount of debt. Your debt only becomes a problem when you show that you can’t pay it.

dnissley 3y ago
If that's the case doesn't it still make sense to try and reduce debt? Due to unforeseen circumstances? Going by your metaphor we could say the possibility of the industry you work in becoming a lot less lucrative due to technological advances, or macroeconomic changes like jobs going overseas -- this isn't an abstract threat! It's happened before and will happen again!
- SkyPuncher 3y ago
  Yes and no. I'm getting into opinion territory now. Largely, the USA is such a dominate world power that it running into trouble on its debt would mean global repercussions. That unforeseen circumstance would have rippling effect around the world. At which point, it wouldn't really matter if the USA was affected. Everybody else would be affected too.
  - dnissley 3y ago
    Yep, totally get that possibility. We've seen it with the 08 financial crisis, COVID (esp. wrt money printing), and even down to more mundane things like nimbyism + pension underfunding (traps that many/most other developed nations have fallen into). Still it makes me squeamish and makes me want to point out that just because we can't conceive of a threat unique to our particular position doesn't mean that one doesn't exist! But a lot of what drives me to think that is almost certainly just my own risk intolerant disposition, which again comes down to opinion.

dnissley 3y ago

If that's the case doesn't it still make sense to try and reduce debt? Due to unforeseen circumstances? Going by your metaphor we could say the possibility of the industry you work in becoming a lot less lucrative due to technological advances, or macroeconomic changes like jobs going overseas -- this isn't an abstract threat! It's happened before and will happen again!

SkyPuncher 3y ago
Yes and no. I'm getting into opinion territory now. Largely, the USA is such a dominate world power that it running into trouble on its debt would mean global repercussions. That unforeseen circumstance would have rippling effect around the world. At which point, it wouldn't really matter if the USA was affected. Everybody else would be affected too.
- dnissley 3y ago
  Yep, totally get that possibility. We've seen it with the 08 financial crisis, COVID (esp. wrt money printing), and even down to more mundane things like nimbyism + pension underfunding (traps that many/most other developed nations have fallen into). Still it makes me squeamish and makes me want to point out that just because we can't conceive of a threat unique to our particular position doesn't mean that one doesn't exist! But a lot of what drives me to think that is almost certainly just my own risk intolerant disposition, which again comes down to opinion.